Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey are two of music’s great masters of emotional excess, and it’s long seemed fitting that they’ve shared one of Billboard’s highest achievements: the longest-running Hot 100 No. 1 for a solo woman. That record was set over 14 weeks by Houston’s “I Will Always Love You” in 1992 and 1993, and then matched by Carey’s “We Belong Together” in 2005. (We’re talking about non-holiday tracks; the 22-week reign of Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You” is in a class of its own.) The enduring dominance of songs by these two volcanoes of vulnerability seemed to prove an iron law of pop: Greatness comes from giving all of oneself.
Their record has now been equaled by the 27-year-old country singer Ella Langley, a very different artist indeed. The Alabama-born Langley has been rising in country music for a couple of years now, but her second album, this year’s Dandelion, has leapt the genre’s fences to reach a general audience. Three Langley tracks are in the top 10 of the Billboard Hot 100. The single “Choosin’ Texas” may soon notch its 15th week at No. 1, breaking Carey and Houston’s records. Where those women belted loudly, Langley offers moderation—an appealing commodity in this cultural moment.
Understanding that moment means understanding how the meaning of the Billboard charts has changed since Houston and Carey’s days: Thanks to streaming, what matters is how often a song is played, not only how many copies it sells. That shift has helped country music—which generally seeks to weave itself into everyday life rather than stick out through spectacle—become the popular sound of the 2020s. When Morgan Wallen’s “Last Night” hit No. 1 on the Hot 100 in 2023, it was the first country song to do so since 2005 (unless you count edge cases such as Taylor Swift’s 10-minute “All Too Well,” which charted in the country world despite sounding more like pop folk, and Lil Nas X’s “Old Town Road,” a source of categorization controversy). Since then, 10 other country tracks have made it to the top.
Out of all the arrivals to Nashville’s gold rush, Langley doesn’t seem like an obvious candidate for success. Her voice tends to stay in a middle range, with only a slight hint of huskiness. Her arrangements aim for modern classicism, placing familiar instruments—guitars, mandolins, Wurlitzer pianos—in polished productions that forgo twists or anthemic buildups. Her tattoos and brunette bangs hint at a bohemian persona, but her glossy-looking album covers and easygoing interview responses aren’t very edgy. To hear what’s unusual about her, you have to listen closely, and pick up on what she’s not saying.
“Choosin’ Texas” is a breezy, sad track that sounds like an even gentler version of the Eagles. The narrator is from Tennessee; her man is from Texas; Langley realizes he’s leaving her for a girl from his home state. The details are precisely chosen clichés: She’s tipped off by “the way he’s two-steppin’ round the room”; in a lovely, pedal-steel-drenched second verse, she muses that he must’ve “forgot about the Smoky Mountain rain.” She doesn’t sound mad, or even annoyed, by this betrayal. Because she knows she “wasn’t a match” for the spark of a Texas girl, she “shoulda known better than to take him back to Abilene.” She’s soberly analyzing her defeat—and trying to teach herself a lesson.
Most of Langley’s work features that kind of wry self-talk. Her hit “I Can’t Love You Anymore,” a collaboration with Wallen, is like a lecture from her brain to her heart: “What part of over don’t I understand?” she chides herself when she gets to daydreaming about an ex. On “Weren’t for the Wind,” a single from her 2024 debut, Hungover, she mixes and matches grammatical tenses to suit the layers of her own flakiness: “I’d make a promise but I know later / I’m bound to change my mind.”
[Read: The next great American mega-genre]
Introspection is hardly foreign to country music, but Langley’s coolly reflective approach stands out in a genre defined by social collisions—by scenes of cowboys and cowgirls settling scores. Langley’s mentor Miranda Lambert, a co-writer on “Choosin’ Texas” and an executive producer for Dandelion, broke out in the 2000s with scorching revenge anthems such as “Kerosene” and “Gunpowder & Lead.” Wallen specializes in whiskey-drunk seductions to skeptical girls who can’t resist his charms. The inevitability that underlies many of Langley’s songs recalls “I Can’t Make You Love Me” by the Americana legend Bonnie Raitt, but in the place of Raitt’s devastation, Langley shrugs with acceptance.
One of Langley’s best—and most telling—songs is another current smash, “Be Her.” Over a groove punctuated by polite handclaps, Langley airs her jealousy about a woman who “drinks wine by the glass, not by the bottle,” who “knows being rich is just a state of mind,” and who “stays talkin’ to Jesus.” In other words, she’s fascinated by a good girl—one who’s internalized the advice of her parents, the Bible, and definitely some wellness podcasts. Although the reference points here are Christian, the outlook scans a bit Buddhist: The song’s subject doesn’t desire “much of anything.” Perhaps the person Langley wants to be is not someone else but rather a dream of her own enlightened future self.
The song is a perfectly Gen Z take on “Jolene”—Dolly Parton’s country classic of female jealousy—in that it’s about self-control rather than sex appeal. Striking a balance between mellowness and fun is an imperative for a cohort that’s drinking less, hooking up less, and staying in more. Many other country stars of the moment, including the oft-canceled Wallen and the former drug dealer Jelly Roll, present as sinners struggling for redemption. Langley’s closest sonic predecessor, Kacey Musgraves, has long searched for transcendence—though in more woo-woo terms than Langley does, and with (on Musgraves’s lusty new album) the sort of neediness that often gets written off as cringe.
Langley could never be cringe. She wants love but doesn’t sweat attachment; if her guy is gonna leave her for Texas, she’s not going to siege the Alamo. Partying, sex, adventure—on Dandelion, she treats these less like life’s great temptations and more like small, manageable indulgences. Her music accordingly pares down the signature elements of a genre in which reckless abandon and defiant self-expression have long been central. I think I enjoy Langley’s pale and pleasant songs, but I can barely remember how they sound when I’m not listening. Like nonalcoholic beer and an early bedtime, she’s a delicacy for the overcrowded now.
The post Gen Z’s ‘Jolene’ Is Here appeared first on The Atlantic.
