DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Top Massachusetts Court to Weigh Lindsay Clancy’s Motion to Dismiss

November 19, 2026
in News
Top Massachusetts Court to Weigh Lindsay Clancy’s Motion to Dismiss

Massachusetts’s highest court will decide whether the charges against Lindsay Clancy, the woman accused of murdering her three young children in 2023, should be dismissed following the mistrial in her case.

The state’s Supreme Judicial Court said on Thursday that it would hear oral arguments on the matter in January. In a succinct three-page decision, it said it had assessed Ms. Clancy’s appeal and concluded that “review of the merits” of her arguments “by the full court is warranted.”

The finding by the Supreme Judicial Court follows months of arguments by Ms. Clancy’s lawyers that a second trial would violate her right to be protected from double jeopardy. They assert that trial judge, William Sullivan, failed to properly investigate the lone juror who voted to convict Ms. Clancy, and that the mistrial might have been avoided if the judge had thoroughly looked into the juror’s conduct during deliberations.

Judge Sullivan denied her lawyers’ motion to dismiss the first-degree murder charges on Nov. 9, finding that there had been no legal reason for him to look further into the juror’s conduct.

The judge also denied a separate motion by the defense that asked the court to review the juror’s cellphone records and other background information. Judge Sullivan wrote that such a post-trial inquiry “would be an improper intrusion into this juror’s privacy and would serve to discourage citizens from being willing to serve as jurors in the future.”

After a six-week trial in Plymouth, Mass., which included nearly 40 hours of deliberations, the deadlocked jury could not break its 11-1 impasse. The jury, most of which had voted to find Ms. Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity, had complained to the judge that the holdout was refusing to apply the legal standard regarding reasonable doubt.

Judge Sullivan declared the mistrial on Sept. 4.

“We will continue to strongly contend that the trial court made a pivotal error” in declining to dig deeper after the other jurors raised concerns, Martin Weinberg, a lawyer for Ms. Clancy, said in a statement on Thursday.

The office of Timothy Cruz, the district attorney prosecuting Ms. Clancy, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The hearing before the court in Boston early next year will not be the first time the Supreme Judicial Court considers Ms. Clancy’s case. In the final hours before the mistrial was declared in September, her lawyers made a highly unusual, last-ditch effort to prevent it, requesting an emergency hearing before the higher court. A brief online hearing was held before a single justice, who denied the defense request for an investigation of the holdout juror.

Michael Desronvil, the holdout juror, has publicly defended his conduct since the mistrial, stating that he had no doubt about Ms. Clancy’s guilt.

At a hearing on Monday, Judge Sullivan set a date in late March for a second trial. Prosecutors have not clearly stated if they intend to try Ms. Clancy again on first-degree murder charges, but the fact that they agreed to a spring trial date suggests that they may intend to do so. If they opted to reduce the charges, Ms. Clancy’s case could be heard by a judge instead.

Ms. Clancy, 36, has remained in custody at a state hospital since the mistrial. Her lawyer argued during her trial that she was not criminally responsible for killing Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, in January 2023 because she was experiencing severe postpartum mental illness and hallucinated a voice that ordered her to kill them and herself.

The post Top Massachusetts Court to Weigh Lindsay Clancy’s Motion to Dismiss appeared first on New York Times.

Anthropic Stock Sputters After Historic IPO
News

Anthropic Stock Sputters After Historic IPO

by Futurism
November 19, 2026

Analysts broadly expected shares of Anthropic to careen skyward after its long-awaited IPO — and though they did initially soar, ...

Read more
News

A third Ukrainian strike in 4 days halts rail traffic on Russia’s Kerch Bridge to Crimea

November 19, 2026
News

Jackson Accusers Say Lawyer Tricked Them Into Signing Hush-Money Deal

November 19, 2026
News

‘You have made yourself irrelevant’: GOP senator onloads on Project 2025 architect

November 19, 2026
News

Trump Cyber Goon Left Squirming in Excruciating Senate Showdown

November 19, 2026
Top Massachusetts Court to Weigh Lindsay Clancy’s Motion to Dismiss

Top Massachusetts Court to Weigh Lindsay Clancy’s Motion to Dismiss

November 19, 2026
The founder of Craigslist shares his advice on how to avoid scams and keep your online life safe

The founder of Craigslist shares his advice on how to avoid scams and keep your online life safe

November 19, 2026
White House ‘snake’ plots post-Wiles return with eyes on major Cabinet job: report

White House ‘snake’ plots post-Wiles return with eyes on major Cabinet job: report

November 19, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026