DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Jailed in D.C., they watched ‘Crime and Punishment’ and saw themselves

November 20, 2026
in News
Jailed in D.C., they watched ‘Crime and Punishment’ and saw themselves

Light from the setting sun filtered through the round chapel window as the men and women wearing orange settled in to watch a documentary about the justice system they knew well.

At the back of the dark room was Lynn Novick, the director of the new PBS documentary “Crime and Punishment in America,” who insisted in the lead-up to its debut this week that as many incarcerated people as possible get a chance to view it with her. Novick had already visited six detention facilities nationwide, including Sing Sing Correctional Facility in New York and San Quentin Rehabilitation Center in California.

On this day in November, her screening was at the D.C. jail with students from Georgetown University’s Prison Scholars Program, which has offered both noncredit and credit-bearing college courses there since 2018. Their assignment was to watch and listen, then share their thoughts on what resonated.

Among the first to speak was James Kinard, whose sentencing for a drug-trafficking conviction has been postponed so he can complete the Georgetown program. The documentary reminded him, he said, of research he’d done for a class. Kinard said he’d learned that there were 300,000 ways to be charged with a state crime and 10,000 ways to be charged with a federal crime in the United States.

“It’s almost impossible,” he said, “for anyone to escape crime and punishment in America.”

The film, and his own reading, he said, left him feeling like the American legal system prioritized “retribution” over justice.

The robust debate continued over the 250-year story of American justice, spanning from public hangings in colonial times to convict leasing — a practice of renting out imprisoned people, most of whom were Black, to do forced labor that began during Reconstruction — to mass incarceration in the 1990s.

“We learned about our history in making this film,” Novick said.

Those at the D.C. jail watched a shortened version of the full documentary, which is broken into four episodes and available to live-stream for free on the PBS website for the next month.

The episodes are divided by era, exploring the origins of the U.S. penal system; slavery’s influence on its racial disparities and harshness; the FBI’s war on the mob; and the “tough on crime” policy stance that has defined the last 50 years.

Again and again, the documentary asks the viewer to balance society’s need for justice with its desire for vengeance — and how those two square with making communities safer.

“These are the hardest questions that societies have to face,” Novick said. “What is the right thing to do for the greater good when a horrendous crime has been committed and people have had their lives shattered?”

The series, which was executive produced by Ken Burns and Sam Pollard, explores the cultural phenomenon of true crime and TV cop dramas and the fraught history of capital punishment.

Within the first few minutes of the film, former president Ronald Reagan flashes on screen as he discusses getting “hardened criminals” off the streets in an old TV clip. Then came the face of former president Bill Clinton during his 1994 State of the Union address.

“When you commit a third violent crime,” Clinton said, “three strikes and you are out.”

From the third row, a cluster of men whispered in recognition of the famous moment, when Democrats and Republicans came together to pass a sweeping federal crime bill that infused billions in prisons and policing — and reshaped the legal system in a way still reverberating today.

Some of the men and women who attended the screening are serving years for convictions and others are awaiting trial. Their cases ranged from carjacking to espionage to murder.

In their open discussion after the screening ended, one young man, 19-year-old Jordan Grice, said the film reminded him of a book he’s been reading, “Worse Than Slavery” by David M. Oshinsky, which he held up for the room to see.

It explores the vestiges of American slavery that were core to the early U.S. penal system, especially in the South, and how racial disparities still show up in jails and prisons today. There are many elements of popular culture, Grice said, in which the general public isn’t aware of the historical context.

In one scene, the film explains the history of American folk hero John Henry, celebrated in cartoons for his strength doing railroad construction, who may have actually been an imprisoned man in Virginia who was worked to death.

“Seeing this documentary has given me a different perspective,” said Grice, who was recently sentenced after pleading guilty to armed carjacking.

As the group’s time together came to a close, one student asked Novick if she had learned anything about alternative systems.

She answered by posing a few questions of her own: “What is the purpose of punishment?” she asked. “What is the goal of all this?”

Those who worked on the film, Novick said in an interview, worked hard to include as many perspectives as possible from those who touch the justice system: victims and defendants, attorneys and judges, scholars, correctional officers and police.

She wants “Crime and Punishment” to be the beginning of a conversation about the meaning of justice, she knows is complex but critical.

“It’s a constant struggle,” Novick said. “Hopefully we are on a journey to a more just world where this is a more settled question. But we are not there yet, that’s for sure.”

The post Jailed in D.C., they watched ‘Crime and Punishment’ and saw themselves appeared first on Washington Post.

How to bring the citizen-soldier back to campus
News

How to bring the citizen-soldier back to campus

by Washington Post
November 20, 2026

John Spencer is the chair of war studies at the Madison Policy Forum, where Frank Viola is a senior fellow. ...

Read more
News

The Birdfy Gifts I’d Buy for Backyard Birders

November 20, 2026
News

Jennifer Lawrence name-drops her worst on-screen kiss as she ranks smooches with A-list actors

November 20, 2026
News

When Dependence on Tech Starts to Feel More Like a Stranglehold

November 20, 2026
News

Melania spills Trump is trapped in a ‘not healthy’ situation in candid confession

November 20, 2026
Mayor Mamdani was arrested at least twice by elite NYPD unit he’s controversially disbanding

Mayor Mamdani was arrested at least twice by elite NYPD unit he’s controversially disbanding

November 20, 2026
U.S. measles cases are at a 35-year high. Here’s how to protect yourself.

U.S. measles cases are at a 35-year high. Here’s how to protect yourself.

November 20, 2026
Trump set to address Americans after historic talks in China and more top headlines

Trump set to address Americans after historic talks in China and more top headlines

November 20, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026