“The Swan” is mostly remembered as the most toxic and shocking reality show ever made, pushing the makeover construct to the edge.
In 2004, over two seasons on Fox, 32 women, or “ugly ducklings” in the show’s parlance, selected from hundreds of thousands of applicants, were isolated while they underwent extensive cosmetic surgery and intense physical training over three months — no mirrors allowed. Both seasons culminated in a pageant in which some of the women, now “swans,” walked a stage wearing, among other things, lingerie.
On Tuesday, a new documentary from Erin Lee Carr, “The Swan: Behind the Mirror,” will debut on Hulu. Twelve contestants — along with some of the show’s producers and one of its plastic surgeons — appear in the film to recount the experience from inside what Kari Bravata, a Season 2 participant, called “pretty prison.”
The film joins a recent slate of documentaries that revisit and scrutinize reality TV competition shows from the aughts, including “The Biggest Loser” and “America’s Next Top Model,” which used humiliation and other questionable tactics to make exciting TV under the guise of polishing diamonds in the rough.
“The original pitch was: ‘Take ugly chicks and make them hot,’” Carl Buehl, a senior producer on “The Swan,” recalls in the film.
In addition to two surgeons, “The Swan” employed a dentist, who was barred from practicing in 2017; a therapist; and a life coach who was actually the show’s creator, Nely Galán.
“Behind the Mirror” includes abundant archival footage from “The Swan” (including of Galán, who didn’t participate in the documentary) and from the surrounding media frenzy; the show was even spoofed on “S.N.L.”
Viewers will be reminded of the severity of the surgeries themselves, as well as the bruised, swollen, stitched aftermath. New revelations also surface: Post-op medical care was so lacking that contestants tended to one another, and the Season 1 cast members weren’t told they’d be competing until they arrived to begin filming. With networks racing to push reality TV to the brink, the pageant element was added later to raise the stakes.
Galán did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday. And Fox forwarded the request for comment to Fremantle, the studio on the series, who did not immediately respond on Wednesday.
If you watched “The Swan” when it originally aired, as I did, you may recall how dramatic the reveals were. These women became almost unrecognizable.
But times have changed. What was once fringe has become normalized, especially amid today’s ubiquitous GLP-1s and conspicuous plastic surgery. Across social media and on reality shows like “The Real Housewives” and “Love Island,” faces often seem to have morphed into a single homogenized aesthetic, whether it’s called Instagram face, Mar-a-Lago face or rich face. In retrospect, “The Swan” feels almost like a prototype.
The show was also early to conflate cosmetic intervention with body positivity, emotional healing and self-care, language that’s echoed widely today online whether it be from wellness brands, influencers or med spas.
In 2023, over 34.9 million cosmetic procedures were performed globally, a 40 percent increase from four years earlier, and face-lifts reached record highs last year in the United States.
Did “The Swan” help desensitize us to extreme physical alteration, or was it simply ahead of the curve? In an interview this month, Carr put it succinctly: It “predicted where we went.” Not unlike the women on “The Swan,” the reality TV star Heidi Montag famously had 10 cosmetic procedures in one day in 2009; she was 23.
“We have come back into a time where we’re searching to be that 2000s-era body,” Carr said. “America is obsessed with the word transformation.” The show’s assembly-line concept, she added, “ultimately put us in a spot where we won’t be happy with one nose job.”
There’s also a discussion to be had here about female obedience, Carr said. The women on “The Swan” did not feel empowered to pick and choose which surgeries they were comfortable with, we learn.
“I was told that if I didn’t get everything on my list, I would be sent home,” Beth Lay, the Season 1 runner-up, says in the documentary.
Tawnya Cooke, who at age 40 was the oldest “Swan” contestant, was the only woman who refused to get work done on her face, even knowing it meant her run on the show would be cut short. Still, she says in the documentary, “I was proud of myself for not letting them go in and do whatever they wanted.”
Above all, though, Carr didn’t make the documentary to serve as a counterpoint to our current era. At its heart, the project is about humanizing these women, she emphasized, and giving them space to speak for themselves about what they endured during reality TV’s early days.
“These women did not know how reality shows worked,” Carr said. “They’re trusting the process, trusting a television company.”
“I don’t want to make it about us right now. I want to make it about them, and then everybody who watches it hopefully has that conversation with themselves about the cost of beauty.”
The post The Most Disturbing 2000s Reality Show Doesn’t Seem So Crazy Anymore appeared first on New York Times.
