DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

A Brilliantly Ambivalent Memoir May Change How You See Nature Forever

November 21, 2026
in News
A Brilliantly Ambivalent Memoir May Change How You See Nature Forever

YOSEMITE FALLS: Reckoning With California History and the Gospel of John Muir, by Daniel Duane


Awe is cheap; the best nature writing unnerves. “Yosemite Falls,” Daniel Duane’s new work of combined memoir and journalism, profiles men — including himself — whose lives have orbited Yosemite. It is brilliantly ambivalent. By the end one feels that the park, and maybe nature itself, is an amalgam of countless human projections layered atop one another like colored film. Reading this book is like snapping a lens on your glasses. The mountain before you changes color; you won’t see it the same again.

Weaving a climbing memoir with a history of Indigenous genocide could easily feel off-balance, but in “Yosemite Falls,” the same themes — ego, solipsism, masculinity, denial — weave so tightly through all its narrative strands that they begin to seem one, and to separate them (and view Yosemite National Park through a single lens) seems both impoverished and naïve.

Duane grew up in an outdoorsy California family for whom Yosemite was practically a religion, and the naturalist John Muir its messiah. As such, Muir is one of the book’s stars, along with the photojournalist Galen Rowell, the Indigenous California genocide survivor Ishi and Clarence King, “a geologist so handsome, loving and fun that half the most famous men of the 19th century would have left their wives for him.”

Duane’s dad was a Yosemite climber, a lifestyle he passed on to his son, who learned early on that he could maintain his parents’ shifting approval by “performing Perfect Happy Strong Mountain Kid.” Duane genuinely loves the outdoors, and bonds with his dad through camping in Yosemite, climbing, swatting mosquitoes at night around a gas stove. But when Duane is 19, his father mis-rigs a rope when they’re rappelling, an error that Duane discovers in the nick of time: “If I’d lowered myself a touch farther,” he writes, “I would have fallen backward 60 feet to my death, looking my father in the eye the whole way down.”

After this near accident, Duane develops panic attacks. He starts backing out of climbs partway through, angry at his fear, his perceived weakness, as if they were the same thing. In an attempt to strike this weakness from his core, Duane pushes his climbing ever farther — and with diminishing psychological returns. “Climbing El Cap a second time corked the internal voice,” he writes, “for only about two weeks,” comparing his desperate strategy of chasing achievements to earn self-worth to “a drug to which one’s tolerance forever rose.”

Around this time, one of Duane’s climbing friends falls and dies, having “listened to the internal voice telling him not to be a pussy, pushed on, lost balance and slipped.” A park ranger disappears, and John Muir — generations earlier, and also at the same time — is losing it, sending a letter to his beloved, “addressed insanely from Squirrelville, Sequoia County, Nut Time,” in which he entreats her to “come suck Sequoia and be saved.”

If Nut Time is weird but endearing, less so is Muir’s history of chucking a cat out an open window, or plucking the wings from a live grasshopper to observe its limp in a dish of sand. Horrifically concurrent, as the book’s lens zooms out, is the active mass murder — for bounty and sport — of Yosemite’s Indigenous people; Muir’s delight in the streams and mountains of their ancient home is, almost literally, a pause to admire the blood-splattered flowers in a killing field. When Muir finds an Indigenous child’s toys, surrounded by murdered corpses, he writes in a letter that surely his daughter would enjoy them were it not for the fact that his wife wouldn’t let them in the house.

Duane’s self-disparagement grows increasingly absurd (and occasionally wearying) in comparison to these historic monstrosities. He comes across on the page as a genuinely likable guy. He’s trying to figure out love with a woman he calls the cellist. By the time he meets “Liz, a beautiful Jewish journalist,” one can guess correctly — based on her having a name — that she will eventually be his wife. Their daughter shows aptitude for the family trade. Duane, proud and worried, tries to be a good dad, raising her as “the safest kid climber of all time.”

Throughout, Duane tries repeatedly to hike the 200-mile John Muir Trail, a quest that he keeps self-sabotaging: inviting his flaky father (again), leaving partway through for a wedding, hauling in his pack a veritable library including “Moby-Dick” and an assortment of global scriptures with which he hopes to “figure out, once and for all, why life felt the way it did.” By the time Duane starts antidepressants for suicidal thoughts, a decision that puts him at odds with his father’s suck-it-up machismo, only the context of his account of his childhood, and his parents’ disappointment when he tells them, make clear the courage of the choice.

The book’s layers are sedimentary; ideas grow deeper by the page, the title gaining in meanings as the story goes on. Duane trusts the reader to be smart; weight-bearing brackets in a passing reference — “Lafayette Burnell, First White Man” to see El Cap — feel comfortably irritable, like a glance between friends, while even basic descriptions are delightfully precise (“a fat marmot waggled its plush ass”).

The effect, in whole, is complicated, disturbing and unforgettable. One hopes the achievement will earn Duane a few hours — or years — of self-worth.

YOSEMITE FALLS: Reckoning With California History and the Gospel of John Muir | By Daniel Duane | North Point | 327 pp. | $29

The post A Brilliantly Ambivalent Memoir May Change How You See Nature Forever appeared first on New York Times.

David Sanders Has Died. As a Pilot, He Fought Off a Hijacker’s Violent Attack.
News

David Sanders Has Died. As a Pilot, He Fought Off a Hijacker’s Violent Attack.

by New York Times
November 21, 2026

David Sanders, a Navy veteran who was among FedEx’s first pilots, was at the controls of a half-million-pound DC-10 loaded ...

Read more
News

Julia Stiles reflects on devastating ‘DWTS’ elimination — and which couples she wants to see win

November 21, 2026
News

I’m house-hacking by living in a shed in my backyard. Here are 4 things I learned from building a tiny home and downsizing.

November 21, 2026
News

A Brilliantly Ambivalent Memoir May Change How You See Nature Forever

November 21, 2026
News

The False Comfort of Online Shopping

November 21, 2026
Body pulled from L.A. River following powerful storm, investigation underway

Body pulled from L.A. River following powerful storm, investigation underway

November 21, 2026
This actress relishes criminals and connivers. Now, she tackles the FTX collapse.

This actress relishes criminals and connivers. Now, she tackles the FTX collapse.

November 21, 2026
Trapped GOP chair admits grim truth after massive midterm wipeout

Trapped GOP chair admits grim truth after massive midterm wipeout

November 21, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026