DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Should I Tell a Judge That My Son-in-Law Is a Better Parent Than My Daughter?

November 18, 2026
in News
Should I Tell a Judge That My Son-in-Law Is a Better Parent Than My Daughter?

I am currently facing what may be the worst dilemma of my life. My daughter and son-in-law are going through a contested divorce. What started as a lovely marriage has turned into a quagmire of mistrust and worse; my daughter has repeatedly told me of the hatred she now feels toward her husband.

My dilemma is this: While I love my daughter greatly, I believe she is not the better parent to their children. My conclusion is based on occasional stints helping to provide child care while she and her husband work. My daughter normally spends long hours at a very demanding job in a stressful environment. I realize that this alone doesn’t determine parenting skills, but I have also seen her sacrifice time with her children to meet the demands of her job. By contrast, her husband has provided the larger share of child care, spending more time with the children and overseeing more of their extracurricular activities. He is a wonderful father.

At this point in the divorce proceedings, my daughter and her husband are both seeking sole custody of the children. I strongly believe that, in the children’s best interests, the parents should share custody equally. I think that the children would suffer greatly if they were no longer allowed to see their father.

I’m torn about what to do if I’m asked to testify in court about which parent I believe is better. I truly believe that it’s their father. But if I express my honest opinion, will my daughter hate me and feel that I’ve abandoned her? Am I risking never seeing her again? And if she is awarded sole custody, might she also prevent me from seeing my grandchildren?

What should I do? Should I decline to get involved? — Name Withheld

From the Ethicist:

I realize that there are reasons to fear the divorce court will make the wrong decision. Such cases are hard to adjudicate, and courts are, of course, imperfect. Still, it has a better chance of reaching the right decision if it has all the relevant facts, including those you’re in a position to provide. I’d caution you, though, against being too confident in your assessment of the parents. Your son-in-law may spend more time caring for the children, but your daughter’s demanding job presumably helps support the family, and their division of responsibilities may be one they agreed on together.

If you haven’t already, you should talk with your daughter about your concerns. You might remind her of the good father you’ve seen him to be and explain why you believe that sharing custody would serve the children’s interests. That’s not to say that, if you’re called to testify, you’ll be asked to make any blanket judgments. You would more likely be questioned about what you’ve observed: how much time each parent spends with the children, how each responds to their needs. You can answer such questions truthfully without venturing any general assessment. (It’s also worth bearing in mind that giving one parent sole custody doesn’t necessarily deprive the other parent of visitation rights.)

The risk, as you say, is that your daughter will resent you for what you reveal. Given what’s at stake for the children, this seems to me a risk you need to bear. I don’t discount your concern that your daughter might keep you from your grandchildren. Still, the strong feelings prompted by a contested divorce may fade with time, and she’s used to relying on you for help with child care. So there’s reason to hope that she won’t cut you off permanently.

You needn’t volunteer to take sides in the dispute. But if you’re asked to testify, your responsibility is to give an honest account of what you know, recognizing the limits of your knowledge and leaving the ultimate judgment to the court.



Readers Respond

The previous question was from a reader wondering how much to reveal — or conceal — to a new acquaintance about her fiancé. She wrote:

A friend of mine had a casual, nonexclusive, on-again, off-again relationship with a man for two and a half years. At one point during the relationship, he shocked her by announcing that he had a girlfriend and wanted to end things. But he continued to try to initiate phone sex with my friend, ask her to meet in person and request lewd photos. She occasionally hooked up with him, assuming that he was single again, only to discover that he was in fact still involved with the other woman. After doing some sleuthing on social media, my friend found out who the girlfriend was and learned that she recently moved to their city to marry this man. … My friend wants this man’s fiancée to know that he’s a sleazeball who has been unfaithful. … By coincidence, a mutual acquaintance recently introduced me to the fiancée by email. We haven’t yet met in person, but when we do, and she eventually tells me who her fiancé is, should I tell her what I know? — Name Withheld

In his response, the Ethicist noted:

Your friend believes that the man’s fiancée would be better off knowing about his history of deception. That seems right. The value of a relationship depends in part on its being grounded in a realistic understanding of the other person. And, of course, the fiancée needs to be alert to the possibility that he’ll treat her the way he treated your friend. Even if he has changed his ways, she has reason to raise the issue with him and make her own judgment. I can understand why your friend might be reluctant to bear this bad news. … It’s true that your friend is in the best position to give her a firsthand account of what happened, but that doesn’t mean she’s obliged to take on that burden. … The rationale for telling the fiancée applies whether the information comes from your friend or from you. So yes, you can go ahead and tell her what you know, making clear that your account comes from your friend. … You can simply explain how you came by the information and why you think she ought to have it. She may find the conversation unwelcome. Still, if she’s about to marry this man, she deserves the chance to make that decision with her eyes open.

(Reread the full question and answer here.)

⬥

I’m kind of stunned that you think the letter writer should tell the fiancée about how her man is a philanderer. It’s not the writer’s business. She should keep her mouth shut. — Janice

⬥

Absolutely tell her! The sooner, the better. — Sheri

⬥

The fiancée has the right to know, but she needs to hear it from her intended, not “the other woman’s” friend. If he tells her himself, maybe they can work it out and start again in honesty. Tell the man to tell her, or the other woman or her friend will. — Alison

⬥

I agree that the fiancée should be told, but I think the teller should be the person who had the relationship with him. I understand the concern that the revelation might be seen as taking revenge, but the teller should be able to dispel that thought fairly easily if her motive is altruistic. She will also have the exact answers to the fiancée’s questions. It will be very painful for both of them, but I think it adds another layer of distress to the experience if the fiancée were to hear the news from a third party. — Carol

⬥

We are entitled to basic truths about our lives. If the cheater and fiancé were closer, I would think this principle applies. But in this situation, I believe that butting out and minding one’s own business is most important. We don’t know the intimate details of their relationship. A third party getting involved will surely make things worse. — Gregory


The Ethicist newsletter will be taking a short break and will return on Saturday, Nov. 28.


The post Should I Tell a Judge That My Son-in-Law Is a Better Parent Than My Daughter? appeared first on New York Times.

‘The View’: Whoopi Makes Passionate Plea to Impeach RFK Jr. Because ‘He’s Responsible’ for ‘Many’ Deaths
News

‘The View’: Whoopi Makes Passionate Plea to Impeach RFK Jr. Because ‘He’s Responsible’ for ‘Many’ Deaths

by TheWrap
November 18, 2026

Whoopi Goldberg has absolutely had it with RFK Jr. So, on Wednesday morning, the moderator of “The View” made an ...

Read more
News

MAGA Loyalist Laura Loomer Goes Nuclear on Team Trump Over ‘Embarrassing’ Russia Today Move

November 18, 2026
News

‘This, I’m sorry to say, is just the opening chapter’: Top cyber expert warns of a ‘vulnpocalypse’ after 4 major U.S. systems broke in 6 days

November 18, 2026
News

New James Bond, New James Bond Style?

November 18, 2026
News

World of Warcraft Players Can Access the Witch, Slayer, and Inquisitor on December 1

November 18, 2026
‘Hunger Games’ Is About to Score a Huge Box Office Opening, ‘GTA VI’ or Not

‘Hunger Games’ Is About to Score a Huge Box Office Opening, ‘GTA VI’ or Not

November 18, 2026
Should I Tell a Judge That My Son-in-Law Is a Better Parent Than My Daughter?

Should I Tell a Judge That My Son-in-Law Is a Better Parent Than My Daughter?

November 18, 2026
‘Egomania’: Nancy Mace accused of ‘narcissism’ after admiring her own photo mid-flight

‘Egomania’: Nancy Mace accused of ‘narcissism’ after admiring her own photo mid-flight

November 18, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026