In March, when the Army discovered nearly five tons of rapidly deteriorating explosives at an Iowa base, it faced two main choices: hire a company to safely dissolve the chemicals, or blow them up.
The Army awarded a contract to MuniRem Environmental, a Georgia-based firm that uses chemicals to neutralize munitions. But it canceled the deal two months later, citing safety concerns, opting to blow up nearly five tons of the material instead.
The detonation is scheduled for Monday. Residents, environmentalists and elected leaders are in an uproar because the material contains lead, and the blast could potentially contaminate hundreds of square miles with toxic dust.
The Army did not respond to questions about its canceled deal with MuniRem and why it chose to blow up the dangerous material. The details about the MuniRem contract have not previously been reported.
It is unclear why the Army did not remove and dispose of the drums of lead azide before they reached the point of deterioration that forced the decision to detonate them.
There is no safe level of exposure to lead, which is a neurotoxin. It is particularly dangerous to children and pregnant women. It can interfere with fetal brain development, cause cognitive and behavioral harm and increase the risk of premature births or miscarriage.
Earlier this week, the Army stated in documents clearing the way for Monday’s planned detonation that chemical alternatives “offered environmental protections by avoiding a blast plume.” The documents didn’t name the alternative method, but said it could process as much as 10 drums per day, requiring up to 22 days to get through the stockpile in Iowa.
The documents also said that the alternative had been “eliminated from detailed study” because it required personnel to handle the explosives and would drastically increase the probability of an accidental detonation, creating an “unacceptable risk to human safety.”
In a letter Friday to the Iowa governor, Kim Reynolds, the Environmental Protection Agency said that those concerns had been raised by the Army, Federal Bureau of Investigation, and Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
The agencies said that any movement of the barrels, or even removing the lids, could cause a spontaneous detonation, posing “a significant risk to personnel and the surrounding population,” E.P.A. regional administrator Jim Macy wrote. None of the agencies immediately responded to requests for comment.
That came after the acting secretary of the Army, Adam Telle, said in a statement on Thursday that there was urgency to destroy the lead azide because temperatures were expected to drop below freezing, which could “risk further destabilization” of the material.
An environmental group is challenging the detonation permit granted to the Army by the Environmental Protection Agency. The Justice Department argued on Friday that the Army has the authority to blow up the cache, regardless of an E.P.A. permit. A federal court has yet to rule on the complaint.
While detonation of unneeded or unstable ordnance in the open air has for decades been a standard disposal method, in more recent years businesses have developed chemical processes that can break apart explosives at the molecular level. The resulting byproducts are typically nonhazardous and can be buried in landfills.
But such chemical sprays are relatively new and unfamiliar to many in the military who have spent their careers blowing up unneeded or unstable munitions on demolition ranges.
MuniRem presented its chemical technology in March to an expert panel assembled by the Army to find a solution to the lead azide crisis at the Iowa ammunition facility.
Lead azide is sensitive to heat, shock and friction, meaning it can easily detonate if mishandled. And when it degrades, these risks increase.
MuniRem’s technology uses a sulfur-based solution that breaks down explosives and immobilizes toxic chemicals, rather than detonating or burning them.
According to materials presented to the expert panel by MuniRem, and reviewed by The New York Times, the company presented case studies in which its solution was applied to unstable lead azide, including the disposal of 412 pounds of aged lead azide that had been poorly stored inside an ammunition bunker.
In an interview, Valentine Nzengung, MuniRem’s chief executive and a professor in environmental geochemistry at the University of Georgia, said that MuniRem had proposed spraying the bunker interiors and barrel surfaces to neutralize risks of spontaneous explosions. That would make it possible to determine how to safely open the barrels and neutralize the lead azide inside, he said.
“Our position on this is very straightforward,” he said. “We believe that any disposal decision should protect public health.”
Following the presentation, MuniRem was hired in late March to dispose of the volatile explosive. But two months later, the Army terminated the contract.
Dr. Nzengung said the Army gave no reason for the cancellation aside from the fact that then-Secretary of the Army, Dan Driscoll, had made the final determination to order the controlled detonation instead. That involves placing explosive charges around the material in both bunkers and blowing them up simultaneously, destroying the lead azide in the process.
According to emails reviewed by The Times, an Army contracting officer told the company that the decision not to use MuniRem’s chemical neutralization method “was not based on deficiencies” in MuniRem’s proposed technical approach.
Mr. Nzengung of MuniRem said the company has filed public records requests seeking more information on why its technology was dismissed, and has not received a response.
Mr. Driscoll resigned as Army secretary on Aug. 31, after clashing with Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over Mr. Hegseth’s removal of qualified Army officers from promotion lists without explanation.
In a statement provided to The Times, a spokesman for Mr. Driscoll said when he was in office and became aware of the lead azide problem at the Iowa plant, he commissioned a study with several federal agencies that oversee explosive safety matters and agreed with their findings that controlled detonation offered the safest possible solution, though Mr. Driscoll believed that more work needed to be done to notify state and local authorities ahead of time to coordinate a public response.
Alternatives to open-air detonation have been gaining acceptance. In 2019, the National Academies of Sciences reviewed MuniRem’s process, along with thermal and chemical alternatives to open burning or detonation, and found that it “can be conducted indoors with little danger to the user or community.”
The Academies also listed shortcomings of the chemical process, namely that it could be slow. Still, the method “has been demonstrated and validated on several field scale projects,” it noted. Workers could wear personal protective gear “to ensure no contact with the reactive chemicals when spraying the MuniRem solution,” it said.
A January 2025 E.P.A. guide to detonation alternatives also lists chemical neutralization, including MuniRem, as a valid treatment technology for lead azide.
Andrew J. Whelton, a professor of environmental chemistry and engineering at Purdue University, said any risk of fatality was a valid concern and should drive decision-making. Still, “if there was a non-detonation option that could have been chosen and the deliberate detonation could be avoided, then this is a major decision,” he said. “Open burning, open detonation is a practice that is used as a last resort.”
The Iowa base plays a critical role in the nation’s defense as the main facility for loading explosives into artillery and mortar shells used by the Pentagon. According to an internal Army history report, the site was built from 1940 to 1941 as part of the massive mobilization for arms during World War II and sits on 19,000 acres.
Deakin Donley, a retired Navy explosive ordnance disposal technician said the rapidly-approaching temperature shift meant there would likely not be a reasonable way to stabilize such a large stockpile. “Proceeding with detonation is the only viable option now, unfortunately,” he said.
This incident would be “a lesson learned for industry and stockpile management,” he added. “Ensuring routine inspections and maintenance would have likely prevented this, and it will be an example cited for decades to come.”
The post The Army Plans to Blow Up Tons of Toxic Explosives. It Rejected a Safer Option. appeared first on New York Times.




