Everyone knows that smoking causes lung disease, heart disease and cancer, and that quitting can substantially reduce these health risks. Yet, despite decades of public education campaigns and numerous available treatments, quitting smoking remains notoriously difficult. According to a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report, in 2022, half of the approximately 29 million Americans who smoke tried to quit, but fewer than 10 percent succeeded.
A new JAMA study found an innovative way to double the quit rate: paying smokers to stop. This adds to a growing body of evidence that financial incentives can change behaviors and reduce health care costs.
The study’s lead author, Joanna L. Hart, a pulmonologist whose primary clinical practice is at the VA hospital in Philadelphia, told me that she treats many patients with lung disease resulting from years of heavy tobacco use. “Almost all of them wish they had never started and had tried many times to stop, but have a very hard time getting it out of their life,” she said.
She and her colleagues randomly assigned more than 3,200 participants to one of four groups. The first received usual care, the “ask-advise-refer” strategy in which clinicians ask about tobacco use, advise patients to quit and refer them to cessation resources. The second received usual care plus free nicotine replacement therapy and reimbursement for approved smoking cessation medications. The third received free medications plus financial incentives of up to $600 for successfully quitting smoking. The fourth received the same as the third but also used a mobile app motivating them on future health goals.
After six months, about 4.3 percent of those who received usual care were still abstaining from smoking, as confirmed by blood or urine tests. Adding free medications did not result in a statistically significant increase in the quit rate, nor did the motivational app provide additional benefit. On the other hand, financial incentives — structured as $100 after two weeks, $200 after three months and $300 after six months of verified abstinence — more than doubled the quit rate, to 8.8 percent.
Hart explained that treating nicotine dependence is not enough; people also need a strong behavioral motivator, because the health benefits of quitting can seem far away while the difficulty of quitting is immediate. Financial incentives bring the rewards into the present. “If we could bring it to the here and now, people will think, ‘I just have to make it to one month or three or six to get this monetary reward,’” she said.
A co-author of the study, University of Pennsylvania health economist Kevin Volpp, adds that cash works particularly well as an incentive because it gets people’s attention. “In essence, it’s saying that the health system recognizes that you are going to be a much higher-cost person if you continue to smoke than if you don’t, and we are going to share some of that money with you up-front,” he said.
Once people have received their cash, won’t they just go back to smoking? Not according to past studies. One, led by Volpp and published in the New England Journal of Medicine, found that after 18 months — a year after incentives ended — the quit rate was still more than 2.5 times higher among those who received cash.
“If we can help people quit smoking for a year, there’s a pretty good chance they’re going to be able to carry it forward on their own thereafter,” he said.
Hart agreed with this assessment. In her experience, people who have stopped smoking for six months to a year are likely to remain abstinent without cash rewards because they are experiencing physical benefits, such as coughing less and being able to breathe better and walk farther. Plus, they are saving money on cigarettes, which can add up to hundreds of dollars a month.
Despite dozens of past studies, including a 2025 Cochrane review affirming the effectiveness and lasting impact of financial incentives, the concept of paying people to quit smoking faces considerable opposition. Nonsmokers may question why smokers should get money for giving up a bad habit. In Volpp’s experience, those who quit without being paid are especially likely to view such incentives as unfair.
The strongest counterargument is that everyone is already paying for the consequences of smoking through higher medical costs. “We all share health care costs across our economy, and $600 is a drop in the bucket compared to how much money we spend treating conditions that arise from tobacco,” Hart said. Insurance typically covers medications to help people quit. If financial incentives work better, why shouldn’t insurers deploy them, too?
The findings also raise a broader question about how the health system can better encourage people to take care of their health. For instance, insurers could eliminate co-payments for essential medications such as insulin and blood pressure drugs. Social safety-net programs could stop paying for unhealthy foods and beverages and offer cash incentives for health-promoting behavior. If the goal is better health at a lower cost, we should heed the lessons of behavioral economics about what really motivates people.
What are your thoughts about paying people to quit smoking? Please write to me; I will feature reader comments and questions in a future edition of The Checkup newsletter.
The post How to get more people to quit smoking? This approach pays off. appeared first on Washington Post.




