An IT consultant who lives on the Lower East Side walked into a Manhattan courtroom on Tuesday and sized Donald Trump up. The excitement rose in his voice as he declared that he found the former president “fascinating and mysterious.”
“He walks into a room and he sets people off one way or another,” the prospective juror went on. “I find that really interesting. Really, this one guy can do all of this. Wow, that’s what I think.”
Trump didn’t seem to register a reaction. “Um, alright,” his lead attorney, Todd Blanche, said, more visibly at a loss. “Thank you.”
Assessments such as these, and not all of them so inspired, have comprised the bulk of the first week of the first criminal trial of a former US president—a series of man-on-the street impressions of the defining cultural-political figure of the last decade delivered as he silently looked on. Jury selection for Trump’s case, in which he has pleaded not guilty to falsifying business records in order to cover up an alleged affair with the porn star Stormy Daniels (which he has also denied), began on Monday, and it has, in some ways, provided a measure of his current grip on our collective attention.
As potential panelists filed into the courtroom throughout the week, they craned their necks to get a look at Trump. As anyone who has been called to serve in New York can attest, jury duty is one of the few unavoidable common denominators shared in a city of extremes. The pool delivered its dependable cross section of New York. One woman giggled and put her hand over her mouth, turning to her seatmate to raise her eyebrows. In most instances, the jury candidates came and went. Many said from the outset that they couldn’t be impartial in this most charged and high-profile case, and so there was no need for them to be questioned by Trump’s lawyers and state prosecutors.
When prospective jurors did advance to take the stand, they generally seemed to have something to get off their chest, even as they maintained that they could remain fair. One woman sighed when asked by Trump’s lawyer Susan Necheles whether she had any strong opinions about the defendant. “I’m born and raised in Brooklyn and New York,” she said, “and I’ve kind of spent my whole life knowing about Donald Trump.” She said she once saw him and his ex-wife Marla Maples shopping for “baby stuff” at ABC Carpet & Home. She said she’d heard positive things about him, but added that “how I feel about him as a president is different.”
“Oh boy,” said another candidate, harkening back to 1989, when Trump took out newspaper ads calling for the execution of the falsely imprisoned Central Park Five. “Here we go. Going back to Central Park, I knew some of the kids, their cousins.”
An Italian man explained that the media in his birthplace “have had a very strong association with Mr. Trump and Silvio Berlusconi,” which made him worry about his ability to retain impartiality. He was excused.
A young Black woman said that as a person of color, she had friends with strong opinions of Trump, but that she wasn’t herself a political person and she appreciated his candor. “President Trump speaks his mind,” she said, “and I’d rather that than someone who’s in office who you don’t know what they’re thinking.” She was the only person in the jury box at the time who was unaware that Trump had been charged in three other criminal cases.
For all the discussion leading up to the trial in heavily Democratic Manhattan, the baseline view was often closer to the IT consultant’s sense of wonder than outright condemnation. “He was our president,” the owner of a construction firm said, describing himself as a fellow entrepreneur. “Pretty amazing. He was a businessman in New York. He forged his way.”
Through it all, Trump has generally looked bored, and it is often quite boring—and cold. He complained to reporters on Thursday afternoon about “this New York scandal trial,” and how he was “sitting here for days now, from morning till night in that freezing room.”
“Freezing,” he repeated. “Everybody was freezing in there.”
With the ceremony of the presidency for now stripped away, he was in a dreary courthouse like every other Manhattan criminal defendant on trial. Over the course of this week, District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office released announcements of indictments for rape, murder, and shooting charges throughout the city, as well as for a fatal subway shoving.
At present, only six reporters are allowed in the courtroom at a time, with the rows there full of prospective jurors. The rest of the press watches via a video feed from an overflow room, where Michael Wolff, wearing white pants and suede loafers, peered into the screen on Tuesday. The prevailing question early in the week was whether Trump had dozed off at the defense table, as The New York Times’ Maggie Haberman reported and as the Trump campaign immediately and forcefully denied. Norm Eisen, the legal commentator and former US ambassador to the Czech Republic, joked to Haberman in an elevator that George Conway had also fallen asleep.
Later on Tuesday, Trump told reporters on his way out of the courthouse that he was headed to a bodega. In Harlem, the neighborhood where Bragg grew up, a clerk at the convenience store stabbed and killed a man with whom he was fighting in 2022. Bragg’s office initially charged him with murder, but after an outcry over whether the worker’s action constituted self-defense, dropped the case. “I love this city and it’s gotten so bad in the last three years, four years,” Trump told the New York Post, “and we’re going to straighten New York out.” His visit amounted to a taunt, with the district attorney currently trying his case so often derided in the conservative press as “soft on crime.” It was a novelty still, this Queens-born former president making a local spectacle of himself in between appearances at an unprecedented criminal trial. The crowd in Harlem matched or even outstripped the third-string MAGA crew—including Laura Loomer and Andrew Giuliani—that showed up outside the court on Monday and never returned.
There were some hiccups throughout jury selection. The IT consultant was initially chosen as a panelist but eventually dismissed after some possible discrepancies in his answers emerged. But by the end of the day Thursday, a jury of 12 was chosen, ahead of opening statements that are expected as early as Monday. The jurors were sworn in and received instructions from Justice Juan Merchan. As they were led out of the courtroom and past the defense table, Trump stared at them.
More Great Stories From Vanity Fair
Anne Hathaway on Tuning Out the Haters and Embracing Her True Self
Meet Clara Bow, the Scrutinized “It Girl” Who Inspired a New Taylor Swift Song
Deprived of His 12 Daily Diet Cokes, Trump Falls Asleep (Again) at Trial
While Melania Thinks the Hush Money Trial Is a “Disgrace”: Report
A Brief, Fascinating History of King Charles’s True Home
The 25 Best True-Crime Documentaries to Binge Right Now
From the Archive: The Devil in Bette Davis
Stay in the know and subscribe to Vanity Fair for just $2.50 $1 per month.
The post How Do You Find a Jury of Donald Trump’s Peers? appeared first on Vanity Fair.