France took virtually every precaution to make sure that its capital would be secure when all eyes were on the city for the opening ceremony of the Paris Olympics.
But the saboteurs who disrupted travel for hundreds of thousands on Friday did so by striking far outside the capital, targeting a rail network so vast, experts say, that it is impossible to secure every foot of it. And they knew exactly where to strike to cause maximum chaos.
“The S.N.C.F. faces attacks on its network every year, every month even,” said Julien Joly, a transportation expert at the Wavestone consulting firm, using the abbreviation for France’s national railway company.
He added: “But never in these proportions, and never in such a coordinated way. Unfortunately the network is so vast, you can’t ensure a 24-hour security presence everywhere.”
France has a very dense train network, with 28,000 kilometers of tracks (about 17,400 miles) used by 15,000 trains every day. Much of it is separate from the high-speed train network.
But the TGVs, as the high-speed trains are known, whisk thousands of passengers across the country daily, and are one of France’s most prized national infrastructures — a symbol of its technical know-how.
Arnaud Aymé, a transportation expert at the Sia Partners consulting firm, said that the infrastructure that was targeted — signal stations and cables — were often protected with alarms, cameras, fencing and barbed wire, and were not always easily accessible.
But train networks, because they are expansive but also limited by nature — a technical failure on one track creates an immediate bottleneck — are hard to make failproof.
“Railway networks are particularly open,” Mr. Aymé said, vulnerable to a fallen tree, an unlucky lightning strike on an electrical substation or a malicious act.
Any disruptions have “cascading effects,” he said. “Even if the network is repaired, it takes time for everything to get back in order,” he added.
Railway networks face thousands of criminal acts every year, experts say: People steal electrical cables to sell copper wire on the black market or carry out petty acts of vandalism.
But the level of coordinated and simultaneous sabotage that happened Friday is extremely rare, experts say. The S.N.C.F. said that it detected the arson around 4 a.m. and quickly intervened alongside firefighters and police.
French prosecutors have opened a criminal investigation. They say there is no doubt that the fires were intentionally set, but have said that it is too early to determine who the suspects are and what had motivated them.
It was also unclear if the aim was to disrupt the Olympics directly, or to merely to embarrass the French authorities as the country had large-scale international attention. Experts noted that sabotage on the Paris commuter lines — which are expected to ferry hundreds of thousands of Olympic visitors — would have been more directly devastating to the Games.
None of the targets are close to the French capital. The S.N.C.F. said that arsonists successfully targeted infrastructure in Courtalain, southwest of Paris; Pagny-sur-Moselle, to the east; and Croisilles, to the north. All are more than 100 kilometers (62 miles) from the French capital.
All the four main high-speed lines sprout out of Paris, connecting it to the rest of the country. Only one of the three was undisturbed on Friday after an arson attack was thwarted on the southern line leading to the French Alps and the Mediterranean, the S.N.C.F. said.
“Critical points were targeted, which shows that they knew enough about the network to know where to strike,” Gabriel Attal, France’s prime minister, told reporters after a crisis meeting on Friday.
The S.N.C.F. said that the suspected arsonists had cut and burned cables that are used for train signaling — each cable is split into dozens or even hundreds of fiber optic threads that have to be repaired, reconnected and tested.
The suspected arsonists targeted infrastructure right before the tracks split into two different directions, ensuring that two branches of the line, not just one, would be affected by the disruptions.
“The locations were particularly chosen to have more serious consequences,” Jean-Pierre Farandou, the president of the rail company, told reporters on Friday.
The post Saboteurs Targeted a Rail Network So Vast That It’s Impossible to Fully Secure appeared first on New York Times.