DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

How not to prevent U.S. adversaries from getting the AI goods

November 16, 2026
in News
How not to prevent U.S. adversaries from getting the AI goods

Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang was one of the chief opponents of export controls on American computer chips for Chinese customers. With him out of the picture, calls for stricter controls are gaining force.

This push-pull episode bears some of the shambolic characteristics of the current administration, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent pointing the finger at Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick for allowing the chip exports, and Huang’s close relationship with President Donald Trump coming under scrutiny. But the failure of export controls is an old story. The strategy has usually been ineffective for commercial products, due to both government ineptitude and basic economics.

Export controls are based on the theory that supersmart Washington planners can manage adversaries’ economies by strategically denying them access to key products. The problem is that export controls are ultimately imposed by politicians, who specialize in political calculations, not strategic ones.

Go back to the 1990s, when satellites were the key strategic technology of the future. The United States had export controls on China, which were enforced … selectively. “You asked me to support your economic package; I did,” Hughes Electronics CEO C. Michael Armstrong wrote in a 1993 letter to President Bill Clinton. Armstrong wanted a waiver to allow Hughes to sell satellite technology in China, because without it, “potentially thousands of California people could lose their jobs.” Hughes got its way.

You might say the problem is having ethically malleable presidents like Clinton or Trump in power. But export controls were waived under George H.W. Bush, too. The U.S. imposed restrictions on China on June 5, 1989, after the Tiananmen Square massacre. Just a month later, it waived them to allow Boeing to sell Beijing aircraft with navigation systems capable of military usage.

Surely something like this would not have happened during the Cold War, right? Except it did. In 1981, the U.S. allowed Caterpillar to export machines to build pipelines in the Soviet Union over the objections of the Defense Department. “The company argued that if the Soviets did not buy American machines,” The Post reported at the time, “they would buy from the Japanese” instead.

That was probably true. Businesses often have reasonable arguments for why their products are worthy of an exception, and they know their products and industry better than the government does. Whether the exceptions are granted for venal reasons or sensible ones, maintaining export controls is nearly impossible.

If the fear is novel technology ending up in an adversary’s hands, quantity doesn’t matter much. One evasion of an export control can be enough for a rival to study and reverse engineer an innovation, and getting through once is nearly guaranteed. “In the late 1970s alone, the Soviets acquired about 700 embargoed one-of-a-kind dual-use products each year,” found a 1985 CIA report on the “intricately organized, highly effective collection programs” the Soviet Union used to obtain U.S. technology.

For artificial intelligence chips, quantity does matter, as more chips equal more computing power. But that means huge amounts of money are involved. And the more valuable a technology is, the more adversaries are willing to spend to evade export controls — and the more profitable it is to help them.

Evidence suggests that controlled chips have made it into China by way of Vietnam, India and Malaysia. Even if the U.S. could prevent chips from crossing the Chinese border, Chinese customers can still use Nvidia chips in data centers in other countries, such as Malaysia. The Commerce Department is trying to police remote access with a focus on Southeast Asian nations. Enforcement will be challenging, and even if it succeeds, other countries will step in.

Alliances can help, but even the strongest aren’t strong enough. In the 1980s, a government-owned company in stalwart NATO member Norway exported high-tech equipment to the Soviet Union. Today, even if the U.S. could get all its allies to comply perfectly, there are enough places willing to play multiple sides to all but guarantee that controlled products eventually reach adversaries.

The Commerce Department is not primarily a national security agency. Its website straightforwardly says it is “the voice of business in the Federal Government.” One of the other jobs Congress has given it is export promotion. It makes sense that it would listen to businessmen, and the economic gains to the U.S. from foreign market access are real.

AI chips are a dual-use technology, with both civilian and military applications. But their potential military use is hardly a dispositive argument for trade restrictions. Most goods are dual-use: Militaries buy lots of food, fuel, clothing and office supplies, too. For a frontier technology like AI, the way the U.S. maintains its competitive edge is by pushing the frontier. It would be a worse security risk to believe export controls will keep adversaries from advancing.

Proponents of export controls can’t decide on their story. When Chinese companies export vital goods such as rare earth minerals to the U.S., that’s genius economic warfare to make Americans reliant on their products. But when U.S. companies export vital goods such as AI chips to China, that’s feeding the adversary’s economy. The case for export controls degenerates into a case for autarky, as trade in either direction is treated as a security threat.

Export controls are fundamentally based on hubris. American bureaucrats can’t manage the American economy. Why would anyone expect them to be able to manage foreign ones?

The post How not to prevent U.S. adversaries from getting the AI goods appeared first on Washington Post.

The Bank Outage May Have Nothing to Do With Your Bank
News

The Bank Outage May Have Nothing to Do With Your Bank

by Wired
November 16, 2026

If you were planning to do any banking today, good luck. Customers of many major financial institutions experienced unspecified technical ...

Read more
News

A Specialist in Weirdos Is Playing Bond. Hooray!

November 16, 2026
News

Iowa State women’s basketball coach suspended for ‘inappropriate contact’ with player

November 16, 2026
News

Stephen Miller’s Secret ‘Radical’ Pledge to RFK Jr. Revealed

November 16, 2026
News

California Sues OpenAI Over Alleged AI Cyberattacks, Safety Failures

November 16, 2026
Mamdani’s Move to Disband N.Y.P.D. Unit Provokes Praise, Anger and Spin

Mamdani’s Move to Disband N.Y.P.D. Unit Provokes Praise, Anger and Spin

November 16, 2026
Devin Hester says chasing rabbits through Florida sugarcane fields helped build NFL speed

Devin Hester says chasing rabbits through Florida sugarcane fields helped build NFL speed

November 16, 2026
SNL’s ‘Sister’ sketch captures the hidden burden of caring for aging parents

SNL’s ‘Sister’ sketch captures the hidden burden of caring for aging parents

November 16, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026