I recently discovered that my brother — whom I was raised to believe is my full sibling — is in fact my half brother. Our parents separated when we were young, and both of us grew up with our mother in a different country from where our father lives. Since the split, three and a half decades ago, my mother has essentially had no contact with him. She raised us to believe that he was a despicable, selfish man whose behavior had made her marriage intolerable.
As an adult, however, I’ve learned that the story is more nuanced. I’ve come to realize that my mother has stretched the truth and sometimes outright fabricated many important things about her life. One of these things is not coming clean about who my brother’s real father is. I harbored suspicions for years, but they were only confirmed last year when I visited my ailing father. He told me the real reason for their separation: She had been unfaithful to him. He also told me that I am his only biological child. Despite knowing that my brother wasn’t his, my father has always treated my brother as his own. My brother still regards my father as his biological father. My question is whether I owe it to my brother to let him know the truth, and whether I should confront my mother about the fact that I know this. My mother is not one to face facts with grace, when confronted, and she will shut down and potentially cut off our relationship if I reveal to her that I know. I also fear uprooting my brother’s sense of identity when he finds out the person he has called Dad all his life is not actually his biological father. What should I do? — Name Withheld
From the Ethicist:
These kinds of family revelations are never only about biology; they’re about identity, trust and the stories that help us make sense of ourselves. Your mother’s impulse to hide and reshape the past is, however misguided, all too human. Parents often want to shield their children, and sometimes themselves, from pain and complexity. Your father’s silence, too, was probably motivated by a desire to avoid making anyone’s life harder, even if it meant keeping your brother in the dark.
The stories we’re given as children, though, don’t always serve us as adults. It will be difficult for your brother to recognize that he has been living inside a story that isn’t quite true. Yet I hope you’ll choose to share what you know with him, because he’s entitled to the fuller version. And I hope you’ll frame it in a way that makes it clear you’re in this together — that family, for all its tangled roots, is built not just on blood but on care and the choices we make for one another. He may find pain in the revelation, but he may also find comfort — in, say, your dad’s steadfastness. (And if he wants to seek out his biological father, let’s hope it’s not too late.)
The question of what to say to your mother is, as you explain, highly fraught. But just as your brother is entitled to the truth about his parentage, your mother is entitled to know what her children now understand about her past. Your relationship with her shouldn’t be premised on prevarication about matters central to your shared lives. You fear she may find it nearly impossible to talk honestly about these things. Still, as you move forward, it may help to think in terms less of confrontation than of honesty — as a steady opening toward a relationship that’s less hemmed in by secrets.
This doesn’t have to happen all at once. You and your brother are the ones most affected, and it’s up to you to decide what you need, and when. Then you can begin to ask what kind of future, and what kind of relationships, you want to build from here.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access.
Already a subscriber? Log in.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
The post Do I Tell My Brother That He’s Not Our Dad’s Son? appeared first on New York Times.
