DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Inside Tribal Leaders’ Fight to Ban Kalshi

November 20, 2026
in News
Inside Tribal Leaders’ Fight to Ban Kalshi

James Siva, the leader of the California Nations Indian Gaming Association, called a meeting to order last month to discuss prediction markets, which many tribes see as an existential threat to their livelihoods.

For decades, tribes have relied heavily on casino gaming revenue to provide social services and fund their governments. But Kalshi — a prediction market that allows users to bet on almost anything — has been encroaching on their business, they said. Eight tribes sued the company over the past 18 months to ban it from operating on their lands, citing laws that grant them sovereignty to decide what — if any — gaming should be permitted.

In a windowless convention room at the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino Sacramento, lawyers for some of the association’s 62 tribes gave updates on various legal challenges — calling the outcomes “mostly favorable.” As sounds from the casino floor bled through the door, a lawyer for Blue Lake Rancheria, a tribe which recently won an injunction against Kalshi, said it was time for action.

“We’re going after their pocketbooks,” said Lester Marston, a Cahuilla Indian who has represented tribes for more than 40 years. “The tribes can get their lost revenue back by enforcing their laws.”

Mr. Siva agreed. “This is absolutely the biggest threat we’ve seen in a long time, perhaps ever,” he said.

Native American tribes are part of an escalating battle in the United States over the legality of prediction markets, a question of whether they are defined as online casinos or financial tools. Dozens of tribes — long battered by displacement and shifting federal policies — say the answer is a matter of survival, and that they must retain control over the gaming industry on their lands.

The companies and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates the markets at the federal level, have said that they are financial trading tools. But some states and tribes have argued that the markets are no different than sports gambling, which they regulate under existing laws.

Around two dozen states are in legal battles with Kalshi over enforcing their own anti-gambling laws and blocking the app from operating in their states, often citing potential harms to tribes. In some cases, state attorneys general have made the argument that Kalshi and other prediction markets should be banned altogether.

Judges have issued mixed decisions in the lawsuits, and the cases are expected to eventually reach the Supreme Court. To hurry that decision, a coalition of 145 tribes wrote a letter last month asking the Supreme Court to address whether prediction market platforms can offer sports betting outside established federal, state and tribal gaming laws.

Tribes have long been granted the authority to govern themselves, legal experts said.

“Funding support is evaporating,” said Ethan Jones, a lawyer at Galanda Broadman in Seattle who specializes in federal Indian law. “That’s putting more and more pressure on the tribes to come up with their own revenue to support these essential governmental services — providing basic necessities, clean water, housing for their people.”

“And it all comes to gaming,” he said.

Kalshi says it does not take business from tribes. Their casinos offer a destination and hospitality experience, the company said, while prediction markets allow people to trade on future events.

Some tribes have also decided to join them. Five tribes have announced partnerships with Kalshi in recent weeks to offer their own prediction market apps following permission granted by the C.F.T.C. Leaders for the tribes that teamed up with the company said they did not view prediction markets as a threat to tribal gaming, but as a promising economic lever.

“Economic development is very core to them, and it’s not always easy to come by,” Max Crowley, the vice president for business development at Kalshi, said about the tribes. “Getting to a few thousand active users on these apps will turn into something significant.”

Overall, gaming isn’t in decline, he said. Either way, the tribes who are partnering with Kalshi are “launching financial apps,” Mr. Crowley said, “not launching gaming apps.”

Mr. Siva, 42, belongs to the Morongo Band of Mission Indians, which has a reservation in Southern California between Banning and Cabazon. In 1983, a year before he was born, the tribe was one of the first in the nation to open a bingo hall to generate revenue and provide employment during Reagan administration-era funding cuts to Native Americans.

Local and state authorities threatened to prosecute. The tribe joined with a neighboring reservation to file a lawsuit against the Riverside County, defending their right to operate. Five years later, the Supreme Court ruled tribes had the right to conduct gambling on their own lands, citing in part tribal sovereignty. The following year, Congress passed the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, mandating that revenue from tribal gaming must support social services.

Since then, tribal casino gambling has become a $46.2 billion industry. Nearly 250 Native American governments operate 545 gaming facilities across 29 states, according to the National Indian Gaming Commission’s latest report.

Enterprise Rancheria, the tribe that hosted the California Nations Indian Gaming Association meeting in October, broke ground on its casino in 2016. The result has been life changing, said its chairwoman, Glenda Nelson.

The casino has brought in “enough money that we are all starting to recover from the severe poverty of multiple generations,” Ms. Nelson, 66, said.

Tribal gaming has also faced setbacks. In 2018, the Supreme Court struck down a federal ban on state-authorized sports betting, setting off the nationwide legalization of sports gambling that upended tribal economies. Now, many fear the prediction markets may cause further strain.

Mr. Siva, who graduated from Columbia University with a degree in ethnic studies, is driven by his tribe’s legacy helping to establish tribal gaming. He became head of the California Nations Indian Gaming Association in 2018 and has since been repeatedly re-elected.

Mr. Siva first heard people were wagering on prediction markets during the 2024 presidential election. By the time his association met at a February conference the next year, he had grown concerned. The Morongo Band of Mission Indians grosses around several hundred million dollars from their casino each year, but they had begun to hear about customers using prediction market apps on their phones at the same time they were pulling slots.

Tribes and tribal organizations began having weekly meetings to discuss the markets. In April 2025, Mr. Siva and a handful of leaders from the Indian Gaming Association held a video call with executives at Kalshi.

Mr. Mansour, Kalshi’s chief executive, said the company was interested in partnerships. Mr. Siva explained the need to defend tribal sovereignty, and said he left feeling uneasy.

By that July, three tribes in California, including Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians, filed a lawsuit against Kalshi.

It was the right move, Mr. Siva said. Tribes could lose around 5 percent of their annual gaming revenue to prediction markets, according to early projections compiled by a market research firm, KlasRobinson Q.E.D. (Kalshi disputes the findings of the report.)

For tribes, that means critical funding for essential services like health care, education and elder care. Mr. Siva feared it could push them “backwards in time.”

But the tribes faced setbacks in the lower courts. In November 2025, a Federal District Court in California denied the tribes’ request for a preliminary injunction to block Kalshi from offering sports event contracts on their lands. The tribes appealed the decision.

In May, responding to a lawsuit with similar allegations filed by the Ho-Chunk Nation of Wisconsin, a federal judge ruled that the tribe had “produced little evidence” that its casinos were losing customers to Kalshi and declined to issue a preliminary injunction.

Mr. Siva’s group stepped in, funding an economic impact study for the Ho-Chunk Nation. . About 5.6 percent of the tribe’s gaming revenue came from customers who also use Kalshi, according to the report, putting “revenue at risk.”

States were also filing lawsuits against Kalshi, citing in part tribal concerns. In Washington State, where casinos are allowed only on tribal lands, tribal leaders celebrated when a state judge ordered Kalshi to cease most operations in August.

Another win came in September, when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco ruled in favor of the California tribes, leading to an order barring Kalshi’s sports contracts from their reservations. (The C.F.T.C. this month directed prediction markets to drop any geographic restrictions, saying that they must operate on a uniform national scale under federal financial regulations.)

Not all tribal gaming is equal. Nine percent of the largest facilities generate about 56 percent of the industry’s total gaming revenue. Smaller gaming facilities and those in rural areas will feel the economic impact of prediction markets first, Mr. Siva said.

That could be the case for Colorado River Indian Tribes, which has operated the BlueWater Resort and Casino in Parker, Ariz., for roughly three decades. The casino’s busy season starts this month, when snowbirds arrive in the state, and will likely be a test of whether prediction markets erode revenue, said Rebecca Loudbear, the attorney general for the tribe.

“Their marketing is heavy. You cannot get on TikTok and not have every other ad be for Kalshi,” she said. “A tribe doesn’t have that resource for marketing.”

Driving through the Morongo reservation in October, Mr. Siva pointed out a new health clinic tucked into the valley surrounded by brown mountains. Not far from the tribe’s original bingo hall, now a community center, a new school was under construction.

“Everything that we do for our members is all funded the majority through the casino,” he said.

In Mr. Siva’s lifetime, the tribe had pulled itself from financial hardship, going from operating a modest bingo hall to among the highest-grossing tribal gaming properties on the West Coast. He does not intend to watch it go.

“It’s not just the loss of tribal gaming revenue,” he said, “It’s a fundamental change in how gaming will exist in the United States. That’s what’s at risk for everybody here.”

The post Inside Tribal Leaders’ Fight to Ban Kalshi appeared first on New York Times.

‘Slap-down’: Judge swats away Trump DOJ’s 11th-hour bid to sideline her
News

‘Slap-down’: Judge swats away Trump DOJ’s 11th-hour bid to sideline her

by Raw Story
November 20, 2026

A federal judge swiftly rejected the Justice Department’s last-minute bid to sideline her from a dispute over evidence in a ...

Read more
News

Pentagon Pete Hegseth Cornered on Mysterious Internet Searches

November 20, 2026
News

Hailey Bieber gets candid about suicidal thoughts she had during intense Selena Gomez feud

November 20, 2026
News

Inside Tribal Leaders’ Fight to Ban Kalshi

November 20, 2026
News

Inside Tribal Leaders’ Fight to Ban Kalshi

November 20, 2026
Melania Trump details hands-on role in Ukraine ceasefire that evacuated nearly 800 civilians

Melania Trump details hands-on role in Ukraine ceasefire that evacuated nearly 800 civilians

November 20, 2026
In Shenzhen, Trump treats deference to adversaries as peace

In Shenzhen, Trump treats deference to adversaries as peace

November 20, 2026
Here’s what our readers are saying about Amazon’s threat to raise NYC delivery costs

Here’s what our readers are saying about Amazon’s threat to raise NYC delivery costs

November 20, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026