DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

The right to an attorney is dying in overworked public defenders’ offices

November 19, 2026
in News
The right to an attorney is dying in overworked public defenders’ offices

Chesa Boudin, a former San Francisco district attorney, is the executive director of the Criminal Law & Justice Center at the University of California at Berkeley School of Law, where Erwin Chemerinsky serves as dean.

Manohar Raju, San Francisco’s public defender, instructed his staff in May 2025 to refuse to take on some new clients. “Every member of my team could cut their workload in half,” he told the Associated Press, “and they would still have more than a full-time job.” When a superior court judge ordered him to reverse that ban in January, Raju refused. Two months later, he was held in contempt and fined $26,000, a thousand for each declined case. On Nov. 19, an appeals court will consider who was right.

The stakes are significant, and the underlying question is fundamental. In 1963, in Gideon v. Wainwright, the Supreme Court guaranteed that under the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution, the government would provide a lawyer to anyone too poor to hire one. It never specified exactly who would pay, however, which has become problematic as caseloads across the country have increased without commensurate boosts in personnel.

Public defenders don’t choose their workloads. Prosecutors decide whom to charge and with what, and courts assign lawyers as needed. When the number of cases outpaces the capacity of attorneys, something has to give. What gives, in practice, is the work done on each case: the witness interview that never happens or the motion that is never written. A client may eventually plead guilty because no one had enough time to review body camera footage or to investigate a defense.

In Los Angeles, home to the nation’s largest public defender office, lawyers are estimated to spend roughly 140 hours on the average murder case. That’s just over half the national workload standard and less than a third of the 500 hours the office’s veteran defenders say an adequate defense demands. A court order to take more cases simply spreads existing resources thinner, meaning everyone receives weaker counsel.

States are confronting the collapse. Earlier this year, Oregon’s Supreme Court ordered that charges be dismissed when the state can’t provide defendants a lawyer. More than 1,400 criminal cases were tossed as a result. Washington’s Supreme Court has ordered that defender caseloads be cut, and counties are suing the state for more funding. Iowa’s Supreme Court also sided with overloaded public defenders, and litigation in Maine helped prompt the legislature to act.

These harms are not abstract. In one prior case documented in litigation in Oregon, a disabled man with four children was arrested on misdemeanor charges for disturbing the peace. He was being held in custody due to an old warrant for an unrelated out-of-state case that didn’t request his detention — something an attorney could have cleared in days. None was appointed, though, so he sat in custody for weeks, appearing in court repeatedly only to be told no attorney was available. By the time he was released, he had lost his disability income and his family had lost their home. His charges were minor. The consequences were not.

South Dakota tried to get ahead of the crisis by creating a state office of Indigent Legal Services in 2024. In doing so, it began to shift responsibility for funding and oversight of such cases from the counties to the state. Ohio, in 2023, enacted a law to cover nearly all trial-level public-defense costs while still allowing local discretion in how to provide counsel. Yet California is still one of the small handful of states to delegate such funding and oversight to the counties — an approach that results in gross discrepancies in quality of service and leaves many counties unable to meet minimum ethical and constitutional standards. Raju’s potential charges grow because he continues to declines a small number of new cases — not out of defiance but to protect the clients he already represents.

That’s what California law, in our view, demands. A state appeals court in 2009 affirmed that a public defender “may not be assigned to represent an indigent defendant in a case” when his excessive caseload compels him to choose between the rights of various clients. Raju worried about exactly that, and yet the judge gave short shrift to his concern. No court should punish a lawyer for refusing to violate the Constitution.

The deeper fix is no mystery. States should follow Ohio’s lead and shift public defense off the counties’ budgets. As Washington has done, they should also set enforceable limits on how many cases a defender can carry. Prosecutors ought to be prudent, too, charging only what justice and public safety require. Every unnecessary charge puts more pressure on a failing system. When legislatures don’t alleviate such strains, judges must enforce the Sixth Amendment themselves, ordering governments to fund defense adequately or to dismiss the cases they can’t fairly prosecute.

The right to counsel exists because a government that can put people’s freedom in jeopardy without a real adversary in the courtroom is a government with too much power. That concerns everyone, not merely defendants in court. The promise of the Sixth Amendment, however, is only as real as the time and resources the country is willing to put behind it. Right now, in San Francisco and elsewhere, it isn’t devoting nearly enough.

The post The right to an attorney is dying in overworked public defenders’ offices appeared first on Washington Post.

Anthropic shares will debut on the stock market in a test for the AI boom
News

Anthropic shares will debut on the stock market in a test for the AI boom

by Washington Post
November 19, 2026

Shares of artificial intelligence company Anthropic will begin trading publicly Thursday in a market debut that may test the strength ...

Read more
News

Trump’s inner circle sends not-so-subtle warning to his would-be heir: ‘We will crush you’

November 19, 2026
News

Deluded Trump Insists ‘Everything’s Good’ After Outage Crisis Cripples U.S.

November 19, 2026
News

Jeff Bezos promised $10 billion for climate and nature by 2030. His Earth Fund just put $100 million into the Amazon rainforest

November 19, 2026
News

‘Josephine’ Review: A Young Witness to Adult Horrors

November 19, 2026
How Trump Embraced, Then Debased, Classical Architecture

How Trump Embraced, Then Debased, Classical Architecture

November 19, 2026
A PE firm scooped up an influencer marketing company in a bet on the industry’s next growth area

A PE firm scooped up an influencer marketing company in a bet on the industry’s next growth area

November 19, 2026
The right to an attorney is dying in overworked public defenders’ offices

The right to an attorney is dying in overworked public defenders’ offices

November 19, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026