DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

The misleading message behind America’s lead warnings

November 17, 2026
in News
The misleading message behind America’s lead warnings

Marc Edwards is a professor of civil engineering at Virginia Tech. Siddhartha Roy is an assistant professor in environmental sciences and engineering at Rutgers University.

A federal appeals court ruled in September that residents of Jackson, Mississippi, had no constitutional right to drinking water that was safe from lead contamination. The concerns among local leaders over the decision are understandable — the Environmental Protection Agency found that Jackson residents were poorly served by their water utility. But another critical point is being overlooked: Because U.S. public health agencies now repeatedly assert that there is “no safe level” of lead, it is impossible for water utilities to produce safe water in the first place.

Lead is a naturally occurring element, and modern humans evolved while exposed to at least trace amounts of it in their soil, water and air. So when government agencies embrace the idea that there is “no safe level” of lead in drinking water, without also identifying a level below which people should not be overly worried, there is no meaningful stopping point. One part per billion (ppb) could be unsafe. So could one part per trillion, or one part per quadrillion. There is no practical point at which there can be a safe drop to drink.

We are generally able to avoid this problem with other contaminants that also have aspirational goals of zero because regulators identify a practical level at which risk is considered acceptably low. For arsenic, the EPA’s health goal is zero, but its enforceable drinking-water limit is 10 ppb. We can debate that limit and revise it as evidence changes. We can live with similar definitions for safe water. But unqualified “no safe level” messaging has become especially prominent for lead, and more recently for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, known as forever chemicals.

We’ve warned about the consequences of “no safe level” messaging for lead because it can turn every detectable measurement into evidence that water is unsafe. Consider a 2024 study of Chicago drinking water in JAMA Pediatrics. Researchers classified water containing at least 1 ppb of lead as “lead-contaminated.”

Why 1 ppb? The authors gave two reasons: No amount of lead in drinking water is considered safe, and 1 ppb was the study’s limit of detection. “Lead-contaminated” simply meant detectable. On that basis, the researchers estimated that 68 percent of Chicago children younger than 6 were exposed to lead-contaminated drinking water.

News coverage of the study invoked a familiar litany of problems associated with excessive lead exposure, including lower IQ and behavioral problems, while suggesting bottled water and lead filters as possible responses. Yet the Food and Drug Administration allows bottled water to contain as much as 5 ppb of lead. The same limit applies to filters certified for lead reduction. If 1 ppb makes tap water unsafe, why are bottled and filtered water, which could contain five times as much, considered safer?

We have devoted our careers to reducing lead exposure. Our collaborative efforts over the past 25 years with communities in the United States have helped expose elevated levels of lead in water in D.C., Flint, Michigan, and beyond. Lead pipes should be replaced. Chemical treatment of drinking water to manage lead levels should work. Government officials should be forthcoming when water systems fail. But public health agencies should not make success impossible by definition. Who benefits from making failure inevitable and creating a permanent health scare over lead in water? Certainly not low-income families spending their scarce income on bottled water, filters and treatment systems. Certainly not those trying to replace dangerously antiquated infrastructure to permanently reduce lead exposure, because even the much-improved water can never earn the label “safe.”

The “no safe level” language is also applied to lead in children’s blood, with a less obvious and potentially more serious cost. Our research in Flint raised the possibility that some of the more alarming messaging about irreversible harm could itself cause harm. Flint children were repeatedly told that they might suffer lifelong consequences from an unprecedented lead poisoning disaster that happened more than a decade ago. Yet blood-lead data did not show the catastrophic exposure that many came to believe had occurred. Even during the worst of the crisis, the blood-lead levels in Flint children were never significantly higher than those in children statewide. Children in nearby Detroit also had higher rates of elevated blood-lead than children in Flint did, likely from lead-based paint and dust, but were not subjected to the same potentially harmful messaging.

When special-education enrollment surged in Flint, lead exposure was blamed. But lead exposure alone cannot explain why enrollment rates later became higher in Flint than in Detroit. The nocebo effect — harm arising from the expectation of harm — might also have played a role. Whatever the intentions, absolutist “no safe level” messaging can make our water and our children seem irretrievably damaged — which can itself be harmful.

Raising that possibility brought us substantial blowback. We later faced attacks from some former allies and advocacy groups after questioning claims that Flint children had been permanently brain-damaged.

The Jackson ruling might yet be challenged. But in the meantime, shouldn’t public health agencies provide Americans with a clear, practical definition of what “safe” actually means when it comes to lead in water and in blood? There cannot be a right to safe water if, by definition, safe water cannot exist.

The post The misleading message behind America’s lead warnings appeared first on Washington Post.

Fox News anchor alarmed as ‘trifecta of turmoil’ wallops Americans: ‘What is going on?’
News

Massive hidden hack served malware to major American news websites: reports

by Raw Story
November 17, 2026

Fox News, CNN and other major websites served malware to their visitors Monday after hackers hijacked a tool the sites ...

Read more
News

What dermatologists look for in a lip balm

November 17, 2026
News

Popular Californian brewery set to close

November 17, 2026
News

DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin Enjoys Private Plane Jaunt During Flight Misery

November 17, 2026
News

From Failed Businessman to Accused Plotter in the Killing of Haiti’s Leader

November 17, 2026
California bridge toll hikes could hit drivers’ wallets and ripple out to consumers

California bridge toll hikes could hit drivers’ wallets and ripple out to consumers

November 17, 2026
World of Warcraft: Forever – All Class and Dungeon Changes in November 17 Update

World of Warcraft: Forever – All Class and Dungeon Changes in November 17 Update

November 17, 2026
The misleading message behind America’s lead warnings

The misleading message behind America’s lead warnings

November 17, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026