Her rise to fame brought joy to the internet. Now, the death of Fiona the hippopotamus is igniting another specialty of the online multitudes: rage, with a dose of vigilantism.
In the hours after the Cincinnati Zoo announced that Fiona had not survived ingesting a child’s knit hat, social media commenters activated.
They have called for investigations to be conducted, video footage to be released and, most of all, for the parents of the child whose hat ended up in the enclosure to be punished. Some want them fined or sent to prison, even as others urge equanimity.
“It’s the worst thing we do as a society online, just pile on, without all the information, and with all the judgment,” said Joy Bennett, a City Council member in nearby Mason, Ohio, who joined in the fray on Facebook.
“We want reasons, culprits, and consequences so life doesn’t feel so out of control,” Ms. Bennett wrote. “But I don’t think it’s OK to attack a total stranger for something that any of us could have been part of.”
Yet the firestorm has only gathered momentum as Fiona fans around the world try to piece together the events that led to her death.
The zoo has shared that about two weeks ago, a child visiting the exhibit tossed a hat into the air. The hat was caught by a ceiling fan and sent through a one-foot gap above the 12-foot-tall viewing window, and it landed in Fiona’s holding tank.
Hippos are considered extremely dangerous animals; the zoo adheres to an industry standard called protected contact, which means zoo staff will not enter the enclosures of some animals when they are present.
At first, it was not clear when the zoo staff was notified about the hat mishap, leaving online sleuths to question if anything could have been done for Fiona sooner.
But on Friday, Michelle Curley, a spokeswoman for the zoo, told The New York Times that caretakers were alerted the same day the hat landed in the enclosure, by a guest who saw what happened. She did not comment on the calls for consequences for the family that owned the hat.
“This was an accident,” she said.
A spokeswoman for the Hamilton County prosecuting attorney declined to comment.
Kimberly Legocki, a University of San Francisco professor who studies online backlash, said that whenever the details of a tragedy are unclear, internet vigilantes tend to swoop in. She has seen many online comments by people claiming, without evidence, that they knew the age of the child and the name of the mother involved.
“Right now, there’s a gap in knowledge,” Ms. Legocki said. “What happens in these cases is that they start filling in that gap.”
On Friday, as the United States Senate adopted a resolution honoring Fiona with rare speed and unanimity, the zoo’s communications focused on the necropsy of the hippo. It revealed that the hat was lodged in the middle of her small intestine, making it impossible to reach by any medical intervention.
Craig Hoover, an executive vice president at the Association of Aquariums and Zoos, of which the Cincinnati Zoo is a member, said that the criticism floating around the internet in the wake of Fiona’s death was “unfortunate and regrettable.”
“There will be time for assessing what, if anything, we might learn from this, but right now I think the focus should really be on providing support” to the zoo, Mr. Hoover said.
The Cincinnati Zoo was also home to Harambe, a gorilla who had to be killed in order to rescue a 4-year-old boy who fell into the animal’s enclosure in 2016. The boy was hurt, but not severely. Online commenters were quick to draw a comparison between the two incidents, but Mr. Hoover warned against drawing conclusions about the zoo, saying it has been accredited since 1978 and remains, “by all accounts, a world-class zoological facility.”
Jesse Lee, a veterinarian in Columbus, was thinking about the high rates of suicide in her profession when she crafted a long Facebook response to the anger she was seeing directed at both the zoo and the parents of the child who threw the hat.
“Trying to raise children in this time of bullying, trying to practice veterinary medicine in this time of bullying — I don’t know how we as a society check ourselves so we can exhibit more empathy,” she said.
At the zoo on Friday, a statue of Fiona was covered in flowers, stuffed animals and two of her favorite foods: watermelons and pumpkins. The typically bustling sidewalk, adorned with faux hippo footprints, was empty. A barrier kept onlookers away from Hippo Cove, which remained closed. Outside the zoo, a 5-year-old boy explored, watched closely by his mother, Heather Willins.
She said she felt for the parents involved but also for the people expressing their rage online.
“We will never feel closure,” Ms. Willins said. “Blaming others is part of the grieving process.”
The post Fiona the Hippo Died After Eating a Hat. Some Want Justice. appeared first on New York Times.




