DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Step 1 of Reporting an Obituary: Confirming Someone Is Actually Dead

November 20, 2026
in News
Step 1 of Reporting an Obituary: Confirming Someone Is Actually Dead

Times Insider explains who we are and what we do, and delivers behind-the-scenes insights into how our journalism comes together.

On Friday, Sept. 14, 2018, Alan Abel died. Again.

The New York Times first reported Mr. Abel’s death in 1980. But rumors of his demise turned out to be deliberately exaggerated.

Mr. Abel was a hoaxer, and he had tricked The Times into running his obituary nearly 40 years before he died. Not long after, he held a news conference announcing his resurrection; The Times, mortified, ran a retraction.

Before The Times runs any obituary, about a notorious prankster or otherwise, we must be certain the subject has died. This crucial detail is generally reported in what we call a “confirmation graph” — a paragraph that explains how someone died, and who confirmed the death. (This follows the subject’s age and where the person died, traditionally included in the first paragraph.) These facts can be challenging to nail down.

In the case of Mr. Abel’s actual death, my colleagues and I called his hospice care facility, his family and the mortuary that oversaw his funeral arrangements. To date, we’ve heard nothing to contradict our obituary, which ran with the headline “Alan Abel, Hoaxer Extraordinaire, Is (on Good Authority) Dead.”

As an obituary reporter and a news assistant on the desk for many years, I’ve made hundreds of similar calls. Those experiences made me wonder about my colleagues’ own interesting, complicated, awkward and frustrating conversations around confirming a subject’s death.

Here’s what they told me.

The Details

Even when a source isn’t trying to pull off a hoax, confirming a death can be tricky. The Times’s bar for confirmation is high: We don’t rely on social media rumors, which are often wrong, and rarely rely on other news outlets.

Sometimes it can take time. Michael Rosenwald, an obituaries reporter, told me that he learned of the death of Frank Coppa, a member of the Bonanno mafia family who became a government witness, on “The Sit Down: A Crime History Podcast.” The podcast was not enough to go on, and Coppa’s sons did not respond to Michael. It took a month, but Michael tracked down a death certificate from Florida, and Coppa’s obit ran more than a year after he died.

The other details in those top paragraphs can also prove difficult; sometimes there might be conflicting information about a person’s age, or The Times will have to cite several sources.

“If you’re an extremely careful reader of obituaries,” said Alex Traub, an obituary reporter and a former news assistant, “you can sort of glean how much work goes into such a torturous confirmation graph.”

People accumulate a staggering number of facts over a lifetime, which obituaries try to include: where they went to school, when they married, who survives them. But when a notable person dies, the first thing many readers want to know is how.

The Times always tries to include the cause of death for that reason, though some families would rather not specify. They may have a number of objections, including when the cause is suicide, as Clay Risen, an obituaries reporter, recently wrote.

In a pinch, we can say that the family confirmed the death but would not specify the cause. But if the cause is public knowledge and we can establish it through a trusted source, like a medical examiner’s office, The Times generally includes the detail.

The Right Tone

The Times tries to write high-profile obituaries in advance. When the time comes to run them, someone, usually a news assistant, calls a grieving family member to confirm the details.

“You, as the news assistant, are the one who’s negotiating that borderland between how to be civil and considerate to a family,” Alex said, “and how to cope with the insatiable hunger of a news organization.”

Tone is critical. Alex said that at first he avoided condolences, which he worried might ring hollow. But he soon found that “expressions of sympathy that you might find trite, in my experience, matter to people.”

Ash Wu, a news assistant and a writer for the desk, said she often uses the phrase “I’m sorry for your loss.”

“Because I am,” she said, “and that feels like a genuine thing that you would say to someone right after they’ve lost someone that they love.”

Sometimes, she said, rather than finding the call intrusive, family members are grateful for the conversation.

“I think a lot of people do want to regard you as a shoulder to lean on,” Ash said.

The Deadline Crunch

Ideally, an obituary won’t take as long as Coppa’s to confirm: Like any other story, it has a deadline. Last fall, Ash was on the subway going to the office when she saw a Slack message saying that Hulk Hogan, the professional wrestler, had died. She ran off the train and into Union Square Park.

“I remember just sitting on a park bench with my phone in my hand, going on FamilyTreeNow and calling every single person that’s related to Hulk Hogan,” Ash said, referring to the genealogy database.

“I actually didn’t end up getting Hulk Hogan’s confirmation that day,” she added, “and that’s something that I’ll always regret.” (The article ended up attributing Hogan’s death to a police statement.)

Alex faced similar pressure while confirming the death of David Crosby, the folk-rock star, when he died in 2023. Alex cold-called anyone he could find with a connection to Crosby, with no luck.

Then he received a text from a number linked to someone named Patricia Dance, who he thought might be Crosby’s sister-in-law. Dance confirmed that Crosby had died, but provided no other information and asked Alex not to call. Alex had other details to confirm, but he thought a long text would seem intrusive. So he asked just one thing: “You’re his wife’s sister, right?”

“Yes, I am,” Dance said. The obituary went up with Dance as The Times’s source. Other outlets including The Associated Press quickly followed, several attributing the news to The Times.

Rarely, one of our journalists reaches someone who is still alive. That happened to me in 2011, when the desk heard that Jack Sheldon had died. He was a jazz trumpeter and singer remembered for vocalizing the “Schoolhouse Rock!” songs “I’m Just a Bill” and “Conjunction Junction.”

I called a number linked to Sheldon, and his partner answered the phone. My memory of the call is foggy, but when she said that Sheldon was sitting beside her on the couch, very much alive, I may have asked: “Are you sure?”

When Mr. Sheldon died nine years later, his death was announced by his manager and partner. She did not say where he died or specify the cause.

The post Step 1 of Reporting an Obituary: Confirming Someone Is Actually Dead appeared first on New York Times.

A young Kennedy joined the Kennedy Center fight, on the outside looking in
News

A young Kennedy joined the Kennedy Center fight, on the outside looking in

by Washington Post
November 20, 2026

In September, a staff member of the Washington Litigation Group — the law firm representing Rep. Joyce Beatty (D-Ohio) in ...

Read more
News

The staggering amount Johnny Depp has earned — and lost — during his decades-long career

November 20, 2026
News

Expert sounds alarm over ‘crisis’ quietly unfolding at Trump’s DOJ: ‘Hard to comprehend’

November 20, 2026
News

Step 1 of Reporting an Obituary: Confirming Someone Is Actually Dead

November 20, 2026
News

Collective[i] cofounder: 76% of executives think their companies are AI leaders. Only 10% are

November 20, 2026
Mysterious illness tied to breast implants shares symptoms with MS, but key questions remain

Mysterious illness tied to breast implants shares symptoms with MS, but key questions remain

November 20, 2026
A packed holiday movie slate serves up all manner of cinematic delights

A packed holiday movie slate serves up all manner of cinematic delights

November 20, 2026
Testing military drones and electronic warfare in Western Europe can be a huge hassle. One NATO ally has a solution.

Testing military drones and electronic warfare in Western Europe can be a huge hassle. One NATO ally has a solution.

November 20, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026