President Donald Trump has nicknames for several aides; his moniker for the architect of his midterm strategy — Brilliant James — sometimes comes with an edge.
James Blair has encyclopedic knowledge of voting minutiae, historical election trends and congressional maps. He’s won Trump’s confidence by delivering information to the president matter-of-factly. But as Trump’s tone sometimes suggests, smart people can sometimes outsmart themselves.
What happens to Republicans on Tuesday depends on which meaning of “brilliant” applies this time. Will Blair’s strategic moves, including an unprecedented nationwide round of mid-decade redistricting, allow the party in power to defy history and hang on to control of Congress, or at least mitigate its losses? Or did it consume time and political energy for minimal gain? Did putting Trump at the center of the Republican campaign with multiple rallies in red states succeed in mobilizing his voters? Or did it backfire by motivating the opposition?
Hanging over all those questions is the one that could shape the future for the bald, intense, 37-year-old Republican operative: If Republicans lose big next week, will he be the one Trump sets up to take the blame?
This account is based on interviews with a dozen close Trump advisers, current and former White House aides and people familiar with Blair’s work on Capitol Hill.
Strategy, voter turnout, attack ads and disbursing the $400 million war chest of Trump’s super PAC all fall into Blair’s purview as the leader of MAGA Inc., the president’s main outside group. Blair has devoted himself full-time since this spring to guiding Republicans through the midterm elections after first serving as a White House deputy chief of staff.
It’s a huge amount of pressure for an operative relatively new to Washington. As a Florida native, Blair was originally brought into the Trump orbit by Susie Wiles, the president’s chief of staff whose own Trumpian nickname is the “Ice Maiden.”
“James has a capacity to maintain an enormous amount of attention to detail. Right now, he is running multistate, multi-campaign expenditures, teams of pollsters, mailers and digital vendors,” said Chris LaCivita, who co-ran Trump’s 2024 campaign with Wiles and continues to advise the president. “The only way I could do something on that level of detail is if I took a whole bottle of Adderall.”
Typically, the party that controls the White House loses congressional seats in a midterm election. It’s a fact of life in politics.
“The president always loses, for whatever reason, midterms. Whoever it is. Republican, Democrat. Great president, lousy president,” Trump said recently at the White House, repeating a sentiment he has been voicing for months.
Trump lost the House to Democrats in 2018 and then faced impeachment. The polling is even worse for Republicans this year, with Trump’s approval rating hitting some of the lowest levels ever recorded and voters anxious about high prices, the war in Iran and the mass deportations and arrests of immigrants by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Blair’s strategy to defy the odds aimed to take advantage of Trump’s singular dominance of the party and turn the GOP into a unified political machine that shares data, polling and spending decisions. Everyone — the president’s super PAC, the congressional fundraising committees, outside groups, megadonors like Elon Musk and sympathetic industry groups, including AI and crypto — would operate in something close to lockstep.
That put Blair at the center of every strategic decision in this fall’s campaign. It also has him the natural target of complaints from White House rivals, Republican lawmakers and individual campaigns.
Friends and allies say his style is to try out aggressive and even seemingly outlandish ideas to win. He correctly anticipated Supreme Court rulings that gutted key parts of the Voting Rights Act and opened the way for political groups to coordinate more closely on spending and planned accordingly, according to people familiar with his decisions.
“Your goal is to provide your side as many tactical advantages as possible, so as long as it is legal, you find those tactical advantages and you implement them,” LaCivita added. “Anything less is a half strategy and half-ass tactician.”
One of the first overt steps was to enlist Republicans in a redistricting war designed to create a more favorable map, an effort that Blair’s critics dubbed “Blairymandering.”
Pulling off a mid-decade gerrymander involved heavily lobbying Republican state lawmakers in Indiana to redraw their maps last winter and spring. When some balked and defied Blair’s insistent phone calls, he got Trump to endorse primary challengers to unseat several of them — pouring time, energy and millions of dollars into typically sleepy state elections to a degree that is rare for a White House, or a president’s top political adviser.
Critics say this mini-revenge tour took energy away from other contests, and at the local level, it was not uniformly popular.
“It was really obvious to most people here in the state that the support and pressure for this redistricting was coming from out of state. It felt very manufactured,” said Julia Vaughn, executive director of Common Cause Indiana who helped to lead a coalition of more than 20 groups to fight back against the redistricting. “The thing about Hoosiers is that they don’t take to that. It was like forcing something down our throats.”
The effort was typical of Blair’s approach, which admirers call persistent and detractors label as bullying.
“It’s easy for people to see him and think he is a tough guy, or he is a bully. If he tells you he is going to do something, he will do it, and if you say no, he will go right past you. Look at who he works for. By the way, the president doesn’t wait for anybody. He goes and does,” said Tony Fabrizio, the president’s longtime pollster.
At one point, Blair boasted that redistricting in Texas, Florida, North Carolina and other Republican-controlled states would net the party a double-digit haul of additional seats. Today, it’s unclear if the nationwide experiment will yield more than three or four.
Democrats fought back by redistricting California. And with Trump’s declining popularity, Republicans are fighting to keep House seats in conservative areas of Florida, including one newly redrawn district that extends from Palm Beach Country to the Miami area. Redrawn districts in Texas also appear vulnerable.
Most election analysts predict Republicans will lose the House; it’s just unclear by how large a margin.
But the Trump team remains convinced redistricting was the correct choice, even if the president has questioned it at times.
“Redistricting creates new battlefields. You can’t create the outcomes,” says one Trump political adviser, who argues the redistricting will also help Republicans in 2028 and 2030.
Blair started his politics career in Florida after growing up in a Southern Baptist, middle-class family and graduating from Florida State University. In his 20s, he worked for a powerful state legislator in Tallahassee, where he was often spotted in the office wearing massive headphones and poring over data on his computer screen.
He went on to help Ron DeSantis run a successful campaign for governor of Florida in 2018, in which DeSantis started as the underdog, underfunded candidate. There he worked with Wiles, who ran the DeSantis campaign. By 2020, he was helping Wiles run Trump’s efforts to win the state.
After Trump regained the presidency and Wiles became chief of staff, Blair moved to the White House.
Empowered by Wiles, he oversaw the political and legislative teams. Much to the chagrin of some other White House aides, he also inserted himself into the policy debates of the day and even flew on Air Force One on the president’s trip to China.
Friends and critics alike describe Blair as brash. One ally says Blair is quick to try to control any room he’s in, a move that shows off his smarts, but can give the impression he’s overconfident.
On Capitol Hill, he gained a reputation for lecturing lawmakers, who were more accustomed to deference, even obsequiousness, from unelected staff. He was known for explaining legislative processes to many of them.
Lawmakers and staff say — but only in private — that he used more sticks than carrots to ensure support for the president’s sweeping agenda on taxes, trade, health care and the war in Iran. Those votes have become liabilities for some lawmakers as they seek reelection.
The relationship between the White House and Capitol Hill, especially the Senate, has been fraught over the past two years. Sen. Thom Tillis of North Carolina announced his retirement once it became clear he would not vote in favor of the president’s sweeping tax bill. Sens. John Cornyn of Texas and Bill Cassidy of Louisiana lost tough primaries against Trump-backed candidates, turning them into lame-duck politicians free to criticize the Trump agenda.
Critics see these as unforced errors on the part of the Trump political team, who pushed lawmakers too far and then punished those seen as disloyal. Blair’s defenders say he is simply carrying out the president’s wishes.
Blair now lives in the D.C. area with his four young children and his wife, a former political fundraiser in Tallahassee and ex-Tampa Bay Buccaneers cheerleader.
If the GOP holds on to the Senate, even narrowly, then Republicans likely will declare victory even if they lose the House; they will have kept the chamber that confirms judges and Cabinet jobs. Operatives and donors have long viewed the Senate as a bulwark against a Democratic agenda.
But if Republicans lose both chambers, it will be harder for anyone in the president’s orbit to make excuses.
One Trump adviser says whenever he brings up Blair’s future, Blair tells him he can’t think past Tuesday. Blair will watch what unfolds while remembering both friend and foe, according to those who know him.
“He is the best of friends, and he is the worst of enemies,” says Brad Herold, one of Blair’s good friends, who worked alongside him in Florida politics. “He will never let me live down times I’ve worked against him in races. I respect that.”
The post Brash architect of Trump’s midterm strategy could become midterm scapegoat appeared first on Washington Post.
