DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

Democrats have the wrong plan for fixing presidential elections

November 18, 2026
in News
Democrats have the wrong plan for fixing presidential elections

After winning majorities in statehouses and Congress, Democrats will be in the driver’s seat next year with a trunk full of legislative plans. Among the long-standing ideas gaining traction is electing the president by popular vote instead of the electoral college.

The proposal is as old as the Constitution. At the 1787 drafting convention, Pennsylvania delegate Gouverneur Morris recommended the direct election of the president and extolled its chief benefit: “If the people should elect, they will never fail to prefer some man of distinguished character.” It has inspired cynicism, too. The critic H.L. Mencken once declared: “Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard.” Time has proved both men wrong — it is not uncommon for people to pick characters over competence, and citizens do not always get the government they deserve. Thanks to electoral math, sometimes they don’t even get the president they chose.

To fix the latter problem, a cadre of Democrats believes the timing is right to enact the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. The agreement would require every member state to grant its electors to whoever wins the national vote — no matter which candidate wins the state — to ensure that the national popular-vote winner becomes president.

There’s a better option: a rehabilitated electoral college.

The public will need some convincing. Since 2000, Pew Research Center has found that an average of 6 in 10 Americans want to change the current system so that whoever gets the most votes gets the White House. In 2024, 80 percent of Democrats and those leaning Democratic favored replacing it with a popular-vote system. Republicans and those leaning Republican were more divided in the same year on whether to change the system. In an Economist-YouGov poll last week, though, nearly half of respondents favored replacing the electoral college with a direct election; the other half opposed it or were unsure. Three things are clear: Many Americans want the popular vote to determine the presidency; the current system doesn’t guarantee it; and a change would be good.

The interstate compact seems to clear each checkpoint. To date, 18 states and D.C. have signed the compact, amounting to 222 electoral votes. Once the number hits 270, the agreement takes effect — and Democrats’ midterm showing could get them well over the threshold, after they gained control of both legislative chambers and the governor’s house in five states: Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. (Democrats also won the trifecta in Minnesota, but that state has already signed on to the compact.) Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (D), a potential 2028 presidential contender, has said “the national popular vote makes sense” and that he’s open to joining the agreement. Advocates warn the conditions are too favorable for Democrats to be asleep at the wheel.

The road to constitutional crises, however, is sometimes paved with good intentions. Yale professor Akhil Amar helped develop an early version of the compact following the contested 2000 presidential election but now has reservations, saying he didn’t think “that only blue states would hop on the bandwagon.” Such partisanship complicates a compact that already would invite constitutional challenges to its validity and binding force. The agreement also circumvents the Constitution by requiring member states to award electors collectively rather than abolishing the electoral college altogether, which would require an amendment. A 2024 Gallup poll shows that the public is not a fan of the work-around — a majority prefer changes to occur by amendment.

The problem the compact hopes to solve can be addressed more effectively by rehabilitating the electoral college. The institution is unpopular because it can award the presidency to the loser of the popular vote, an occurrence that has happened several times in history and twice since 2000. And its origins can be traced to the Three-Fifths Compromise’s counting of enslaved people that bolstered the South’s representation in Congress. But its primary weakness today is the winner-take-all formulation that every state employs, except for Nebraska and Maine. Tweaking that feature — by requiring every state to award its electors to each candidate proportionally based on the statewide vote, not the nation’s — would still give the people what they want.

And the states, too. Reforming the electoral college rather than bypassing it would ensure that the states retain their distinct voice. Each would receive one elector for every member of its congressional delegation: House seats apportioned by population; plus two for the Senate, regardless of size. That approach would mean that when choosing a president, both people and states — twin pillars of the republic — count.

In any event, an interstate compact cannot be the end goal. Though its proponents note that a popular-vote system would have changed the outcome of the 2016 election — which President Donald Trump won despite losing the popular vote — it would not have prevented his second term, despite two impeachments and multiple state-level felony convictions. Voters may not always prefer distinguished characters, and democracy can make for bumpy rides, but they shouldn’t have to worry a president will be picked for them. Reforming the electoral college creates more pathways to the presidency without paving over the states in the process.

The post Democrats have the wrong plan for fixing presidential elections appeared first on Washington Post.

‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ is an astonishing American epic
News

‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ is an astonishing American epic

by Washington Post
November 18, 2026

(4 stars) Early while playing “Grand Theft Auto VI,” I caught myself minding my manners. I let people talk. I ...

Read more
News

Ukraine says letting private defense companies buy and operate air defense systems is paying off

November 18, 2026
News

The priciest, most extravagant biohacking tools money can buy

November 18, 2026
News

The NWSL championship brings a fan fest, skills competition and happy hours to D.C.

November 18, 2026
News

‘Not for people who want their Marriott points’: Can franchise-free Mendocino stay quaint?

November 18, 2026
Red state Dem star stranded at airport as Duffy’s ‘hot mess’ flights disaster spreads

Rising Dem wins plaudits for ‘boss move’ with major Nike deal: ‘Picked a better Senator’

November 18, 2026
‘The most ominous signal’: Four ways Trump may pivot after the midterm rout

‘The most ominous signal’: Four ways Trump may pivot after the midterm rout

November 18, 2026
Fired ‘Home Alone’ actor Daniel Roebuck accuses director Chris Columbus of lying about infamous axing: ‘It hurts my heart’

Fired ‘Home Alone’ actor Daniel Roebuck accuses director Chris Columbus of lying about infamous axing: ‘It hurts my heart’

November 18, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026