Young adults are having a harder time coping with uncertainty than in decades past, according to a meta-analysis published on Wednesday in JAMA Psychiatry. Researchers say it may help explain the rise in anxiety among this age group.
The study found that people reported feeling more intolerant of uncertainty over time, meaning that they had difficulty enduring unpredictable or ambiguous situations. The steepest increase occurred from 2012 onward, starting right around the time that smartphones became ubiquitous, allowing for continuous consumption of information during uncertain times.
Previous research has shown that intolerance of uncertainty is linked to a variety of anxiety disorders. It fuels “worry cycles” that make not knowing feel like a threat, said Katherine M. Keyes, a professor of epidemiology at the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and an author of the study.
She hypothesized that the greater levels of intolerance of uncertainty could be contributing to the increase in anxiety disorders among young people, especially in the current climate, where people are facing “increasing political polarization, economic uncertainty, political uncertainty and the rise of information technology.”
The rate of anxiety disorders was relatively steady through the 1990s and into the early aughts. But in more recent years, symptoms of anxiety have been on the rise, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and are more common among younger adults than older ones.
Jean Twenge, a professor of psychology at San Diego State University and the author of “10 Rules for Raising Kids in a High-Tech World,” suggested that the increasing discomfort with uncertainty might stem from declines in rituals of teenage independence, like getting a driver’s license, having a paid job or going out with friends.
“It’s also possible parents have become less tolerant of uncertainty,” said Dr. Twenge, who was not involved in the study.
In addition, if social media and smartphones lure kids into staying home rather than going out with friends, in-person interaction and independence can seem even scarier.
“Constant internet access also means that questions can always be answered right away,” she said. “Gen Z and Gen Alpha have never known the world of uncertainty previous generations lived with when they might have to just guess, or just show up and hope it works out.”
The meta-analysis, which analyzed 132 studies with more than 35,000 participants, is not generalizable to all adults because it looked only at college students in the United States and Canada. But other research has shown that uncertainty has become baked into the everyday life of many Americans. In this year’s Stress in America survey, conducted by the Harris Poll on behalf of the American Psychological Association, 68 percent of respondents said they had become accustomed to living with uncertainty.
The survey also found that, over the past year, uncertainty was one of the factors driving adults to put their futures on hold, in some cases delaying major life decisions such as purchasing a home or having a child. This was especially true among younger adults. One-third of those ages 18 to 45 reported delaying planning for the future, compared with 24 percent of adults ages 46-61 and 13 percent of those 62-80.
Participants in the A.P.A. study also listed their top stressors, many of which related to cost of living or the future of the nation.
“Big sources of uncertainty that we don’t have control over are particularly challenging,” said Lynn Bufka, a clinical psychologist and spokeswoman for the American Psychological Association. “One of the things that we try to help people think about is where are the places you do have some control, where you can assert something.”
When treating anxiety, mental health providers often focus on helping their patients tolerate uncertainty, said Dr. Bufka, who sometimes suggests that her clients put their worries into an imaginary box and check in on them once a day.
Kalya Castillo, a clinical psychologist in New York City, said she sometimes asked clients to write down affirming statements like “I have been here before, I have experience in managing uncertainty” on their phones or on the fridge. Then they can revisit those messages if they are feeling distressed.
She also helps them tolerate uncertainty by practicing radical acceptance, a concept that calls for accepting reality without fighting or avoiding it, with the faith that you’ll be able to adapt and move forward.
“Accepting reality does not have to mean we have to like it or agree with it,” Dr. Castillo said. “It means we are choosing to preserve our energy for factors within our control.”
The post It’s Getting Harder for Young Adults to Deal With Uncertainty appeared first on New York Times.




