California has barred Waymo from operating its self-driving cars on freeways after its vehicles were involved in at least two wayward incidents.
In response, Waymo temporarily pulled its driverless vehicles from limited-access highways across the United States, the company said on Tuesday. The move represents a setback to the company’s expansion plans.
The California Department of Motor Vehicles, in a Nov. 11 directive, ordered Waymo to stop operating and testing its driverless vehicles on all of the state’s freeways, citing an “an imminent hazard to public safety.” The action came almost a year after Waymo launched freeway service in the San Francisco Bay Area.
Experts applauded the decision by the state, saying it was necessary to prevent more accidents and would give the company time to improve its technology.
“Pulling them back from freeways is more of a firm hand than we’ve seen before, which is a good thing because these are concerning incidents,” said Philip Koopman, professor emeritus at Carnegie Mellon University and an expert on the safety of self-driving technology.
In a statement, the D.M.V. cited an incident in which three Waymo vehicles entered a closed construction zone on Highway 101 and a separate episode involving California Highway Patrol vehicles on Interstate 280 in San Francisco.
A Waymo spokesman, Chris Pappas, said in a statement that the company removed its vehicles from freeways across the country the same day. He noted that the construction zone situation “did not involve any injuries or collisions” and that the company would evaluate the vehicles’ performance during the withdrawal from freeways.
Waymo vehicles have caused problems before by driving onto lanes that were closed for construction. In June, the company recalled 4,000 of its robotaxis for software updates after vehicles entered construction zones in Phoenix and San Francisco.
On Nov. 6, a video was posted on social media showing a Waymo car attempting to pass two California Highway Patrol vehicles that were deliberately slowing the flow of traffic on Interstate 280 in San Francisco.
Matthew Wansley, a law professor at Yeshiva University’s Cardozo School of Law in New York and an expert on the regulation of self-driving technology, said that freeways, in concept, are “actually a simpler driving environment than local roads” because there are no pedestrians, cyclists or cross traffic to navigate.
But the speed of freeway travel poses a different problem. Mr. Wansley noted that robotaxis have encountered construction zones and law enforcement activity on local streets, but those situations are less dangerous.
“When you are doing it at highway speeds, the margin for error is a lot lower,” he said. “It’s very hard to kill someone at 25 miles per hour. It’s very easy to kill someone at 65 miles per hour.”
The biggest impact to the company’s business from the temporary highway ban is likely to be access to airports.
“Highways are an issue because they really need to get to airports, and if you can’t go on highways, that’s a real problem for the airport business,” Mr. Koopman said. “That’s a huge fraction of the value they can unlock.”
“You can get to San Francisco airport on surface streets, but it’s not a lot of fun,” he added.
The restrictions in California will remain active until the autonomous vehicle company makes “effective corrective actions,” according to the D.M.V. statement.
Earlier this year, Waymo had to update software in thousands of its taxis after some of them had driven into flooded roadways.
The post Waymo Pulls Its Driverless Taxis From All U.S. Freeways Temporarily appeared first on New York Times.




