DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

‘Downstate’ Review: How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished?

November 16, 2026
in News
‘Downstate’ Review: How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished?

“Am I being detained? Am I being detained?” In a grimy, gray-brown living room somewhere in Southern Illinois, a one-sided interrogation is going on. A young woman, Effie (Ivy Wolk), flops casually on a bench. A stern-faced probation officer, Ivy (Liza Colón-Zayas), keeps trying to give her the third degree, but — “I do not consent to the question,” Effie yawns, not even looking up from her phone. “Am I being detained?”

Listening to Effie’s deliberately nasal drone may feel like cracking a tooth, but this is actually the rare, cheering exchange in Bruce Norris’s “Downstate.” The nausea-inducing, adrenaline-pumping moral drama — revived by the director Joe Mantello in a Broadway production that opened on Sunday at the Booth Theater — teems with furious argument, but rarely does anyone win a quarrel. Effie wins this one.

Ivy isn’t her probation officer, and this isn’t Effie’s house. The four men who do live in this dreary group home, operated for sex offenders who can’t find housing, are technically out of prison, but their release conditions (and various registry requirements) keep them on a tether. Unlike Effie, they can’t ignore Ivy’s commands. They aren’t allowed to shop at particular grocery stores or use the internet because society cannot stop punishing them.

Is there a limit to how much they should be punished? At one point, a character shouts that sex offenders should all simply choose death. The afternoon that I saw the play, a person in the audience clapped.

That disgusting applause was not the only thing that turned my stomach in “Downstate.” Norris, king of feel-bad comedies, does have compassion, but he distributes it in unusual, deliberately shocking ways. He hates “right-thinking” puritans; he loathes liberal pieties. (He often tosses some slurs into his dialogue.) He wrote an uneasy satire about child abuse (“The Pain and the Itch”), he wrote an uneasy satire about racism, political correctness and suicide (“Clybourne Park,” which won the 2011 Pulitzer Prize for drama). His sensibility is “comic” in the way Dante’s was. Here’s hell, they both say. See what you think.

In “Downstate,” some of the four roommates are more open about their crimes than others. The most yearningly apologetic among them is Fred (Francis Guinan), who groomed and assaulted two of his piano students 30 years ago. The play begins as one of these now grown-up boys — the depressive Andy (Thomas Sadoski) — arrives, hoping to confront Fred. Andy’s bossy wife, Em (Cassie Beck), urges him on, though her encouragement tends to interrupt a lot. (Fred offers Andy hot cocoa, which is either creepy or kind.)

Norris is interested in how we apportion sympathy, and so he makes Fred — a monster to Andy — as vulnerable as possible. Fred requires care: He can get around in his wheelchair, but he’s clearly unwell, so he can’t play his keyboard anymore, much less offer a physical threat. Guinan’s gee-shucks version of Fred is basically the word “golly” and a cloud of talcum powder. The man barely has edges.

His protector in the house is the onetime actor Dee (K. Todd Freeman), who, decades ago during a touring production of “Peter Pan,” had a “sexual relationship” with a 14-year-old playing “one of the Lost Boys by the name of ‘Tootles.’” The consonants and plosives in that phrase indicate how linguistically deft Norris can be. The statutory rape situation is not at all funny, but the word “Tootles” — bitten into two irritated morsels by the excellent Freeman — is.

The other two men in the house, the combative go-getter Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee) and the shy Bible-clutcher Felix (Adrian Martinez) add their own tensions to the group. Every person thinks that he or she is being unfairly treated. Gio and his co-worker, the insouciant Effie, squabble loudly; Felix retreats from the noise into his alcove bedroom, where a painting of Jesus looks sweetly down. (Scott Pask designed the grim set; Heather Gilbert’s lighting gives it a queasy shade of old oatmeal.)

Freeman, giving the performance of a lifetime as Dee, dominates “Downstate.” Whatever Dee has done (and believes about underage consent), he is the play’s conscience, and, in a way, its accountant and litigator. He knows when to tell Felix to ask for a lawyer; he knows, to the penny, how much each man owes for groceries. In argument, he’s devastating — drawling and funny, then quick as a viper. Dee doesn’t deny the men’s guilt, but he does insist on perspective and rationality.

“Lotta things worse than death,” says Andy, reflecting on his trauma at Fred’s hands three decades ago. “Worse than death?” Dee asks. He just wants to be sure he heard Andy right. It’s relevant because people really would be happy to kill him and his roommates — there’s a baseball bat in the foyer, just in case someone makes it through the door.

When “Downstate” had its premiere in 2018 at Steppenwolf in Chicago, the director Pam MacKinnon presided over a show quite similar to Mantello’s version; I saw MacKinnon’s production Off Broadway at Playwrights Horizons in 2022. Freeman and Guinan starred in both of those earlier productions, and they carry with them the exquisite portraits they started work on at least 8 years ago.

In this production, though, Norris’s bent toward melodrama seems more prevalent — perhaps because of the larger theater, perhaps because of one rather too-heightened performance. Supposedly surprising developments are long telegraphed, and a certain broadness sets in, late in the second act. Norris tends to blunt his own razor’s edge whenever he writes for Andy, whose shrieking “I am the victim!” does give away the wellspring of Norris’s contempt. It’s regrettable, therefore, that Sadoski so exaggerates Andy’s character. Mantello’s direction is meticulous in almost every other respect, but he and Sadoski crank up Andy’s dog-in-the-manger affect too early on — so Andy’s other weaknesses cannot come as a jolt.

But I suppose Norris isn’t particularly interested in subtlety. He does not conceal his indignation under a bushel: He seems utterly, rigidly furious at the way we use the “justice” system to hide those whose existence we would prefer to ignore. This play insists that we think about difficult things, like, say, the difference between punishment and retribution. The portal to Felix’s bedroom — a closed accordion-folding door — takes on symbolic weight as the show goes on. We keep learning about horrors done by the men, done to the men. What do we fail to grapple with by simply shutting them away?

“Downstate” also indicates that refusing humanity to a given selection of people may have consequences. Remember Effie? Her grasp on her Constitutional rights immunizes her to the authority that crushes the others, or — at least — she thinks it will. Her defiance might not make it quite to the final curtain. In a hyper-surveilled America, all of us are close to a fall that can take us down, out of the state of grace, forever.

Downstate Through Jan. 10 at the Booth Theater, Manhattan; downstateonbroadway.com. Running time: 2 hours 20 minutes.

The post ‘Downstate’ Review: How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished? appeared first on New York Times.

‘Paper Tiger’ Sets Record for James Gray, ‘Club Kid’ Expands Strong at Specialty Box Office
News

‘Paper Tiger’ Sets Record for James Gray, ‘Club Kid’ Expands Strong at Specialty Box Office

by TheWrap
November 16, 2026

The specialty box office stayed busy after a strong start to November with the platform release of Neon’s “Paper Tiger,” ...

Read more
News

Somebody Stole the Original ‘Nosferatu’ Director’s Skull, and It Still Hasn’t Been Found

November 16, 2026
News

Mike Vrabel doesn’t want Patriots to ‘b—h and complain’ but he b—-es and complains about his players a lot

November 16, 2026
News

New York hit with lawsuit over state’s new social media warning label law

November 16, 2026
News

‘Downstate’ Review: How Much Should Sex Offenders Be Punished?

November 16, 2026
Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway

Controversial ‘Downstate’ is the best new play on Broadway

November 16, 2026
‘Downstate’ Broadway Review: Bruce Norris Proves Again That He’s a Great Playwright

‘Downstate’ Broadway Review: Bruce Norris Proves Again That He’s a Great Playwright

November 16, 2026
49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass

November 16, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026