When your favorite website or app stops working — and that seems to be happening a lot lately — Downdetector is often the first place to report what’s wrong.
The site, which says it tracks outages in real time for more than 36,000 companies, is coming off an unusually busy week, its maps and charts providing one heads-up after another for a global Microsoft outage, a nationwide flight stoppage, a software bug at JPMorgan Chase, computer problems at United Airlines and a disruption to Apple services.
Haym Hirsh, a computer science professor at Cornell University, called Downdetector “the thing everyone relies on if they want to know if something is not performing.”
“The scale of what they’re doing — the number of reports they’re getting — makes it believable to me,” he said. “If I’m having a question, I will go to Downdetector.”
For all its popularity and utility, the site has limits, which the company acknowledged in interviews. The charts it displays can lead to confusion and anger from executives at some of the companies it monitors.
Despite their drawbacks, the site’s alerts make their way into media reports. Its signals on the recent outages were cited by the British Broadcasting Corporation, The Associated Press, Fox News, The New York Times and other news outlets.
Downdetector started in the Netherlands in 2012, the creation of Tom Sanders, a former tech journalist, and Sander van de Graaf. It became part of Ookla in 2018, which was acquired this year by Accenture, the technology and management consulting giant.
When Downdetector launched, it would search Twitter for complaints about outages. Today its approach is broader, but Ookla is frank that Downdetector does not actually detect outages. It tracks user complaints about outages that are submitted by visitors to its website, which often pops up high in Google search results when people ask if a particular service, app or website is down.
Downdetector also tracks visits to individual company pages on its site as another indicator of a potential outage. Downdetector no longer monitors social media posts about outages, as it did when it was founded, according to Raquel Sanz, an Ookla spokeswoman.
Downdetector compares the number of user reports it fields for a particular service, such as Netflix, Verizon or Bank of America, against a base line average of the number of complaints for that company.
If the number is “significantly higher than the base line,” the company says, Downdetector displays a chart showing the spike in complaints for that company.
Downdetector does not verify with the companies that their services are actually down, a point emphasized by Luke Kehoe, a lead industry analyst at Ookla.
“We are a mirror of consumer perception and experience, and we’re holding that up,” he said in an interview. “And we do not, unfortunately, have visibility into the inner workings of individual companies, and it is just a kind of pulse of what people are feeling, and that is what is surfaced.”
That pulse can be helpful in spotting outages before companies publicly acknowledge them. And it can confirm that a problem a user is experiencing with a service is happening to other people and not the result of, say, a faulty Wi-Fi connection.
Mr. Kehoe likened Downdetector to “an early warning system” and “a red flag in the wind.”
But Mr. Kehoe added that “no single data point or data source gives a complete picture.” He counseled users — and journalists reporting off Downdetector’s charts and maps — to “definitely also refer to the official information from the company itself.”
Some corporations have complained that Downdetector’s reports can be misleading.
“Downdetector routinely shows false positives,” said Patrick Neighorn, a spokesman for Amazon Web Services.
“When one provider has a widespread service disruption, reports often increase for other services that are operating normally,” he said. “Downdetector’s home page doesn’t show how many reports each service has received, so hundreds of thousands of reports about a real disruption are hard to distinguish from a few hundred about a service where nothing is wrong.”
For example, when AT&T’s cellular network went down in February 2024, Downdetector reported thousands of user complaints about other cellular services, including Verizon and T-Mobile. But those companies said they were operating normally. At the time, T-Mobile said, “Downdetector is likely reflecting challenges our customers were having attempting to connect to users on other networks.”
Similarly, when JPMorgan Chase, the nation’s largest bank, ran into problems processing transactions on Monday, Downdetector also reported outages at other major banks, raising fears of a systemic breakdown in the banking system. But other banks said they were not having any problems, and JPMorgan Chase acknowledged that “other banks may have been impacted by slowness in transactions only to the extent that they were a party to a transaction with us.”
Mr. Sanders, one of the Downdetector founders, said in an interview that over the years corporate clients have been persuaded that it could help them identify issues before their own internal monitoring systems detected them.
The website, which now gets 500,000 user visits every day, makes money through a subscription service offering a variety of features for clients, including data that helps them spot trends and compare their outages with their competitors.
Dr. Hirsh at Cornell said he considers its crowdsourced data very reliable, especially for outages at large companies.
“When Downdetector tells me something is down, and it’s some sort of major service,” he said, “I tend to believe it.”
The post When Downdetector Warns of an Outage, Some Hear It Crying Wolf appeared first on New York Times.




