On a cool June evening, the actress Ashlie Atkinson was playing the role of party host.
Wearing a tousled blonde wig, red gingham top and jean skirt, Atkinson was in costume as Dottie LoBlotto, a “bitter, failed Broadway starlet” persona she inhabits to M.C. “Lonely Hearts Safe Space,” a monthly drag karaoke night.
For the last four years, its home has been at Mama Tried, a neighborhood bar in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, though it originated at a restaurant in Red Hook in 2011.
Her co-host for the evening, Stella Dora — a drag queen performed by Pete Ascolese — wore a cotton-candy-colored wig, cat-eye glasses and a multicolored sequined baby-doll dress.
“God, I love throwing parties,” Atkinson, 49, said between sips of a peach-flavored High Noon seltzer on the bar’s outdoor patio. “The weirder the better.”
While Atkinson has been beloved by locals for her role as Dottie for years, Atkinson has won an even bigger audience on HBO’s “The Gilded Age,” as another party host: Mamie Fish.
For the past three seasons — and now the fourth, which premiered Nov. 1 — Atkinson has played Mrs. Fish, a character based on a doyenne of New York’s high society near the turn of the 19th century, known for her outrageous parties and vinegary barbs.
“Mamie was not afraid of making people mad,” said Atkinson. “I admire that. I kind of wish that I was willing to offend in the way that she was. I have a deep vein of pleasing.”
Marion “Mamie” Graves Anthon Fish, who died in 1915, was the plucky, second daughter of a cash-strapped New York society family. She elevated her family’s fortunes when she married Stuyvesant Fish, the bookish son of the wealthy politician Hamilton Fish.
Mamie Fish famously bucked social conventions with over-the-top parties in Manhattan and Newport, R.I., where she was remembered for antics like serving Champagne to a monkey, and hosting a ball where dogs wore diamond collars and hats. Something of a catty hostess, Fish mocked and entertained her way to the zenith of New York society — with a firm spot on the Four Hundred, an unofficial list of people considered elite and fashionable at the time by Caroline Astor.
When greeting guests at her parties, Fish was known to say: “Make yourself at home. No one wishes you were there more than I do,” according to Jennifer Wright’s 2025 biography, “Glitz, Glam, and a Damn Good Time: How Mamie Fish, Queen of the Gilded Age, Partied Her Way to Power.” (Atkinson voices the audio version.)
Fish’s way with words and appetite for scandal shows up in “The Gilded Age” from the character’s first scene, when she chats with hapless guests on the lawn of her Newport mansion in the pilot episode.
Atkinson said to prepare for these scenes, she thought often about how “nothing is a problem for these people,” and tried to imbue the character with ease. She educated herself on the hostess by reading the 2008 book, “A Season of Splendor: The Court of Mrs. Astor in Gilded Age New York,” by Greg King.
In July, the show’s cast and crew convened to film at a 19th century gothic mansion, Glenview, and the stand-in for Mrs. Astor’s Fifth Avenue home. In a sunlit side parlor between takes, Atkinson rustled beneath a heavy gold dress, surrounded by cameras and scurrying assistants. To embody her character, she said she relied heavily on her character’s extravagant wardrobe, designed by Kasia Walicka-Maimone.
“You’re going to know it’s Mamie from the back,” said Atkinson, between dabs of powder from a hovering makeup artist. “I just have to think like Mamie and the costume does the rest,” Atkinson said, estimating that a complete look can weigh up to 40 pounds. “She gets the biggest bustles,” she added.
“Every element of the dress has something whimsical, whether it’s grapes for a fancy dinner or a hot-air-balloon print for travel,” Walicka-Maimone said.
Manhattan Mayhem!
Atkinson, who is married to Leon Chase, a documentary filmmaker, grew up in Little Rock, Ark., far from the frills of Mamie Fish’s New York. Born in 1977, to a pathologist, Bill, and a nurse, Beth, she was the youngest of three — an older half sister and a brother from her mother’s previous marriage.
“My older brother, Aaron, and sister, Leah, were my first and best friends, and teenagers when I was 6,” said Atkinson, who said that the three of them would spend a lot of time at the local roller rink. Her hours there as a child inspired her to get involved in roller derby as an adult, when she joined the team, Manhattan Mayhem, and adopted the alias Margaret Thrasher, Prime Minister of Your Demise.
Though she was a self-professed theater kid, Atkinson initially left drama to study English at Barnard College in New York. She played alto sax in a ska band and made extra cash voicing erotic recorded messages for a 1-900 number. But by her sophomore year, she felt herself starting to flounder.
“I became super depressed and had to leave,” she said, adding that she returned home to Arkansas, eventually graduating from Hendrix College with a degree in theater. By 2001, she was back in New York to train further as an actor at the Neighborhood Playhouse.
But her pursuit demanded the support of part-time jobs — diner waitress, babysitter, receptionist. She got her big break in 2004, when she starred with Jeremy Piven in the original Off Broadway production of Neil LaBute’s “Fat Pig,” a play about a young executive who falls for a plus-size librarian but can’t get past his new lover’s weight.
“It was an extraordinary experience that handed me a career,” Atkinson said. “It also came with a lot of hard-and-fast messages about what the culture thinks of people who look like me.”
Atkinson built a career onscreen with memorable parts in such films as “The Wolf of Wall Street,” Spike Lee’s “Inside Man” and “BlacKkKlansman,” a recurring role on TV series like “Mr. Robot,” and portraying Juanita Broaddrick, a fellow Arkansas native, on Ryan Murphy’s “American Crime Story: Impeachment.”
Cynthia Nixon, a star of “The Gilded Age,” first met Atkinson on the set of the “Sex and the City” movie in 2007, and directed her in episodes of “And Just Like That …” and the Off Broadway play “Steve” in 2015. Nixon recalled bonding immediately with her on set and “got on like a house on fire.” As an actress, Nixon said, Atkinson, “comes rushing at you like the tide. Like waves crashing.”
After declining a smaller recurring role on the first season of “The Gilded Age,” Atkinson got a call to meet with the show’s producers about Mrs. Fish.
“I was teaching kids acting on Zoom, thinking I’d never work again,” she said, recalling the uncertainty for actors during the pandemic.
Initially, the producers felt she did not have the voice or the easy bearing necessary for the character. Michael Engler, an executive producer, suggested she look at clips of Peggy Cass, an actress and regular on the game show “To Tell the Truth.” Nixon also set her up with Howard Samuelsohn, a dialect coach, and Atkinson eventually found her way into the role.
“Mrs. Fish is hilarious and a good time, but she’s a total nightmare — a snob and a gossip,” said Nixon. “But you love her too, because it’s Ashlie.”
In September, Atkinson, dressed in a black slip dress, was sitting at Lowlands Bar, a cozy watering hole in Brooklyn’s Gowanus neighborhood, preparing for her monthly saxophone gig with Beyondo Band, a pop and jazz fusion ensemble.
“It’s not like I’m good,” she said of her musical ability. “But what I am is enthusiastic and very excited to be there.”
Beyond the feathers and corsets of Mrs. Fish, her next project is an independent film she shot this summer, a comedy called “Wedding War,” which is expected to be released in summer 2027.
“I’m so pleasantly surprised to have a job in this climate,” Atkinson said of the role that now occasionally gets her recognized at airports and bars. As the band warmed up, she posed for a photograph with a group that recognized her from the show, and reflected on the appeal of Mamie.
“She’s so good,” Atkinson said. “She’s so weird. She’s so rich. She’s so awful. She’s so fun!”
The post Partying with the Cattiest Hostess of ‘The Gilded Age’ appeared first on New York Times.




