The cost of higher education and the burden of student loans are always hot topics because borrowing for college can leave families with debt that lasts for decades.
The federal student loan portfolio for undergraduate and graduate students exceeded $1.6 trillion in 2025.
To help their children excel academically, some parents feel it’s necessary to stretch beyond their means to pay for private preschool and K-12 education, including Ashlee, a guest on my show “Dollars & Sense with Michelle Singletary.”
Along with her child’s father, she’s paying tuition for a 6-year-old son, while struggling with almost $230,000 in student loans and more than $30,000 in credit card debt.
So, is private school really worth it?
Before we talked, Ashlee thought it was.
“I think a lot had to do with, I won’t say guaranteeing, but ensuring that he had a certain level of education going into the more formative years,” she said.
Ashlee was not planning to keep her son enrolled until he went to college. For her, private kindergarten and elementary grades were a transitional step to give him a better start in his education.
What surprised me, though, was that Ashlee holds two degrees and grew up in a family of educators.
No shade to parents who choose to pay for private academies, but they are a luxury you shouldn’t buy if doing so strains your household budget or jeopardizes your long-term financial security.
Ashlee went to public schools as a child, and I did too.
“I went to Baltimore public schools in the ’60s and ’70s,” I told Ashlee. “And I think I did pretty well.”
I credit my career success to the many public school educators who invested in me along the way, including my high school guidance counselor, who chased me for weeks to apply for a full college scholarship I eventually won.
Kindergarten builds foundational skills, such as reading and writing, but a private school education isn’t a prerequisite for academic success. How well children do in the classroom often depends on having engaged parents who read to their kids, help with homework and make time to stay involved in their learning.
“You know, the key to your kid being smart?” I asked Ashlee. “If we had a mirror, I’d have you hold it up. It’s you and his dad.”
Although I should add that having involved parents isn’t a guarantee of academic excellence either.
Before committing to private school tuition, run a quick financial stress test. Ask yourself: Can I still comfortably fund retirement, maintain a healthy emergency fund and set money aside for a 529 college savings plan? If the answer to any of those questions is no, the tuition is beyond your budget.
If you have to choose between paying for private K-12 and funding a 529 plan, choose college every time. Redirecting those tuition dollars toward higher education will eliminate or significantly reduce the debt you, your child or both of you would otherwise incur. And given the fact that college graduates earn significantly more than workers with a high school diploma over the course of their lifetimes, it’s an investment worth making.
Follow Michelle’s financial advice show, Dollars & Sense with Michelle Singletary, on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. Want Michelle to answer your money question on the show? Email [email protected].
The post The critical question to ask yourself before you commit to private school appeared first on Washington Post.




