When it comes to premium-grade escapism, go for the gold.
Loosely defined as mysteries written between the two world wars (though there’s some flexibility here), Golden Age mysteries impose a moral and logical order on a topsy-turvy world by means of deduction, clue puzzles and some of fiction’s most remarkable sleuths. These novels are not necessarily cozy — there’s often as much gin as tea. But reassuring? Addictive? Absorbing enough to distract you from doomscrolling and its 1930s equivalent? Oh, yes. (And if you’re looking for some fabulous country-house settings, great millinery and the odd vicar, well, they’ve got that, too.)
In one attempt to codify the genre, an English priest and writer named Ronald Knox drafted a “Ten Commandments of Detection” in the late 1920s. His rules for mystery novels included no ghosts, minimal use of twins, no reliance on cheap stereotypes and only one secret passage per novel.
At their best, Golden Age mysteries are filled with iconic characters, hairpin twists and superb writing. Here, to get you started, are gems from novelists like Agatha Christie, Ngaio Marsh and Josephine Tey. Clear your schedule, pour yourself a drink (either sort) and lock up the cyanide.
Give me the O.G.
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd
by Agatha Christie (1926)
With 66 detective novels to her name, Dame Agatha Christie is the undisputed Queen of Crime. (Literally: Her estate trademarked the sobriquet.) One of her most iconic creations is the meticulous Hercule Poirot, a former Belgian police officer. Poirot first came on the scene in a country-house mystery called “The Mysterious Case at Styles” in 1920, and certainly, you could do worse than to start on the vast grounds of that well-manicured estate. But “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd” finds both detective and author at the height of their powers.
Our narrator, a country doctor named James Sheppard, is called to the scene when a wealthy widow apparently dies by suicide. Her fiancé, Roger Ackroyd, says she was being blackmailed by someone who knew she had poisoned her first husband. When Ackroyd himself turns up dead, enter Poirot and a vast cast of suspects, including an entitled stepson, a fanciful spinster, a resentful illegitimate son, a by-the-book retired military officer, a secretive personal secretary and a housekeeper who knows far more than she’s saying. It’s a master class in red herrings, misdirection and unreliable narration, and it ends with perhaps the greatest twist of all time.
As our critic wrote in 1926, “There are doubtless many detective stories more exciting and bloodcurdling than ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd,’ but this reviewer has recently read very few which provide greater analytical stimulation.”
I love an eccentric detective
Fer-de-Lance
by Rex Stout (1934)
Giving literal meaning to the armchair detective — his is custom-made for his generous proportions — Nero Wolfe is a brilliant, sybaritic and somewhat mysterious Montenegrin detective who solves mysteries from his luxuriously appointed Manhattan brownstone, frequently clad in canary-hued silk pajamas. His weight makes it hard for him to leave his gadget-strewn mansion, and in any case, he doesn’t want to neglect his 10,000 orchids or miss a gourmet meal prepared by Fritz, his private chef. So all the actual investigations are carried out by Nero’s assistant, the dapper ladies’ man Archie Goodwin, who brings the chaos of the outside world back to Wolfe’s perfectly ordered domain.
Here, what begins as the case of a missing metalworker soon balloons into something much more complicated, involving the death of a college president on a Westchester golf course — a place where Wolfe, needless to say, wouldn’t be caught dead.
The Wolfe series would continue for decades, and while the city around him changed, Wolfe himself remained reassuringly, unerringly eccentric. He is never better than in this story of greed, haute cuisine and deadly herpetology.
How about something that will unsettle me?
The Franchise Affair
by Josephine Tey (1948)
“There is no end to the extravagances of human conduct,” observes one of the implacable characters in Tey’s unsettling and acid-tinged nail-biter. Betty Kane, a teenage orphan, accuses an elderly woman and her daughter, the aptly named Sharpes, of abducting and imprisoning her at their remote house. Hired to defend the Sharpes, the solicitor Robert Blair becomes increasingly convinced of their innocence, even as the town turns against them. Based on an 18th-century case, Tey’s novel was controversial when it came out; not everyone liked its crystalline froideur and profusion of antiheroines. It has since been characterized by some modern critics as misogynistic. Read it and decide for yourself.
Dark intrigue and a dame in distress? Sign me up!
The Case of the Lame Canary
by Erle Stanley Gardner (1937)
You may associate Perry Mason with his midcentury TV iteration, but in fact, Gardner’s indefatigable defense attorney had already been around for decades by the time the show started. “The Case of the Lame Canary” — about a case that seems like an open-and-shut domestic dispute but turns very dark, very fast — was Mason’s 11th outing.
When a gorgeous dame walks into Mason’s office carrying an injured bird, who wouldn’t be intrigued? Newcomers to the series will be immediately immersed in Gardner’s Depression-era Los Angeles; longtime fans will note the unique role played by Mason’s secretary, Della Street.
I’d like a well-crafted literary puzzle
The Duke of York’s Steps
by Henry Wade (1929)
Henry Wade (a pseudonym that was easier to get on a book jacket than Sir Henry Lancelot Aubrey-Fletcher, 6th Baronet) was a founding member of the Detection Club, and his seven Chief Inspector Poole novels are models of Golden Age craft. The Scotland Yard detective’s second outing, in which a banker’s body is found near London’s Duke of York monument, is beloved for its intricate plot and final twist. (It also includes a German-Jewish character who isn’t one-dimensionally sinister, a rarity for the era.)
How about a twisted mystery set in a gorgeous place?
Fear Stalks the Village
by Ethel Lina White (1932)
“The village was beautiful. It was enfolded in a hollow of the Downs, and wrapped up snugly — first, in a floral shawl of gardens, and then, in a great green shawl of fields. Lilies and lavender grew in abundance.”
What could possibly go wrong in such an idyllic place? Joan Brook, the companion to Lady d’Arcy, can’t imagine who would, out of nowhere, terrorize the community with a series of poison-pen letters revealing everyone’s secrets. Could it be the saintly vicar, the cheerful spinster, the head of the temperance society, the visiting lady novelist? With sly wit, White undercuts the tropes of English country life, juxtaposing the beautifully drawn landscape with a community gripped by paranoia.
Give me a wartime tale of murder and blackmail
The Blank Wall
by Elisabeth Sanxay Holding (1947)
With her husband fighting in the Pacific, Lucia Holley is left at home in Connecticut with her father, her two children and her maid, Sibyl. What starts as a conventional domestic drama about someone trying to hold it together quickly unravels when Lucia’s rebellious teenage daughter becomes involved with a shady older man, a situation which leads, in short order, to murder and blackmail. It’s an evocative portrait of American life on the home front, the fierceness of maternal devotion and the close, if restricted, relationship between two women, one white and one Black — but it’s also a mystery so tense and relatable that it will stay with you for years. (The fact that its 2001 adaptation, “The Deep End,” works so well is a testament to its essential excellence.)
“The end of the tether,” Lucia says to herself at one point. “You go as far as you can, and then the rope is stretched tight and you can’t go on.”
Take me to that most iconic of settings: the British country house
A Man Lay Dead
by Ngaio Marsh (1934)
Surely this has to be one of the first mysteries to combine a murder parlor game with a fabulous, frivolous weekend party at an English country house.
Sir Hubert Handesley’s assembled guests — a dissipated womanizer, a society matron, a jaded journalist, a Russian doctor and assorted family members and staff — decide to play, if a little grudgingly. But when the game turns all too real, it’s up to the dapper, dashing detective Roderick “Rory” Alleyn to find out who lodged an antique dagger in a guest’s back. This mystery firmly established the New Zealand writer Marsh as a queen of crime, trademarked or otherwise.
I like my sleuths suave and debonair
The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club
by Dorothy L. Sayers (1928)
An unashamed dilettante, Lord Peter Wimsey enjoys fine food and wine, bell-ringing, Savile Row tailoring, sports cars, Bach, collecting manuscripts and solving the odd murder. The fourth Wimsey novel is set at the titular London veterans’ club, where an elderly general is found dead in his armchair on the same day his wife is found dead at home, leading to a series of questions over who inherits their vast estate. Assisted by his valet (and former World War I batman), Wimsey wades into the case, leading to not just a terrifically twisty read, but a subtle study of the lingering costs of the Great War, even for those who seem to wear them most lightly.
How about a thriller that grapples with the nature of evil?
The Tiger in the Smoke
by Margery Allingham (1952)
Though the posh gentleman detective Albert Campion, first introduced in 1929, may have originated as a spoof of Lord Peter Wimsey and his jaunty ilk, by the time we meet him in his 14th case, he — like postwar London — has been through it.
During a pea-souper of a fog, Campion’s cousin, the widow Meg Elginbrodde, is about to remarry when she begins receiving photographs suggesting her first husband, Martin, did not die on D-Day as she had been led to believe. The plot thickens when Meg glimpses a man through the haze who seems to be wearing Martin’s distinctive coat. What follows is a Channel-hopping story of hidden treasure, the fraying loyalties of a group of army comrades and, ultimately, the true nature of morality.
“What is the soul?” asks one character, in a spine-tingling soliloquy. “When I was a child I thought it was a little ghostly bean, kidney-shaped. I don’t know why. Now I think of it as the man I am with when I am alone.”
Give me the GOAT locked-room mystery
The Hollow Man
by John Dickson Carr (1935)
Dr. Gideon Fell, a sleuth supposedly modeled on the British writer G.K. Chesterton, stars in perhaps the most iconic of all locked-room mysteries. The story itself — of a body, three Transylvanian brothers, faked deaths, live burials and even a magician — is engaging and smart. But it’s the “locked room lecture” in Chapter 17 that cemented the book’s place in the canon.
In it, Dr. Fell famously discusses the different kinds of locked-room mysteries and their solutions with friends, even breaking the fourth wall in one passage. “We’re in a detective story,” he says, “and we don’t fool the reader by pretending we’re not. Let’s not invent elaborate excuses to drag in a discussion of detective stories. Let’s candidly glory in the noblest pursuits possible to characters in a book.”
I love a wildly unpredictable roller coaster of a read
Birthday Party
by C.H.B. Kitchin (1938)
Twelve years after his father’s death, Ronnie Carlice is about to come into his inheritance, the ancient family seat of Carlice Abbey. But to the dismay of his family, Ronnie — who has developed Marxist sympathies at Oxford — has decided to give the property away. As his 21st birthday party approaches, questions arise about his father’s cause of death, throwing into question the fate of the estate and everyone on it. As much literary novel as taut mystery, Kitchin’s study of a changing England deserves to be better known.
Give me something fizzy and fun
The Roman Hat Mystery
by Ellery Queen (1929)
During a performance of the Broadway hit “Gunplay!,” the body of a widely despised lawyer is found in the audience, dead by poisoning. And where is his silk top hat, possibly containing important documents? The veteran homicide detective Richard Queen is put on the case, aided in his investigation by his writer son, Ellery. This is a series that deserves its popularity: ingeniously plotted, tight, filled with fun set pieces and unerringly clever.
I’d like a cozy mystery with an edge
The Poisoned Chocolates Case
by Anthony Berkeley (1929)
The Crimes Circle is a private London club of six armchair amateur detectives, all of whom think they can do a better job than the pros. When their founder, Roger Sheringham, invites a Scotland Yard inspector to deliver a lecture on an unsolved murder, the members decide they’ll put their powers of deduction to the test and see which one of them can crack the case. The range of their theories is strikingly wide — and largely inaccurate. But, together, might they be onto something? The novel is not just an increasingly tense investigation of the actual case, but a study in voyeurism that remains eerily relevant nearly a hundred years after it was written.
How have you not mentioned Miss Marple yet?!
The Body in the Library
by Agatha Christie (1942)
In a Christie thunderdome, it’s hard to say who would emerge as the world’s most popular detective: the natty, meticulous Hercule Poirot or St. Mary Mead’s resident amateur sleuth, the prescient Jane Marple. In the foreword to this novel, Christie said that she was determined to get around the clichéd “body in the library” trope, writing, “The library in question must be a highly orthodox and conventional library. The body, on the other hand, must be a wildly improbable and highly sensational body.”
In fact, Christie gives us two corpses here: that of a young dancer found at Gossington Hall, and that of a second teenager, an unworldly girl with her own dreams of stardom. How are their fates entangled, and why? Who are the various rich older men in their lives? Naturally, the police need to bring in Miss Marple to see through the stories and lies. The wildly improbable conclusion flirts with breaking Knox’s rules, but the plotting is so impeccable and the twists so genuinely surprising that no such list would be complete without its inclusion. All hail the Queen.
Surprise me with something fiendishly clever
The End of Andrew Harrison
by Freeman Wills Crofts
Crofts was a mystery-lover’s mystery writer: a meticulous technician of the locked-room puzzle, demanding as much deduction from the reader as from his main character, Scotland Yard’s Inspector Joseph French. The titular Harrison is a thoroughly odious millionaire whose body is discovered on his houseboat, ostensibly dead by suicide. French, however, has his suspicions. As usual, he is right — albeit in thoroughly surprising, ingenious and satisfying fashion.
The post Golden Age Mysteries: A Starter Pack appeared first on New York Times.
