The first Trump administration tried, unsuccessfully, to eliminate a major grant program that funds public transit infrastructure around the country. Nearly two years into a second term, transit officials and advocates fear the administration is squeezing the program instead.
Since returning to office, the administration has awarded just one grant from the multibillion-dollar program, called Capital Investment Grants, which helps local communities build costly rail and bus projects that expand transit service. The White House budget office has pushed more than $5 billion in funds appropriated by Congress for the program into fiscal year 2028, locking away money that could be spent today.
And in a proposal released this fall, the administration wants to significantly overhaul the program’s rules in ways that could make it harder for communities to secure grants and, ultimately, to take on complex construction projects they can’t afford on their own.
The Federal Transit Administration says it wants to streamline the program and improve accountability for communities that sometimes seek hundreds of millions in taxpayer funds. The Department of Transportation, which includes the transit administration, said in a statement it was moving to deliver transit improvements on time and on budget.
“That means setting strict deadlines and demanding real local accountability up front so we can finally build these systems faster, better and safer,” the agency said Friday. “Moving forward, the federal government is focusing on smart, affordable projects with high ridership. If you want federal funding, your project needs to align with where communities and families are actually growing.”
Transit infrastructure costs in the United States have soared, raising questions about how to build projects more efficiently. But transit advocates note that by delaying grants to ready projects, the administration is driving up their costs amid inflation, not reducing them.
Transit agencies and local governments, who have filled the public comment docket in opposition to the new rules, say the changes would make the grants unattainable for many and pull the rug out from under communities that have spent years pursuing funds.
“Because of the large number of disruptive and unsound elements of the proposed policy guidance, we must consider if F.T.A.’s intent is to undermine the C.I.G. program and discourage future applicants,” wrote the top Democrats on committees overseeing the program and its funding, the senators Elizabeth Warren and Patty Murray and Representative Rick Larsen, in a letter to the F.T.A. and White House budget director this week.
Their letter noted that major rail projects in Boston and Los Angeles have been waiting a year to advance into the final stage of the program. In response to questions from The New York Times, the administration said Friday evening that it had approved the Boston project to advance closer to an award, with a maximum potential grant of more than $2 billion.
Over decades, this federal program has helped fund rail networks in Seattle, Los Angeles and Phoenix, as well as modern bus service in midsize cities like Albuquerque, Raleigh, N.C., and Grand Rapids, Mich. Transit agencies and local governments typically spend years in the program’s pipeline developing plans and trying to prove their value. The grants then cover a portion of any project, with communities also piecing together local taxes, bonds or state funds.
The Federal Transit Administration wants the changes to apply immediately to dozens of projects in the program’s pipeline. Some began the process a decade ago.
The new proposed rules would adjust in numerous ways how the program scores projects and then determines their funding.
“It’s just systematically designed to make it so projects look substantially worse, and then are judged on that worse score,” said Yonah Freemark, a researcher at the Urban Institute.
The rules would make cost effectiveness more important, while tightening what counts as a good cost effectiveness score. The outside funding that large projects must secure midway through the process would go up. A measure of the strength of an agency’s financial plans would be rounded down (defying “generally accepted mathematical standards,” as one agency put it).
The agency would “weaponize” the new ratings to drive down funding, Sound Transit in metropolitan Seattle wrote in its public comment. The system would effectively “dismantle the current project pipeline,” transit advocates in Virginia wrote. Other industry officials warned the changes would particularly penalize rail projects, which are inherently more expensive.
Another change in the rules that has perplexed transit officials would give a funding boost to projects in communities with higher-than-average birth and marriage rates, a priority of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. That proposal is unrelated to the goals of public transit and unworkable in practice, local officials say. Census data measuring marriage and birthrates in corridors within a mile of transit infrastructure, they said, could be prone to error.
Dozens of people wrote to the agency mocking the idea or labeling it social engineering. One said: “‘Honey, let’s get married and have two kids! Because our town’s transit agency depends on married couples having babies for its capital budget!’ Said no one ever.”
Put it all together, and advocates fear the administration has delayed awarding grants for nearly two years while it wrote new rules that would render many waiting projects ineligible.
“You reach a pretty logical conclusion that this administration is trying to eliminate funding provided by Congress for transit projects,” said Steve Davis, director of the advocacy group Transportation for America. “And who’s going to suffer? Americans in cities of all sizes just trying to catch the bus to work.”
The Federal Transit Administration has not publicly released its own preliminary analysis of how the changes would affect the projects now in the program’s pipeline.
The American Public Transportation Association warns that many of them would no longer qualify for funding. And those that do could receive smaller grants, potentially forcing them to abandon projects where they can’t replace that funding. Either outcome would waste millions of dollars and years of time, local agencies said.
“APTA has met with dozens of project sponsors who believe the proposed guidance will threaten” their plans, said Ward McCarragher, the association’s vice president for government affairs and advocacy. The group supports simplifying the program, and it welcomed changes in the guidance that would give agencies more flexibility to tap other federal funds while they pursue these grants. But those benefits were swamped by the changes transit agencies have opposed. And some changes, Mr. McCarragher said, would violate the law authorizing the program.
Republican appropriators in Congress have signaled their unease, too. In releasing a draft transportation appropriations bill this week, Senate Republicans proposed language urging the F.T.A. not to delay grants and directing it not to apply the new guidance to projects that have already been rated under the current rules.
As Congress debates the spending bill and as the new guidance moves forward, transit projects stalled in the pipeline continue to wait. That includes smaller bus rapid transit projects in Chapel Hill, N.C., and Montgomery County, Md., which had been expected to receive grants this summer.
“Changing the rules in the middle of the game is not the action of a trusted partner in advancing the development of vital public transit investments,” wrote Dow Constantine, the C.E.O. of Sound Transit.
Rachel Buigas-Lopez contributed graphics and production.
The post A New Trump Tactic to Restrict Transit Funding: Rewrite the Rules appeared first on New York Times.




