In the three decades that San Juanita Guerra had been crossing into Mexico to fill prescriptions, she never had a problem returning home to the United States.
But last March, officers at a South Texas port of entry detained the then-74-year-old green-card holder. Border officials had taken her fingerprints and discovered a 30-year-old conviction on a weapons charge.
Guerra had no criminal record in the years since, and the misdemeanor had not prevented her from renewing her status three times. Nor had it come up during the hundreds of trips she had taken to Mexico, said her attorney, Wendoli Rodriguez.
But now legal permanent residents — immigrants granted the right to live and work indefinitely in the United States — are finding that their status is not as secure as many previously thought. Attorneys say clients are getting flagged at border crossings and airports by officers who are checking identification cards and flight manifests.
In some cases, authorities are detaining people over decades-old charges that did not come up when they applied for or renewed their green cards and that in the past would have resulted in a citation — not an effort to remove legal status.
The detentions mark a shift in how President Donald Trump’s administration is treating a group of immigrants who already have undergone vetting and in many cases have lived for extended periods in the United States.
Some immigrants, like Guerra, are being accused of not disclosing the charges when they submitted that paperwork. Attorneys and relatives for several recently detained longtime permanent residents said in some cases charges had been expunged or dismissed. They say the omission was a mistake, not an attempt to commit fraud.
“I tell all my clients, if you have a green card, just stay home. Don’t travel, it’s not a good time for that,” said Jodi Goodwin, an immigration attorney in Texas. “They will use anything to try to detain someone.”
One green-card holder, Emiliano Andrade Covarrubias, died in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody last month after he was stopped at a port of entry while returning the United States from Mexico. The Department of Homeland Security accused the 56-year-old of obtaining his green card without telling U.S. Customs and Immigration Services that he had faced theft charges years earlier.
States cooperating with DHS, such as Florida and Texas, have granted the agency access to a wealth of information about its residents, handing over databases with information on criminal records, voter registrations and more. Officers use powerful surveillance, digital forensics and data-mining tools employing artificial intelligence to pinpoint information that could lead to an arrest or termination of a permanent status.
Federal agencies such as the Transportation Security Administration also are sharing information with DHS that permits officers to identify violations that could lead to a green card being revoked — such as tax evasion or staying outside the United States for more than six months.
DHS did not respond to a request for comment on how many green-card holders it has detained. The agency has argued that reviews are essential for safeguarding the country and that no noncitizen should ever feel their stay in the United States is unconditional. Port officials in Texas said they always have conducted these checks and denied following any specific directives or arrest quotas from the Trump administration.
The information that officers are using to detain people can offer an incomplete picture of what transpired in someone’s past, several attorneys said.
John Gihon, a former ICE attorney who now practices immigration law in Florida, described the example of one client who has been a permanent resident for decades and accidentally registered to vote after receiving the forms in the mail. While traveling back to the United States recently, ICE detained him at the airport.
In court, Gihon demonstrated that his client had not falsely claimed to be a citizen on the voter-registration forms. The local supervisor of elections wrote a letter apologizing for mistakenly processing the registration. Gihon did not name the client, saying he wanted to protect the man’s identity.
“It wasn’t the crime of the century,” Gihon said. “We won his case, and he kept his green card. But he didn’t deserve to sleep on a pee-stained mattress in detention for weeks. That’s unnecessary.”
Lawful permanent residents must disclose any criminal history when seeking a green card, even if the charge ultimately was dismissed, in addition to other information such as financial records.
Attorneys and advocates said many lawful permanent residents successfully challenge their detentions in immigration court and keep their green cards. But being held for weeks or months is nonetheless challenging for both the individual and their family.
Andrade Covarrubias, the man found dead at a South Texas detention center in October, spent months fighting his case as his health deteriorated. The longtime Dallas resident obtained a green card in 2019, and ran a contracting and painting business with his son. He had been charged with theft in 2004. His daughter Estefani Andrade said he had taken a ladder after a client failed to pay him.
Monica Yoas, an ICE spokeswoman, said in a statement that Andrade Covarrubias was attempting to enter Laredo, Texas, on June 26 when agents determined he had “obtained status through fraudulent means by failing to disclose his previous arrest during the review process.” She added that “He was receiving due process.”
Dallas County records show the father of three pleaded no contest to the misdemeanor charge. He received deferred adjudication from the judge — meaning it did not appear as a conviction on his record. Andrade Covarrubias served probation and had the option of having the charge expunged.
Texas border attorney Jaime Diez said he has handled at least 100 cases in the last 18 months in which green-card holders were detained. In several, he said, officers acted on information that proved incorrect. He described the case of a 65-year-old woman who had gone to Mexico for a church retreat. When she returned, officers questioned whether she had registered to vote in 1995.
The woman, whom Diez declined to name, has had a green card since 1987. She was detained for 10 days, and the case against her was dismissed because officers were unable to prove that she had indeed registered.
“They are focusing on finding things to make you ineligible to stay here,” he said. “And they are doing it without any consequences.”
Andrade Covarrubias, who ICE said had been receiving proper care and had a “documented medical history of diabetes, hypertension, and anxiety,” was found unresponsive Oct. 17 in his detention bed. He was pronounced dead moments later. Andrade said it was clear from her father’s deterioration that he was not receiving adequate care or his medications regularly while detained.
“We have always felt that the circumstances surrounding his case and the way he was treated deserved to be heard,” said Andrade, who helped her father complete the green-card paperwork and process as a teenager. “We don’t want what happened to him to be forgotten.”
In Guerra’s case, the September 1994 weapons charge stemmed from a family crisis and a mistake, said her daughter Carla Gomez. One of Guerra’s teenage children had been struggling with suicidal thoughts and obtained a gun. The single mother took the gun and put it in her purse, Guerra said in an interview.
Two days later, Guerra went to pick up her sister at McAllen International Airport in Texas’s Rio Grande Valley. While there, airport security detected the unloaded pistol and charged her with unlawfully carrying a weapon, according to Hidalgo County court records.
Guerra said her attorney at the time advised her to plead guilty to the misdemeanor charge. She paid a fine and was briefly on probation. Then the case was dismissed.
Guerra, now 75, obtained her green card a decade before the incident with the firearm. Authorities did not terminate her status as a result of the charge, and Guerra said she mistakenly thought it had been wiped from her record. A notary public erroneously advised her that she didn’t need to disclose it on future applications, she added.
But on March 2, officials at the Progreso port of entry — a popular crossing for medical tourists and day shoppers — took Guerra’s fingerprints after she forgot her green card at home. One of her daughters brought the documents to the port office. They expected the matter to clear up.
But the biometric database pinged Guerra’s 30-year-old conviction.
“Yo cumplí con todo. … Se lo expliqué,” Guerra recalled telling the officer. “I’m done with that. … I explained what happened.”
ICE officers shackled her. She spent 22 days in detention, where relatives say she didn’t sleep or eat well. Guerra said younger detainees took pity on her and found extra mats to give the older woman more cushion for her ailing hip. But nothing helped. She became severely disoriented and weak.
Gomez, her daughter, said fellow detainees contacted her, saying that if she didn’t get Guerra out soon, the woman would die there. The family rallied community support, an attorney immediately filed for a bond hearing, and an immigration judge granted the request.
“I had to move quickly because she was declining rapidly in detention,” said Rodriguez, her attorney.
Guerra was outfitted with an ankle bracelet to track her whereabouts, though it was later removed after she raised health concerns. Her family is still trying to pay back the $15,000 they borrowed to secure her release. She has a hearing scheduled for later this month.
The post They had green cards for years. Then ICE detained them. appeared first on Washington Post.




