DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

The Russian Orthodox Church is waging a war against one word

November 16, 2026
in News
The Russian Orthodox Church is waging a war against one word

Sergei Chapnin is the director of communications at the Orthodox Christian Studies Center at Fordham University and an editor at Public Orthodoxy.

Several months after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, a Moscow priest named Ioann Koval was celebrating the Divine Liturgy, the Orthodox equivalent of the Mass, when he came to the prayer that Patriarch Kirill had ordered to be read at every service. The prayer asks God to “grant us victory.” Koval said “grant us peace” instead.

An altar server reported him. A bishop told him he was barred from celebrating services. In February 2023, a patriarchal decree suspended him, and in May a diocesan church court stripped him of his priesthood. Changing one word counted as breaking the oath of full obedience to the hierarchy that every priest takes at ordination.

On Nov. 20, Kirill will turn 80, and delegations from Orthodox churches in other countries, as well as from other Christian churches, are expected to come to Moscow to congratulate him. Before they set out, they should read the book he published this July: “War: Beyond Visible Causes and Consequences.” It is a sustained religious justification of a war of conquest against a people the patriarch himself calls brothers. I know of no Orthodox precedent for it, and it shows why the word “peace” has become intolerable in his church.

I know that church from the inside. I have known Kirill since the mid-1990s, and from 2009 to 2015 I was executive editor of the Moscow Patriarchate’s official journal. I watched as Kirill modeled his rule on that of Russian President Vladimir Putin, turning the church into a mirror of the state — which is why it could bless the war so quickly and with so little visible remorse. It is also why so many of the priests I have known for decades speak of their patriarch with fear rather than love.

The boldest pages of his book deal with the commandment against killing.

Kirill writes that his opponents might say, “And what about the commandment ‘Thou shalt not kill’?” His answer is that “the one who rises to defend the Fatherland … is the one who keeps the commandment ‘Thou shalt not kill.’” A commandment you keep by doing its opposite is no longer a commandment.

The argument collapses on its own terms. The book invokes the Christian idea of a “just war,” and every version of that idea, from Augustine on, turns on the question of who attacked whom. By the patriarch’s own formula, it is the soldier defending Kharkiv who keeps the commandment, not the one who crossed into a neighboring country in February 2022.

On Sept. 25, 2022, four days after Putin announced partial mobilization, Kirill preached that a soldier who dies doing his duty offers a sacrifice that “washes away all the sins a person has committed.” Orthodox tradition never taught this. Saint Basil the Great advised soldiers who had killed in battle to stay away from Communion for three years. In the 10th century, when the Byzantine emperor Nikephoros Phokas asked the church to honor his fallen soldiers as martyrs, the patriarch and synod refused. More than a thousand years later, the current patriarch of Moscow has granted the request.

Hence the danger in the word “peace.” An ordinary authoritarian state would settle for silence. Kirill’s church demands speech: the prayer for victory read aloud at every Liturgy. Alexei Uminsky, one of Moscow’s best-known pastors, refused to read it.

The text is a prayer “for Holy Rus,” an old devotional name for Russia as a land sanctified by its saints. The prayer conscripts that image into the service of Putin’s war. Asked at his church trial why he refused to read it, Uminsky answered, “I don’t know what Holy Rus is.” He could honor the name; he would not agree that today’s Russia embodies it. A church court defrocked him in January 2024. Meanwhile, the patriarch’s book promises that priests who have served at the front “deserve special attention and corresponding prospects” in the hierarchy.

This is a Russian problem, not an Orthodox one. Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I of Constantinople, the senior bishop of the Orthodox world, condemned the invasion on its first day, and many Orthodox bishops elsewhere did the same. Koval and Uminsky were restored to ministry by Constantinople and serve in its parishes today. If Russian Orthodoxy has a future, it looks like them.

American Christians have a stake here. Moscow markets itself as the defender of “traditional values,” a term Kirill has been using since at least 2000, and many Western Christians, weary of secular decline, have heard in it the voice of an ally. Read the book, and you will see what the phrase means in Russian practice: a vocabulary loose enough to turn “Thou shalt not kill” into a blessing on an invasion.

So when church leaders from East and West meet the patriarch or his envoys this month, they should say the word his church cannot forgive. Peace. They should say it aloud for Ukraine, whose people have borne the full weight of this war, and for every victim of it. And they should say it in the names of Ioann Koval and Alexei Uminsky, of the other Christians Russia has punished for their faith and conscience and of all its political prisoners.

The post The Russian Orthodox Church is waging a war against one word appeared first on Washington Post.

Delta CEO Ed Bastian believes ‘human error’ and faulty equipment led to FAA ground stop
News

Delta CEO Ed Bastian believes ‘human error’ and faulty equipment led to FAA ground stop

by Fortune
November 16, 2026

Delta Air Lines CEO Ed Bastian thinks Friday’s nationwide FAA ground stop came from “a combination of faulty equipment, coupled ...

Read more
News

The Hegseth impeachment vote was just a warmup for the real thing

November 16, 2026
News

There’s a Wildly NSFW Wardrobe Malfunction Hiding in ‘Grease 2’

November 16, 2026
News

You might be pronouncing Nvidia the wrong way

November 16, 2026
News

Measles is here. That demands a ‘zero dose.’

November 16, 2026
Jensen Huang Is Gone. Now What?

Jensen Huang Is Gone. Now What?

November 16, 2026
Gentrification by billionaire: How the rich get displaced by the ultrarich in L.A.’s toniest ZIP Codes

Gentrification by billionaire: How the rich get displaced by the ultrarich in L.A.’s toniest ZIP Codes

November 16, 2026
The Russian Orthodox Church is waging a war against one word

The Russian Orthodox Church is waging a war against one word

November 16, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026