A federal judge ruled on Friday that Oscar Belgal, the Dominican man shot by a federal immigration officer in New York last month, must remain in detention while the Trump administration moves to deport him.
Mr. Belgal, who was 28 at the time of the shooting, was wounded on Oct. 8, when Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers apprehended him while he was in a car with his 5-year-old son, renewing national scrutiny of the tactics used by ICE.
Mr. Belgal’s lawyers sued the federal government for his release on Oct. 14, arguing that his arrest was unlawful because ICE did not have a proper warrant. His lawyers had said that he was being held in solitary confinement in a federal jail in Brooklyn as a bullet remained lodged in his body.
The Department of Homeland Security, the parent agency of ICE, had opposed his release from the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, arguing that Mr. Belgal had entered the United States illegally and had been lawfully detained.
On Friday, Judge Hector Gonzalez sided with the Trump administration after a five-week legal battle in Federal District Court in Brooklyn.
Mr. Belgal, whose shooting ignited a clash between the White House and Democratic leaders in New York, will remain detained while ICE pursues his deportation in immigration court. The judge said Mr. Belgal still had a right to request a bond hearing before an immigration judge.
It is unclear if Mr. Belgal’s lawyers from the Legal Aid Society will appeal the judge’s ruling.
Neither the Legal Aid Society nor the Department of Homeland Security responded immediately to requests for comment.
The ICE agent’s shooting of Mr. Belgal was the latest among more than two dozen involving immigration officers across the United States since President Trump took office in 2025. Critics have denounced the agency’s use of deadly force as reckless and aggressive.
Critical details of Mr. Belgal’s shooting, which is being investigated in separate inquiries by the Department of Homeland Security and the Bronx district attorney, remain unclear.
The New York Police Department has released footage capturing the moments before and after the shooting, but video showing the shooting itself has not surfaced.
Markwayne Mullin, the homeland security secretary, has said that there is ICE body camera footage of the incident, but the agency has not released any. It appears that not all ICE officers were wearing body cameras, according to videos taken by bystanders and those released by the Police Department.
Mr. Belgal’s lawyers argued in court that the agency’s use of deadly force — one officer fired at least seven shots at Mr. Belgal’s vehicle, according to police officials — was unlawful.
His lawyers said that the ICE officers, who were in plain clothes, never identified themselves when they ran up to Mr. Belgal’s car while it was parked in Marble Hill, a neighborhood that is physically in the Bronx but legally part of Manhattan. One agent had drawn his gun.
Federal officials said that at least one ICE officer, fearing for the safety of his team, shot multiple rounds at Mr. Belgal after he drove into two vehicles belonging to the agency and tried to run over an ICE officer. His lawyers said that Mr. Belgal drove away because he feared for his life and his son’s life.
Mr. Belgal was struck in the left side of his neck and taken to a hospital by New York City police officers before he was placed in ICE detention. His son was unharmed.
His lawyers’ main argument in court pivoted on a technical issue.
They argued that ICE had not initiated deportation proceedings against Mr. Belgal before issuing an arrest warrant, running afoul of federal regulations that govern how ICE is supposed to take noncitizens into custody.
“Compounding the egregiousness of its actions,” his lawyers wrote in court filings on Oct. 27, “ICE did not even possess the statutory, regulatory or constitutional authority to make a civil arrest of Oscar, having not initiated any removal proceedings against him until the following day.”
They also challenged the authenticity of the two arrest warrants that ICE submitted in court, noting that they had not been time stamped and that judges in other cases had found that ICE fabricated warrants to cover up illegal arrests.
The Trump administration argued in court that the warrants were valid and lawful.
Mr. Belgal, a father of two, crossed the U.S.-Mexico border illegally in late 2022 after leaving the Dominican Republic because of economic reasons, according to acquaintances who spoke to The New York Times. In New York, he struggled to find his footing and was arrested twice.
In 2023, he was accused of robbing two acquaintances in the Bronx with the help of an armed accomplice. He pleaded guilty to grand larceny in the fourth degree and was given five years of probation.
Two years later, he was accused of drug dealing after the police said he sold bags of cocaine — and a bag of heroin and fentanyl on one occasion — to an undercover officer during multiple exchanges. The case has not been resolved.
The Trump administration highlighted Mr. Belgal’s criminal record to argue that New York City’s sanctuary laws had allowed him to avoid deportation despite his arrests.
In a statement last month, the Department of Homeland Security said that Mr. Belgal “should have never been in the streets of New York, but it’s thanks to the Biden administration and sanctuary politicians that ICE was forced to conduct a targeted operation to remove this criminal illegal alien from their community.”
The department also said that ICE had arrested Mr. Belgal because the agency believed he had information about a shooting last year that injured an off-duty customs officer in Manhattan. The agency accused Mr. Belgal of being associated with the Trinitarios, a Dominican street gang.
Federal officials have not provided evidence for either assertion, and Mr. Belgal has denied belonging to a gang.
Judge Gonzalez, who was appointed by former President Joseph R. Biden Jr. in 2022, had denied a separate emergency motion by Mr. Belgal’s lawyers that had sought his release so that he could receive medical treatment last month.
The judge had found that Mr. Belgal was in stable condition and had received adequate medical care while in custody.
Santul Nerkar contributed reporting.
The post Judge Denies Release of Immigrant Shot by ICE in New York appeared first on New York Times.




