President Trump and Vice President JD Vance’s televised berating of President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine suggests that things could be worse between Canada and the U.S.
But when Prime Minister Justin Trudeau steps down in a few days, his successor will face the worst relations between the U.S. and Canada since the trade war of the Great Depression. Arguably they are nearing a nadir not seen since the 19th century.
After a week of confusing signals from the White House, Mr. Trump said he was committed to imposing potentially devastating 25 percent tariffs on most exports from Canada except oil and gas, which face a 10 percent tax.
[Read: Trump Says Canada and Mexico Tariffs Will Go Into Effect Next Week]
If we recall when Mr. Trump first started proposing tariffs on Canada and Mexico, which now seems a very long time ago, he had two justifications. He insisted that the U.S. was being overrun by migrants and poisoned with fentanyl coming across the borders with the country’s two major trading partners.
Mr. Trudeau’s government responded with a 1.3 billion Canadian dollar package of measures to fortify the border. He named a “fentanyl czar,” gave the Mounties two Black Hawk helicopters to fly along the border, assigned a large number of their officers to border patrol and bought a variety of surveillance devices, including drones.
Matina Stevis-Gridneff, our Canada bureau chief, went to Coutts, Alberta, to see the project in action. What she found is that instead of stopping migrants coming out of Canada, the new patrols are picking up people fleeing from the U.S.
[Read: Canada Curbed Illegal Migration to the U.S. Now People Are Heading to Canada.]
Mr. Trump’s arguments for tariffs are sometimes based around the view that the U.S. is, as he puts it, subsidizing Canada. The idea is part of a general argument by the president that trade is being used by the rest of the world to “rip off” the U.S. and undermine its industries.
In Canada’s case, his subsidy claim appears related to its trade surplus with the U.S. That surplus is largely a result of oil and gas exports to the U.S. Because Americans receive goods and services from Canada for their money, the trade surplus in no way fits the definition of a subsidy.
My colleagues Ana Swanson, Andrew Duehren and Colby Smith write that “Mr. Trump maintains that tariffs will impose few, if any, costs on the United States and rake in huge sums of revenue that the government can use to pay for tax cuts and spending and even to balance the federal budget.”
But in their analysis of Mr. Trump’s trade pronouncements, they found that “tariffs cannot simultaneously achieve all of the goals that Mr. Trump has expressed. In fact, many of his aims contradict and undermine one another.”
[Read: When It Comes to Tariffs, Trump Can’t Have It All]
If a last-minute reprieve doesn’t come and tariffs are in effect just after midnight on Tuesday, Mr. Trudeau has made clear that Canada will retaliate with taxes of its own.
But they are not likely to make Mr. Trump immediately backtrack, nor will they reverse the plant closings or inflation that most experts and many industry leaders anticipate.
In Ontario, Doug Ford, the premier, called an early winter election, arguing that he needed a new mandate to “protect” the province from the effects of Trump tariffs.
[Read: Doug Ford Wins in Ontario in Vote Pitched as Fight Against Trump]
One result of Mr. Trump’s tariff crusade and his repeated calls for Canada to become the 51st U.S. state has been an uprising of patriotism and resistance throughout the country.
I spoke with flag makers who, during what is normally a dead sales period, are now scrambling to meet a surge in demand for maple leaf flags.
[Read: Rejecting Trump’s Call to Annex Their Nation, Canadians Rally Around the Flag]
A petition is circulating that calls on the government to revoke the Canadian citizenship of Elon Musk, the multibillionaire whose work for Mr. Trump makes him, it says, “a member of a foreign government that is attempting to erase Canadian sovereignty.”
[Read: Over 230,000 Sign Petition Calling for Musk’s Canadian Citizenship to Be Revoked]
In Travel, Claire Fahy looks into the growing number of Canadians who have decided to avoid using their tourist dollars in the U.S. Last year, Canadians made 20.4 million visits to the U.S. and spent $20.5 billion there.
[Read: Feeling ‘Slapped Across the Face by Trump,’ Canadians Say They’ll Skip U.S. Trips]
And in the lead up to what may be the start of a trade war, Vjosa Isai, my colleague in Toronto, spoke with Bill Fukazawa, who lives in Vancouver and offered the new mantra of many Canadian shoppers: “If there’s a Canadian choice, I’m going to make a Canadian choice.”
[Read: How Canadians Are Making Their Anger Toward the U.S. Loud and Clear]
Trans Canada
-
Norimitsu Onishi has written a sensitive and revealing profile of Sandra Demontigny, a 45-year-old mother of three from Lévis, Quebec, who, after being diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer’s, pushed the province to become one of the few places in the world to allow people to choose a medically assisted death years in advance.
-
Ian Willms, a photographer in Toronto and a regular contributor to The Times, has a powerful visual story of the safe injection site at the city’s Moss Park. Since 2018, it has reversed 3,040 overdoses, Now, a developer is planning to build a condo there. Ontario’s government has said it will stop new safe injection sites from opening, which means this site won’t be allowed a new license to reopen once it’s evicted.
-
A search of the Prairie Green Landfill near Winnipeg has “identified potential human remains.” Matina Stevis-Gridneff and Kim Wheeler report that they “could be the remains of two Indigenous women murdered by a serial killer, a possible breakthrough in a case that has devastated local communities and brought to the fore the issue of violence against Indigenous women in Canada.”
-
In Books, Leah Greenblatt reviews two “highly personal tributes” to Joni Mitchell.
-
Drake has canceled four tour dates in Australia and New Zealand because of what his representatives described as a “scheduling conflict.”
-
Josh Ocampo of Times Insider chatted with me about my job.
Ian Austen reports on Canada for The Times and is based in Ottawa. Originally from Windsor, Ontario, he covers politics, culture and the people of Canada and has reported on the country for two decades. He can be reached at [email protected]. More about Ian Austen
How are we doing?
We’re eager to have your thoughts about this newsletter and events in Canada in general. Please send them to [email protected].
Like this email?
Forward it to your friends, and let them know they can sign up here.
The post Canada-U.S. Relations Continue to Reach Lows Over Tariffs and Annexation Threats appeared first on New York Times.
