Like an inedible gruel made with top-shelf ingredients, Ben Affleck’s “Animals” whisks its high-value cast into an overwrought script (by Affleck, Connor O. McIntyre and Billy Ray) to produce an extraordinarily flat political thriller. Affleck plays Mark Kimball, a Gulf war veteran who’s in the final stretch of his campaign for mayor of Los Angeles. Despite being a wealthy lawyer — as his luxurious home, where most of the movie takes place, confirms — Mark is an all-caps decent guy. We know this because a grandiose musical score accompanies him on campaign stops, where he delivers highfalutin, clichéd speeches about fairness and decency.
Mark is also a serious person, as evidenced by the shot of Robert Caro’s 1974 opus “The Power Broker” on his bookshelf. (Though viewers who have read the book might reasonably question the purity of Mark’s political aspirations.) It’s not long, however, before cracks appear in his picture-perfect facade. His gorgeous wife, Abby (Kerry Washington), is having an affair and his political adviser, Sam (Steven Yeun), needs a large infusion of cash to improve Mark’s faltering poll numbers. His housekeeper, Cecilia (Adriana Paz), is requesting a job for her undocumented fiancé, Ramon (Luis Gerardo Méndez), and a man on the phone claims to have kidnapped Mark’s son. And he would like seven million dollars to give him back.
As the kidnapper keeps reminding us, this is the worst day of Mark’s life, especially when a major plot reversal links his handling of the crisis directly to his approval rating among a specific class of voter. So while he and Abby attack each other, Cecilia cries and Ramon lurks about looking shifty, it’s left to Dayle (Gillian Anderson, a treat), a steely, psychology-spouting fixer, to find a solution. Oddly, her white suit does not convince us she’s one of the good guys.
Owing a significant narrative debt to John Ford’s 1962 classic “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance,” “Animals” is a synthetic, soulless product. The supremely talented cinematographer Robert Elswit spins his camera in circles in a desperate attempt to whip up excitement, to no avail. This is surprising, because Affleck (who also played a compromised politician in Kevin Macdonald’s 2009 drama “State of Play”) is a smart, nimble director with an uncommon gift for atmosphere and place. In movies as diverse as “Gone Baby Gone” (2007), “The Town” (2010) and “Argo” (2012), he shaped complicated stories and emotions into rewarding entertainments. Here, though, his most intriguing choice is to deliver entire speeches in fluent Spanish — an impressive, pointless distraction.
Bedeviled by clumsy plotting and perplexing behavior — maybe think twice before issuing murder instructions to someone whose specialty is manipulating leverage — “Animals” never achieves liftoff. The finale alone is so poorly choreographed, its players’ motives so murky, that befuddled viewers might be more grateful than usual for the convenience of pause and rewind.
Animals Rated R for dead bodies, desultory sex and a dirty mouth. Running time: 1 hour 46 minutes. In theaters and on Netflix.
The post ‘Animals’ Review: The Politician’s Dilemma appeared first on New York Times.




