A Democratic senator is urging Congress to secure lawmakers’ phone calls, emails and video meetings from the executive branch as President Trump threatens criminal investigations targeting members who conduct overly aggressive oversight of his administration.
The risk of retaliatory surveillance by the Justice Department, which could chill or blunt oversight as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress after the midterms, is a concern in part because many lawmakers use campaign-provided phones and personal email accounts for official business. Prosecutors have repeatedly subpoenaed communications companies for lawmakers’ records.
Senator Ron Wyden, Democrat of Oregon, said the Trump administration’s “threats to investigate members of Congress who do our job and oversee the executive branch are a five-alarm warning that the Senate needs to ramp up the security of our communications as soon as possible.”
The warning dovetails with concerns cited in a Senate report last week about “the threat of hacking and cyberattacks on senators and staff on their official and personal devices and accounts.” It directed the sergeant-at-arms office, the chamber’s technology provider, to study how “to provide end to end encrypted voice, video and text communications,” including storing data on its servers.
Lawmakers’ communications and data have repeatedly proved vulnerable.
One threat: foreign espionage. In 2024, Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, then the majority leader, was among political leaders whose phones were targeted by Salt Typhoon, a Chinese hacking group that penetrated American telecommunications networks and surveilled the calls and texts of high-profile victims.
Criminal investigations pose another threat. During leak inquiries in the first Trump term, the Justice Department secretly obtained “non-content communications records for phone numbers and email addresses” of two Democratic lawmakers and dozens of aides from both parties, and “sought records of a Republican member of Congress,” according to an inspector general report.
In 2022 and 2023, prosecutors examining Mr. Trump’s attempt to subvert the 2020 election secretly subpoenaed phone logs of 20 current and former Republican lawmakers who had spoken with Mr. Trump or his proxies as they pushed allies to block certification of Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s victory around the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the Capitol. Those call logs, or “toll records,” show who communicated with whom and when, but not what was said.
As Democrats prepare to take control of Congress and vow to investigate Mr. Trump and his inner circle, the administration has threatened criminal investigations in retaliation for oversight it deems unduly aggressive — raising the possibility that it could seize lawmakers’ communications and records.
Mr. Trump’s White House counsel, Will Scharf, warned that subpoenas deemed to lack a valid legislative purpose “may cross the line into blatant criminality” and “may warrant further investigation.” Aaron Reitz, a U.S. attorney in Texas, sent letters to Democratic lawmakers accusing them of planning to abuse oversight powers, citing civil rights crimes and demanding they preserve records and communications.
Any such attempted prosecution is unlikely to succeed because the Constitution’s “speech or debate” clause gives Congress immunity for legislative acts. Still, the administration has repeatedly investigated Mr. Trump’s perceived adversaries on dubious legal and factual grounds, and exposed confidential law enforcement information to embarrass them.
In February, a grand jury rebuffed the Justice Department’s bid to indict several congressional Democrats for making a video reminding troops of their duty to disobey illegal orders. The White House released F.B.I. files last summer showing a former Democratic congressman whom Mr. Trump dislikes had confidentially admitted to agents a decade ago that he had sex with a woman who turned out to be a suspected Chinese spy.
The vulnerability of lawmakers’ communications records stems from ethics rules and gaps in federal law, said Christopher Soghoian, a technologist who recently left Mr. Wyden’s staff after a decade working on surveillance and cybersecurity.
Ethics rules prohibit lawmakers from using congressional resources to conduct campaign business like soliciting donations but allow official business using campaign resources. Most therefore use campaign-provided phones and consumer email accounts for all their communications — even as aides use work phones and government email addresses, he said.
“We have the 100 most important people in the Senate using cellphones and email accounts that are completely outside the perimeter, and the institution can’t protect them — it’s bananas,” Mr. Soghoian said. “Work-related communications of the entire institution are sitting on Yahoo or Google servers.”
Each chamber controls its own technology, and there appears to be little appetite for outside scrutiny of a widespread practice that invites awkward comparison to the scandal over Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server to conduct official business as secretary of state. The sergeant-at-arms office did not respond to inquiries, including how many senators, if any, use Senate-provided phones. Its House counterpart’s spokeswoman declined to comment.
In 2020, as Senate offices increasingly used cloud services like Google Documents and Slack on their own, the Senate inserted a provision into a bill adding some protections. The resulting statute allows Senate offices to ask courts to quash legal demands for their data and permits providers to disregard gag orders and notify Senate offices of such directives.
But major gaps remain. The law does not cover the House. It does not require companies to notify the Senate of such subpoenas, and senators cannot challenge directives they do not know about. Its text is ambiguous about coverage of campaign phones and private email accounts, and it created no system to alert companies when lawmakers are using those.
The Senate sergeant-at-arms office has sought to address some weaknesses by contractually requiring providers to notify the chamber of data demands. But a May 2025 letter from Mr. Wyden to colleagues warned that “significant gaps remain, especially for the campaign and personal phones used by most senators.”
Later in 2025, after revelations that prosecutors investigating Mr. Trump’s attempted subversion of the 2020 election had subpoenaed the phone logs of several Republican lawmakers, senators slipped a measure expanding the 2020 law into a bill ending a government shutdown. It required notification and clarified coverage of senators’ campaign and personal lines.
But it also allowed senators whose phone records were obtained without notice to sue and automatically collect $500,000 in taxpayer funds per record. It would have applied retroactively, creating a windfall for Mr. Trump’s Senate allies — though not his House ones. After a backlash, Congress repealed the entire measure, reopening the gaps.
At a February Senate oversight hearing on the election-case subpoenas, telecom lawyers testified that their companies had created a system to identify Senate-commissioned lines. They said they would notify Congress of subpoenas when possible and challenge nondisclosure orders in court.
They said they were working with the Senate sergeant-at-arms office to identify campaign and personal numbers used by lawmakers. But Mr. Soghoian described a haphazard system, with some Senate offices emailing telecom lobbyists their bosses’ numbers — meaning companies likely still do not know all the accounts that should set off notices if subpoenaed.
He also warned of broader threats. State and local prosecutors seeking political prominence could subpoena communications companies for congressional records. And while reports of spyware on legislators’ phones are common abroad, he said, they are rare in the United States because no one systematically looks for it.
Mr. Wyden has urged his colleagues to allow the sergeant-at-arms office to provide cybersecurity help for lawmakers’ campaign phones and personal online accounts, and to provide encrypted video and audio meeting software. That conversation has largely unfolded outside public view.
“I and other members have repeatedly urged Senate leaders — as recently as this summer — to secure our communications against surveillance by spies, criminals and the executive branch,” Mr. Wyden said.
The post Lawmakers’ Data Is Vulnerable to Trump’s Justice Department, Senator Warns appeared first on New York Times.




