DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

A failed execution, a shrinking death row and a historic moment for capital punishment

November 16, 2026
in News
A failed execution, a shrinking death row and a historic moment for capital punishment

After Tennessee botched her intended execution, convicted killer Christa Pike woke from a coma last month confused and in pain. Her arms were burned and blistered, and she struggled to speak. She had been “prepared to die” for her crime, she later said, but instead became the first known person in U.S. history to endure a complete lethal injection protocol and survive.

That same week, the Trump administration announced its intent to execute the Fort Hood mass shooter by firing squad, reversing its plan to live-stream the death after a sharp public rebuke.

Then California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) moved to commute the death sentences of 548 state prisoners in a historic — and controversial — decision that could empty more than a quarter of the U.S. death row population.

Taken together, the three high-profile moments have refocused attention on the death penalty in the United States, where support of government-sanctioned killings has eroded even as President Donald Trump has advocated for capital punishment and executions have continued in several states.

Though Americans remain deeply divided on the death penalty, a Gallup poll released last week found that support has reached its lowest level in more than 50 years, with 49 percent of adults saying that they are in favor of capital punishment for convicted murderers. Support is lowest among Democrats, at 28 percent, and younger Americans, at 39 percent. While much higher overall, Republican support has also waned.

At the same time, the midterm elections ushered in a historic blue wave, setting up a shift in politics that experts said could lead to a slowdown of executions. Democrats flipped some state legislative chambers and won the governor’s mansions in four death penalty states that are currently led by Republicans. In one of those states, Ohio, outgoing Gov. Mike DeWine (R) is considering commutations before he leaves office.

Robin Maher, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center (DPI), said declining public support is reflective of a broader shift in courtrooms and state capitals. Prosecutors are trying fewer capital murder cases, juries are sentencing fewer people to death and states overall are executing fewer prisoners.

“There are always going to be states in the country that are enthusiastic users of the death penalty,” Maher said. “But the long term trend is certainly toward very little or no use of the death penalty at all.”

Since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976, the modern death penalty era has been defined by a public grappling over moral and constitutional questions, including racial disparities, the possibility of executing an innocent person, cost and a growing victims’ rights movement calling for the end of executions. States and the federal government have executed nearly 1,700 people in that time, according to DPI, the vast majority of them by lethal injection.

The unprecedented nature of Pike’s failed execution by lethal injection is underpinning the revitalized national conversation over how death sentences are carried out, how often they go wrong and what that means for both prisoners and victims’ families.

Death penalty opponents, medical experts and faith leaders have renewed their long-standing call to end executions, saying there is no humane way to kill human beings. Some in favor of the death penalty defend lethal injection, arguing the method’s flaws — including poorly trained execution teams — are fixable.

Others are recommitting to capital punishment, particularly for the most brutal crimes, by embracing execution methods the nation has largely abandoned, including the electric chair, hanging and firing squad.

“Capital punishment has been part of our country’s history since before we were a country,” said filmmaker Lynn Novick, whose new documentary, “Crime and Punishment in America,” explores the origins of executions in the U.S. “This is a constant question our leaders have tried to reconcile: Is there a humane way to execute somebody, or is it inherently inhumane?”

The Hippocratic paradox

When he wrote the nation’s first lethal injection law in the 1970s, William Wiseman Jr. was holding two truths at once.

The rookie Republican from Oklahoma was morally opposed to state-sanctioned violence. He had also decided that if the nation wanted capital punishment — and the majority did — then it was the job of state lawmakers like him to make it more humane.

Public executions had been a way of life in colonial America, and the centuries since have been an exercise in maintaining the government’s right to kill while searching for less violent ways to do it. Executions were eventually moved behind prison walls. The electric chair, initially marketed as painless, replaced the gallows. But its use sometimes resulted in charred flesh and flames.

So Wiseman went searching for another way, consulting his own doctor, who declined to help by citing his Hippocratic oath to do no harm, and musing to colleagues that maybe a veterinarian could assist to “put down” the condemned. Finally, he found an ally in the state’s medical examiner — together coming up with a cocktail of hospital-grade medications that would eventually be adopted in every state where executions are legal.

“No pain, no spasms, no smells or sounds,” Wiseman, who came to regret his role, once wrote of the protocol. “Just sleep, then death.”

The medical community swiftly rejected lethal injection. The American Medical Association and the American Nurses Association barred members from participating. Pharmaceutical companies began banning the use of their drugs in executions, forcing officials to acquire them at extreme markup prices through unofficial distribution channels on the gray market.

That confluence of factors led states to experiment with combinations of sedatives and paralytics, prompting a series of botched executions and corresponding court challenges.

One such case led U.S. District Judge Jeremy Fogel, who has since retired, to pause executions in California in 2006.

A death row defendant argued the state’s protocol was cruel and unusual, because records showed that other prisoners may not have been fully unconscious from a sedative when they were injected with lethal drugs, potentially causing excruciating pain.

Twice before, Fogel, now executive director of the Judicial Institute at University of California at Berkeley, had rejected lethal injection challenges as delay tactics. But after an in-depth inquiry, he said the poor training of prison staff overseeing executions was “deeply disturbing.”

California’s “implementation of lethal injection is broken,” Fogel wrote at the time, “but it can be fixed.”

His solution: require a medical professional to observe executions. But two anesthesiologists who were scheduled to be there backed out for ethical reasons after an appeals court said they would have to step in if the prisoner woke during the process.

The California case was the first time a court had ordered doctors’ involvement in an execution, underscoring what the medical community calls the “Hippocratic paradox” — that the way to ensure lethal injections are conducted properly is to include skilled professionals. But asking those professionals to kill is an ethical violation.

California has not executed anyone in the 20 years since.

The role medical professionals play in current day executions is not fully clear, and their participation is not foolproof. At least seven states authorize physicians to be members of execution or IV teams, according to DPI, but details are often unavailable because of state secrecy practices.

In Tennessee, a doctor said he was on-site for both of the state’s botched executions this year.

The Supreme Court has ruled that lethal injection only violates the Eighth Amendment if it is intentionally torturous and has created a narrow legal standard under which a death row prisoner can request an alternative execution.

Those alternatives also come with challenges, including access to gallows, an electric chair or a firing squad. The U.S. military, which has not executed anyone in more than 60 years, has scheduled Nidal Hasan — convicted of killing 13 people — to die by firing squad next month. Last year, South Carolina executed a man by firing squad, but his lawyers said all three shooters missed his heart, causing him to bleed to death instead of dying instantly.

Pike’s attorneys had asked for a firing squad or hanging as an alternative to lethal injection, arguing the IV process could go badly because she has small veins and a blood disorder. State courts rejected her argument, and the U.S. Supreme Court allowed her execution to proceed.

Even as Pike’s lawyers now press for a commutation, her case has been cited in other court filings, including in an attempt to stop a recent execution in Indiana and a lawsuit challenging the lethal injection protocol in Tennessee.

It could take years for Pike’s court case to play out, but experts said there could be quicker impact on state public policy.

“This is uncharted territory,” said Lee Kovarsky, an attorney and leading death penalty scholar at the University of Texas at Austin. “I don’t know if the Supreme Court is going to intervene, but the visibility is so extreme that it’s certainly going to give other actors pause.”

‘Imperfect legal system’

In an open letter to California residents, Newsom said he had decided to commute the death sentences of all condemned prisoners because “we cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system.”

The outgoing governor, who is weighing a 2028 presidential bid, drew ire from some prosecutors and murder victims’ family members. But he said racial disparities in sentencing and the possibility of executing an innocent person pushed him to act.

Studies have found that Black and Latino people are more likely to be sentenced to death in the U.S., especially when the victims of a crime are White.

The District and 23 states have abolished the death penalty, according to DPI, often citing similar concerns. It remains on the books in 27 states and the federal system, though just a few states are actively executing people, and some are facing state constitutional challenges.

A number of governors in other states, including in North Carolina and Oregon, have commuted some or all of their state’s death row populations. Both Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (D) and Ohio Gov. DeWine have paused executions and urged lawmakers to abolish the death penalty. In Alabama, Gov. Kay Ivey (R) has allowed three executions to go forward this year but surprised experts when she commuted the death sentences for two other prisoners, citing fairness concerns in their underlying criminal cases.

Newly elected Democratic governors in Texas and Nevada have said they oppose the death penalty, though what they will do in office remains unclear. In Ohio, Gov.-elect Amy Acton (D) has said she will maintain DeWine’s moratorium. Georgia’s Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms (D) has said she feels deeply conflicted over the death penalty — noting system injustices while acknowledging the brutal experiences of crime victims.

In the last half century, more than 200 people have been exonerated of charges that landed them on death row, according to DPI, and 30 of those wrongful convictions have been in Florida — the state with most executions in recent years.

So far in 2026, the U.S. has executed 37 people in seven states, and more than half of those took place in Florida. Already, death penalty opponents in the state are calling on Gov.-elect Byron Donalds (R) to pause executions.

“I’m asking you, as the new governor, please sit there and review the death penalty and all its flaws,” said Herman Lindsey, a Florida exoneree and executive director of Witness to Innocence, an advocacy organization of exonerees working to end the death penalty.

The victims

The day Pike was scheduled to die, her victim’s mother, May Martinez, walked into Tennessee’s execution chamber hoping to find the closure she had been seeking for 30 years.

When 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was tortured and murdered in 1995, a victim advocate group hung the teen’s photo in its office and vowed their unwavering support.

Decades later, Justice Coalition executive director Robert Bracewell said he remains close with Martinez, who declined to speak for this story. Both support the death penalty, Bracewell said, and both are upset with Tennessee for failing to execute Pike and give Martinez the peace she was promised.

“The botched execution, it’s just the epitome of wrong,” said Bracewell. “I don’t know how else to say it.”

Many victims’ family members say the just punishment for someone who has taken a life is to lose their own. Sandy Friend, who recently rallied in Sacramento against Newsom’s commutations, said the move was a “direct slap in the face to the entire justice system.”

Her 8-year-old son, Michael “Mikey” Lyons, was kidnapped, sexually abused, tortured and murdered by a stranger who was sentenced to death. Friend said she has long weighed the morality of capital punishment. But for her child’s killer, she wants no mercy.

Yet a growing community of crime survivors and victim advocates have embraced an altogether different philosophy. States should end the expensive death penalty process, they’ve said, and instead spend that money on healing resources for victims.

Among those advocating for alternatives to the death penalty are Jess and Annie Nichol, whose sister, 12-year-old Polly Klaas, was kidnapped and killed in 1993 by a man now on California’s death row. They don’t forgive him, they said, but they also don’t believe his death would help them heal.

“We have this criminal legal system that tells us justice is punishment,” Annie Nichol said. “It feels like it’s something that just exploits the moment when survivors are most vulnerable, and it kind of just keeps returning us to it.”

Brady Dennis contributed to this report.

The post A failed execution, a shrinking death row and a historic moment for capital punishment appeared first on Washington Post.

Congress Looks to Charge Data Centers Billions in Sweeping Energy Plan
News

Congress Looks to Charge Data Centers Billions in Sweeping Energy Plan

by New York Times
November 16, 2026

Weeks after voters lashed out at data centers in the midterms, Congress is debating a sweeping overhaul of federal permitting ...

Read more
News

Democrats could raise the minimum wage next year. How high should they go?

November 16, 2026
News

Nearly 2,200 migrants reach Canary Islands in 2 days, Spain says

November 16, 2026
News

A failed execution, a shrinking death row and a historic moment for capital punishment

November 16, 2026
News

Rural voters revolted because they wanted Republicans to help them. GOP didn’t deliver

November 16, 2026
Basketball Player Busted After Shock Discovery at Nigerian Airport

Basketball Player Busted After Shock Discovery at Nigerian Airport

November 16, 2026
Should you take a buyout? 9 Big Tech workers share how they made the call.

Should you take a buyout? 9 Big Tech workers share how they made the call.

November 16, 2026
James Talarico Has the Rarest Political Virtue

James Talarico Has the Rarest Political Virtue

November 16, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026