In the foothills above Los Angeles sits a yellow field with a cement plant in the distance. It looks like the middle of nowhere but lies at the center of a debate about the cause of California’s housing crisis and whether more suburbs can help solve it.
The company that owns the field, the Tejon Ranch Company, has spent the past two decades trying and failing to turn the plot into housing, part of a larger plan to build what would amount to three new towns with some 40,000 homes across them. The development has been stymied by lawsuits arguing it would increase wildfire risk and lead to more carbon emissions that cause climate change.
To fight back, Tejon Ranch is backing a ballot initiative, Proposition 45, that would curtail the length of environmental reviews on large projects, including housing, roads, power and other infrastructure. Proposition 45 would also make it harder to challenge development.
If passed by voters on Nov. 3, the measure could shift the state’s development pattern by reigniting the kind of edge-city growth that built the modern California but is now derisively known as “sprawl.” Proposition 45 is backed by the California Chamber of Commerce and supported by a long list of homebuilders whose vision for California’s future comes from the past.
“This is the Chamber of Commerce saying, ‘We need to bring back the kinds of growth that California had in the 1960s,’” said Christopher Elmendorf, a law professor at the University of California, Davis, who studies land-use regulations.
It is not much of an exaggeration to say housing is the only issue Californians care about. The state’s median home price sits around $750,000, and home buyers in Los Angeles and San Francisco consider themselves lucky to find a teardown for twice that. More than a decade’s worth of surveys place the cost of housing atop the list of issues state voters are most concerned about and the reason a steady stream of U-Hauls continues to leave California for cheaper states.
The root cause of high home prices is a longstanding housing shortage. For the past decade, California legislators have tried to increase supply by passing dozens of laws that relax zoning rules, streamline permitting and curb environmental regulations.
But most of these efforts have focused on building more housing in existing cities, usually by allowing more density or punishing local governments that drag out permit approvals. The idea that the state should also make it easier to add subdivisions on the urban outskirts — which is what Tejon Ranch wants to do — has been largely absent from the policy agenda.
Proposition 45 would change that by expanding the kinds of projects that qualify for streamlining. If passed, the law would narrow the scope of environmental reviews on large projects, making it harder to sue to stop them and setting timelines to prevent the lawsuits that do come up from dragging out. That is the briefest of summaries: Proposition 45 would add 41 pages to the novel-length California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, known colloquially as “See Qua.”
As with most everything that touches environmental law, there is a chasm of disagreement about Proposition 45’s potential impact. Depending on whom you talk to, the measure is either a wholesale gutting of CEQA or a needed update that will help create the kinds of housing and energy projects the state’s voters say they want.
“For decades, anti-housing activists have used the environment as a shield,” said Jason Elliott, a political consultant who helped write the measure. “We’re saying enough is enough.”
Proposition 45’s opponents argue that the campaign is using the housing crisis as a smoke screen. The measure would apply to a catalog of projects that, in addition to housing, includes transportation, water, energy, hospitals and broadband. Opponents say the broadband piece could apply to the warehouse-size data centers that voters around the country have risen up against, while the measure’s backers say it applies only to projects like connecting rural communities to the internet with broadband fiber.
“The proponents are talking a lot about housing, but that is hiding the full scale of projects,” said Aruna Prabhala, a senior attorney and urban wildlands director at the Center for Biological Diversity, an environmental advocacy group that has filed multiple lawsuits accusing Tejon Ranch of violating CEQA.
CEQA was passed in 1970 and signed by Ronald Reagan, then the governor, months after the federal government enacted the National Environmental Policy Act. For all the fear CEQA inspires in developers, the law only rarely kills developments outright. What it can do, however, is drag projects out and keep many others from being proposed in the first place.
The way it usually works is that developers of large projects have to complete a report detailing the impact of their development on the environment and how they can mitigate it. Advocacy groups can sue to challenge the findings, creating yearslong court battles that add tens of millions of dollars in lost time and extra costs — which is what happened at Tejon Ranch.
Tejon Ranch is a 270,000-acre spread at the junction of Los Angeles and Kern Counties. The Ranch began as a series of land grants from Mexico shortly before California joined the United States. In the nearly two centuries since, its rolling mountains and grassy valleys have been central to the idea of California as a contiguous state. The land connects the Central Valley and Southern California via the Grapevine, a 4,100-foot pass that snakes through the Tehachapi Mountains.
Aside from a commercial center with gas stations, outlet stores and warehouse space, most of Tejon’s land is undeveloped. In the early 2000s, as growth from Los Angeles began pushing farther outward, the company proposed three developments. In the decades since, the projects have run into legal challenges raised through CEQA. Environmentalists do not deny that CEQA can delay projects, but they say the process makes development better by reducing their impact or moving them to places that are better suited for them.
Jordan Grimes, legislative director at the Greenbelt Alliance, said his group opposed Proposition 45 while also supporting proposals to curb environmental regulations in urban areas. The group’s logic is that cities are already so full of cars and concrete that it is hard to see how another building will harm the ecosystem. But that analysis changes when a project encroaches on sparsely populated land.
“The changes that Proposition 45 makes to CEQA will create an explosion of sprawl across California,” Mr. Grimes said.
In an interview, Matthew Walker, chief executive of the Tejon Ranch Company, said that while focusing on urban development sounded good in theory, home buyers continued to favor single-family houses in suburban environments. That is the kind of housing Californians are leaving the state to find, so while the state needs more apartments and condominiums, he said, it needs more suburbs, too.
“There is still a strong desire from many people to live in detached single-family homes,” he said. “We sit in a growth corridor and can be a solution to the housing problem.”
Until recently, changes to CEQA were a sensitive subject for California’s Democratic leaders, who were wary of crossing powerful environmental and labor groups that line up against major changes. But the housing crisis has upended that calculation as voters have grown increasingly frustrated about housing costs. In September, a survey by the Public Policy Institute of California found that Proposition 45 was neck and neck in polling, but the measure has already created cross-party alliances. The measure is endorsed by California’s Republican Party and opposed by the state Democratic Party, but there are cross-party alliances on either side.
“CEQA is being weaponized to stop projects of all shapes and sizes in their tracks,” said Buffy Wicks, a Democrat in the California State Assembly from Oakland who supports Proposition 45. “We need homes across the board.”
The post Could Embracing Sprawl Ease California’s Housing Crunch? appeared first on New York Times.




