DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

He Was in Charge of Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ Case. Until He Wasn’t.

November 22, 2026
in News
He Was in Charge of Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ Case. Until He Wasn’t.

It was around 4:30 p.m. on Oct. 1 when an acquaintance told Matthew Van Houten that someone from Gov. Kathy Hochul’s office was looking for his phone number. Was it OK to share it, the person asked. He said yes.

By 6 p.m., the governor hadn’t called and Mr. Van Houten, a district attorney in upstate New York, was getting ready to be questioned by local lawmakers about how he had handled a woman’s allegation that she had been sexually assaulted at a Cornell University fraternity house two years ago. At the time, Mr. Van Houten had decided not to bring charges.

That decision went mostly unnoticed outside of Cornell’s home in Ithaca, N.Y., until September, when the woman, known as Jane Doe, sued the school, her sorority, the fraternity and seven men. Now the whole country was paying attention.

As Mr. Van Houten fielded the lawmakers’ questions, he received a phone call — then a text when he didn’t answer — from someone in the governor’s office. He texted back, he recalled, saying that he couldn’t talk at the moment but would call after his meeting with the Tompkins County Legislature.

He didn’t need to. At 7:57 p.m., Mr. Van Houten received a text reply: The governor was going to announce that the state attorney general’s office was taking over the investigation of the woman’s allegation. About 10 minutes later, Ms. Hochul posted on X that she had “lost faith” in Mr. Van Houten and was removing him from the case.

The chair of the Legislature read the governor’s post aloud.

Sitting behind a large wooden desk in his office at the Tompkins County courthouse last month, Mr. Van Houten reflected on what he said was one of the most difficult months of his life.

For many, this case has formed their opinion of him. Some have demanded he resign.

“I’m not going to resign,” he said.

‘A Lot of Distrust’

Nestled in the Finger Lakes region of upstate New York, Tompkins County is home to about 105,000 people.

Like many district attorneys in small and rural counties across the country, Mr. Van Houten personally prosecutes cases. His office, which has eight other attorneys, gets between 1,600 and 2,000 cases a year. Mr. Van Houten said he handles about 80 of them himself.

In 2024 came the case of Jane Doe. That November, about three weeks after the night at the fraternity house, the woman reported her accusations of sexual assault and coerced drug use at Chi Phi to the Cornell University Police Department. On Nov. 25, an investigator who took a statement from her filed a document reporting that the district attorney’s office reviewed her statement and determined that “criminal charges would not be pursued.”

But with the woman’s lawsuit this year came public pressure to reopen the investigation. As the criticism mounted, Mr. Van Houten appeared on national television and released a nine-page statement that said the evidence had not supported bringing charges.

The statement, said Anna Kelles, a Democratic state assemblywoman whose district covers Tompkins, “landed, I think, very differently than maybe he was hoping it would land for people.”

Ms. Kelles said she heard from several women who felt that Mr. Van Houten’s statement was too focused on justifying his actions. The move troubled many of her constituents who had survived sexual assaults, she said, including herself.

For days, Mr. Van Houten insisted to reporters that he made the right decision but said he would reopen the investigation. Then Ms. Hochul removed him from the case.

In the weeks that followed, a bag of feces was mailed to his home. Emails and calls threatening him and his staff came in droves. Then, there were the messages telling him someone should assault his daughter. Those threats shook him so badly he removed her photos from his office so her image would not be visible when he was being interviewed on television.

The County Legislature ordered a review of how his office handles reports of sexual assault.

Mr. Van Houten said his office is contending with “a lot of distrust” based on a single case.

“The body of work that we have established over 10 years should not be judged on the social media evaluation of this case,” he said.

A Learning Moment

Mr. Van Houten has spent most of his life in and around Tompkins County. He was raised in a neighboring county and graduated from a high school in Tompkins. He attended the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, served in the Army and graduated from Albany Law School in 1995.

He returned home to enter private practice for about 17 years, and became the chief executive of USA Team Handball, a sport he played at West Point, in 2012.

After briefly moving to Colorado, Mr. Van Houten returned to Tompkins County around 2014 and resumed his work as a defense lawyer and in family court. Two years later, he won the office of the county’s top prosecutor in an uncontested general election after a heated Democratic primary. He took the helm in January 2017.

Now in his third term in a county where Democrats outnumber Republicans by about three to one, Mr. Van Houten said he has focused on reducing the number of cases that end up in court. “I think it’s better to help somebody than to incarcerate them,” he said.

He checks the county’s jail population weekly, if not daily, he said, “to make sure that nobody’s in the jail who shouldn’t be there.” He was on the committee that launched the county’s mental health court.

He became known in the region, and across the state, as a more progressive prosecutor, according to several local lawmakers. But his first term was also marked by controversy.

One early morning in April 2019, as people spilled from bars into a public square known as the Ithaca Commons, an argument erupted, resulting in a fight. It ended when the police arrested two Black people — a man and a woman — and charged them with disorderly conduct, among other crimes.

There were protests and calls for the charges to be dropped. Mr. Van Houten’s office took the man to trial, where he was acquitted, and a judge eventually dismissed the charges against the woman. (A federal lawsuit stemming from the incident was dismissed.)

For Mr. Van Houten, the episode was a learning moment, he said.

“There are a lot of people trying to tell me how the case should be handled,” he said. “And I would still listen to people, but I need to stick with my gut more.”

‘We Did Believe Her’

On Sept. 28, overwhelmed by media requests with no one on staff to handle them, Mr. Van Houten released his statement on the Cornell case, including portions of the woman’s statement to the police.

“I wanted people to understand the process we went through and the law that we applied,” Mr. Van Houten said. “That we did believe her. We weren’t trying to victim blame her or bash her.”

But to Irene Weiser, a county legislator, one of the most glaring problems in the case was that Mr. Van Houten said his office did not communicate directly with the woman before deciding not to pursue charges.

Mr. Van Houten said he is now requiring his assistant district attorneys to ask to meet with each person who reports a sexual assault, though he said meeting with Jane Doe would not have changed his decision at that time. But it might have put his office in a better position to respond to the criticism now, he said.

The county is also instituting changes. The sheriff’s department unveiled a proposal last month to create a new Special Victims Unit staffed with deputies and an assistant district attorney. The plan, which is also spearheaded by some lawmakers, is one Mr. Van Houten said he supports and has already been proposed to the governor.

But the decisions that he made in 2024 were not flippant ones, Mr. Van Houten said in an interview.

“They were not decisions that were made without a thoughtful analysis of the law,” he said. “So that’s the comfort I have.”

Kitty Bennett contributed research.

The post He Was in Charge of Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ Case. Until He Wasn’t. appeared first on New York Times.

Missing 19-year-old Marine found dead after weeks-long search in Southern California
News

Missing 19-year-old Marine found dead after weeks-long search in Southern California

by Los Angeles Times
November 22, 2026

A family’s desperate weeks-long search for a 19-year-old missing Marine ended in tragedy Friday, after authorities found him dead in ...

Read more
News

A Father Who Crusaded Against Steroids in Sports Has Died

November 22, 2026
News

Noah Schnapp Reveals He Auditioned for Haymitch in ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’

November 22, 2026
News

Dozens of rare striking snakes unleashed into the wild in California — with more on the way

November 22, 2026
News

A Landmark Genocide Ruling

November 22, 2026
Melania Trump Goon Marc Beckman Makes Shocking Admission on Vladimir Putin Russia Ukraine Talks

Melania Trump Goon Marc Beckman Makes Shocking Admission on Vladimir Putin Russia Ukraine Talks

November 22, 2026
He Was in Charge of Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ Case. Until He Wasn’t.

He Was in Charge of Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ Case. Until He Wasn’t.

November 22, 2026
Ukrainian city moves to remote learning as Russian strikes disrupt utilities

Ukrainian city moves to remote learning as Russian strikes disrupt utilities

November 22, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026