In a span of 48 hours, Americans faced the full cost of slow-walking technology.
The Microsoft 365 outage on Nov. 12 – which knocked out email for companies nationwide – significantly slowed business operations across the global economy. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) decision to ground flights nationwide for nearly four hours on Nov. 13 led to thousands of flight cancellations and brought the economy to a halt.
While the two events are not technically related, they both demonstrate an off-balance sheet liability. In the classes I teach at Columbia Business School, which include chief financial officers, financial directors, and board members, I have characterized it as technical debt – the cost of hardware and software modernization that has not been done and keeps getting postponed. The problem for Americans: when companies and governments refuse to pay this technical debt, the results can be disastrous.
Businesses and governments alike are focused on short-term thinking – they’re incentivized to prepare for the next quarterly report or the next election. There are always pressing demands on funds today for other worthwhile and needed causes that offer near-term rewards. But I would go as far as to argue that technical debt is the biggest liability, and it doesn’t sit on any company’s balance sheet. This belongs almost to the same category of underfunded pensions and off-balance-sheet leases.
Framed in the language of finance, think of technical debt as unhedged, variable-rate operational debt. The upfront cost of the modernization not done is the principal. The daily drag of bills – related to workarounds, un-patchable systems, and outages – is interest paid on the debt. To make matters worse, technical debt almost carries a variable rate interest rate – it tends to be cheap in calm times but spikes under stress, without warning, imposing large costs on customers and stakeholders. The covenant breach comes when there is a public failure such as the Microsoft 365 crash or the FAA debacle.
The FAA knew the principal. After the 2023 NOTAM outage, which was the first nationwide ground stop since 9/11, the FAA assessed that 51 of its 138 systems were unsustainable and 54 were potentially unsustainable with 58 of them designated as critical. In September 2024, the U.S. Government Accountability Office confirmed that the FAA was slow to upgrade the most critical systems. It’s a warning that no one has done anything about. This is almost akin to a flag concerning the financial statements that the auditor assigns but investors look the other way. Meanwhile the technical debt accumulated.
U.S. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy has stated that “you will have more of these” unless the systems get upgraded. After the ground stop, Duffy called for $50 billion to overhaul air traffic control. Congress appropriated https://apnews.com/article/trump-ground-stop-air-travel-faa-duffy-1a308c557552b2ce24a0532fee0be1912.5 billion in 2025. To streamline this issue, the DOT should publish an annual inventory of such technical debt for the airspace system covering each critical system’s age, vendor support, outage history, and whether its remediation plan is funded. Go further and price both cost of transitioning to the new system and the loss to the economy of not undergoing such a transition. Because management cannot audit its own books, have the GAO or an outside panel issue an independent opinion on the state of the technical debt at the FAA.
This is not just a story about government incompetence. Microsoft is a world leader in engineering, and its systems still went down. The technical debt situation is far worse in mainstream corporate America. This happens partly because boards approve AI and cloud budgets without knowing which fragile systems the firm’s strategy rests on. Boards would do well to ask three questions of management of every company in the U.S.: What is our total unfunded technical debt in Tier 1 systems? What does it cost to carry each year? Under what scenario does the cost go from manageable to catastrophic?
We would never allow borrowing without a balance sheet. But the bill for unfunded technical debt came due twice last week.
Covenant breaches on unfunded technical debt will keep arriving until we start keeping the books and make such debt transparent.
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
The post The FAA knew 51 of its 138 systems were unsustainable. Then it grounded every flight in America appeared first on Fortune.




