DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
No Result
View All Result
DNYUZ
Home News

‘Trump Has Left Republicans in a Highly Perilous Position’: Opinion Writers Assess the Midterms

November 4, 2026
in News
‘Trump Has Left Republicans in a Highly Perilous Position’: Opinion Writers Assess the Midterms

This article will be updated regularly on Tuesday. Please check back in.

Welcome to Times Opinion’s midterm election round-table discussion. In this article, Times columnists and other Opinion writers who have been writing and bickering and bantering about the 2026 cycle offer rolling commentary, analysis and observations on what they are seeing on election night — and what that might mean for America today and in the coming months and years.

Our columnists and contributors — Kristen Soltis Anderson, Jamelle Bouie, Michelle Cottle, David French, Michelle Goldberg and Matthew Yglesias — will be bantering and debating live in written conversation as the night goes on. We will update this article as results come in.

To tee us up on Monday, Nate Silver, the founder of the newsletter Silver Bulletin, and Katherine Mangu-Ward, the editor in chief of Reason, offered their thoughts and prognostications. Their conversation has been edited for length and clarity.


PUblished 8:30 P.m.

‘Trump Has Done Basically Everything That You’re Not Supposed to Do’

John Guida: Most polls have dropped, and the campaigns have basically ended. With election results coming in, let’s level-set.

Obviously, the polling has been very strong for Democrats. Still, the election analyst Sean Trende recently offered some perspective. He wrote: “A great Democratic year doesn’t mean Democrats take the Senate. An awesome Democratic year doesn’t mean Democrats take the Senate. It takes an extraordinary year for Democrats to win the Senate.”

Is this looking like an “extraordinary” year?

Nate Silver: I’m a big fan of Sean’s, but I slightly disagree. The big thing about midterm elections is that waves are kind of the default outcome, and it’s mostly a question of their magnitude. President Trump’s approval numbers and the G.O.P. position on the generic ballot have steadily worsened in a way that evokes past waves, like the one in 2006.

The one thing Republicans really have going for them is the very red territory in which the Senate states are being contested. It’s not obvious from first principles whether an otherwise big Democratic year necessarily translates to flipping a Senate race in a state Trump won by 14 points, like Texas.

Katherine Mangu-Ward: Every election is the most important election of our lifetimes, right? That’s what we’ve been told, anyway. I do think this one is important. I don’t know if this is an extraordinary year, though. It’s a weird year. I’m more than a little worried about what Democrats might decide a “tsunami” means in terms of how they should govern, if or when one happens. A big blue sweep doesn’t mean voters love Democrats’ policy proposals; it most likely means they’re sick to death of Republicans.

Guida: What are you going to be looking for as results start to come in?

Silver: Kentucky is one of the first states to close its polls, and the Sixth District in Lexington is competitive, basically a pure tossup in our model, even though Trump won it by 15 points. It’s the Republican states that generally count faster. It could be an early bellwether for a Democratic wave or a polling miss.

Beyond that, I think people need to be careful about how many conclusions they draw early in the night, because with all these different tranches of votes — mail, in-person early voting, Election Day voting — what order states report their votes in matters, and that differs a lot from state to state. There will be some red and blue mirages.

Mangu-Ward: I’m kind of obsessed with the Alaska Senate race, where the outcome is going to hinge at least somewhat on the state’s unusual open primaries and ranked-choice voting. So I guess that means I’ll be up awfully late. Like so many pundits, I have full-fledged PTSD about jumping the gun from early results. I’ll be looking for Nate Silver to tell me what to think.

Guida: Right, so let’s talk about Nate and his gut … and the Silver Bulletin model. Nate, both the model and your gut have pointed in the same direction: a very strong night for Democrats, with your Senate forecast on Monday back up to 53 seats for Democrats. I assume that hasn’t changed? Katherine, with all these Senate races showing super-close contests, how are you assessing the elections?

Silver: Especially in the New York Times/Siena polls, there have been favorable trends for Democrats in the blue states: Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan have been expanding their margins, and Troy Jackson in Maine has had some of his best numbers recently (though polls are more mixed there). So there’s pretty strong evidence that Democratic voters are coming home. And you don’t see that evidence in the red states for Republicans, or at least not consistently. Probably a bit in Alaska, but that may be about the various Mary Peltola controversies than any sort of improved morale. The polls are going the wrong way for Roger Marshall in Kansas, though, and to a slightly lesser extent for Ken Paxton in Texas.

If Republican turnout is strong, that could offset some of the votes that Democrats have already banked in early voting. It might not be enough to save the Senate for the G.O.P., depending on how many independents and other Trump disapprovers are flipping, but that would make for a long night, maybe even a recount or two. If those Republicans who feel ambivalent about Trump don’t show up, that’s when you get into the tsunami scenarios.

Mangu-Ward: One more thing about the Alaska Senate race is that they’re voting on whether to keep that unusual mechanism! That seems like a case where Alaska is performing its designated role as a laboratory of democracy quite well. There has to be a better way to do this whole elections thing.

But mostly, Trump decided to make himself the protagonist of every story and every race. Republicans are discovering the downside of that. When things aren’t going well — as they are not — Americans are going to place the blame with the man who said he was in control and vote accordingly.

Guida: Katherine, you said you do think this midterm election is important. Why? Nate, does it strike you as a consequential election as well?

Mangu-Ward: Both parties are looking to claim a mandate of some kind, which isn’t really on offer. If Democrats have an extraordinary year, it is almost certainly a straightforward case of the public engaging in a traditional midterm ritual of throwing the bums out. Should Republicans hold on, they’ll be even more unrepentantly MAGA during Trump’s final two years. One thing libertarians understand better than most is that sometimes all you can do is vote against something.

Silver: Like I said on “The Ezra Klein Show,” it’s basically the last chance for voters to repudiate Trump, and that inherently makes it momentous. Trump had a bad 2018 and lost in 2020, but I’m not sure either of those really produced the catharsis Democrats were hoping for. Republicans held control of the Senate in 2018 and there was a big polling miss in 2020, even if it wasn’t enough to cost Joe Biden the Electoral College. People have just seen the movie so many times where Trump is counted out and then returns. The bottom can fall out of presidencies in lame-duck terms, however, which is why 2006 makes for a natural comparison.

Guida: Nate, you said in that discussion that a rough night for Republicans “would mark the end of the Trump era.” You also noted that as soon as the elections are called, “the 2028 election campaign begins.” As the dust settles on 2026, what will that look like or mean for both parties? Katherine, how do you see the final two years of Trump’s presidency going?

Silver: People should be careful not to extrapolate too much from 2026 to assume Democrats will win in 2028, even if polls are right and they have a good night. But Trumpism without Trump has repeatedly been a losing proposition for Republicans. They didn’t have a good 2018, and they also had a fairly poor 2022, considering Biden’s bad approval ratings. They usually lose things like special elections, runoffs and ballot propositions. The infrequent voters that Trump has some magical gift for turning out tend not to participate in midterm-type environments.

Mangu-Ward: If Democrats do well tonight, and especially if some of the more progressive or Democratic Socialists of America-aligned candidates do well, that will tempt fringe Democrats into the 2028 presidential primary. I don’t think that necessarily reflects what the electorate wants. Meanwhile, if Democrats in Congress spend the next two years going after Trump with various investigations, hearings and possible impeachments, they’re not going to have any policy achievements to run on in 2028.

Guida: Trump’s fingerprints have been all over this election, and not just because he is sitting in the White House and has largely set the policy agenda of the past year and a half. He has also shaped, directly or indirectly, Senate races in North and South Carolina, Ohio and Texas. Is there an alternate universe where this midterm cycle could not have been so squarely a referendum on him?

Silver: Midterms are always a referendum on the ruling party broadly and the president specifically, but Trump has done basically everything that you’re not supposed to do by making himself the center of attention instead of keeping a lower profile. It was probably a coincidence, but the big shift in the polls that took the Senate from a tossup to leaning Democrat came right after his midterm convention. Republican candidates are barely mentioning him in ads, but he’s never been one to take the hint.

Mangu-Ward: I can no longer remember or imagine a world where Trump is not the main character. It’s been a decade, and we have a couple of years to go. But this is the problem with a locked-down two-party system. To vote against Trump’s tariffs, you might have to vote for a protectionist Democrat. To vote against Trump’s war, you might have to vote for a moderately hawkish Democrat. To vote against Trump’s executive overreach, you might have to vote for someone who was happy to hand those same powers to Biden or Barack Obama. There’s no way to use your major party vote to convey that you’re sick to death of all of it or communicate your real policy preferences.

Guida: One of the key phrases of the 2026 midterms has been “candidate quality.” As in, with a few exceptions, Democrats seem to have fielded very good candidates in key races across the country, and Republicans … not as much. Nate, is there a way to quantify what someone like Adam Hamilton in Kansas brings to a race? Katherine, any idea why there has been such a discrepancy between the parties on candidate quality?

Silver: For the most part, the narratives about candidate quality are actually supported by the polls this year. Ken Paxton in Texas and Marshall in Kansas are underperforming by several points each; Susan Collins is overperforming; Abdul El-Sayed is slightly underperforming; and so on, as compared with both the partisan base lines you’d expect given the overall (blue) political climate and the respective gubernatorial races in those states.

Mangu-Ward: At Reason, we have been documenting Trump’s yearslong campaign to push out anyone who is even remotely principled or heterodox from the Republican Party. In a profile of Kentucky’s Thomas Massie, who occasionally broke with Trump, I wrote about how Massie was a dying breed — and then he lost his primary. After a decade of Trump, the G.O.P. is essentially growing a monoculture of candidates. It’s fields of MAGA as far as the eye can see. And like all monocultures, it’s vulnerable to changing conditions or pestilence.

Guida: Are there particular candidates you are rooting for or against tonight?

Silver: I have to be honest: I have my preferences as a citizen, but I’m mostly rooting for candidates that will make our model look smart. And I suppose I am rooting for candidate quality differences to matter. It would be better for the country if voters were less reflexively partisan.

Mangu-Ward: No, and given how things went for him after I said nice things about Massie, I’m not sure any candidates would even want my praise at this point.

Guida: The races for governor have not received as much attention as who will hold power in Congress. Yet Americans tend to like their governors very much. Right now, there are only two governors in the country whose constituents view them unfavorably. Are there any races for governor that have caught your eye or interest you?

Silver: The Vermont governor’s race might be the most subtly interesting one in the country. Republican Phil Scott won by more than 50 points in 2024. (Vermont governors have two-year terms.) But the polls are all over the place, with some showing a tie or even a lead for the Democrat, Amanda Janoo. I’m happy it’s a low-profile race because it’s not one that I’d want to stake a lot of credibility on.

Mangu-Ward: Data centers have been a major issue in the Ohio governor’s race, and I hold the increasingly unpopular position that they are mostly good. (It’s one of vanishingly few things about which I agree with Trump.) Both candidates in that race offered different forms of opposition to data centers. Vivek Ramaswamy ran for president on a surprisingly pro-tech platform, but in the Ohio governor’s race he backed off on data centers, perhaps in an attempt to appease the public. I wonder if that will work?

Guida: What most surprised you about this year’s midterms? Were there issues that were overlooked or candidates that underperformed?

Silver: In some ways, what’s surprised me the most is how long people in the news industry took to come around to the proposition that Trump has left Republicans in a highly perilous position. Talk of a conservative “vibe shift” should probably have died out sooner, especially after Democrats’ strong results in New Jersey and Virginia last year — and after Trump started a war with Iran, which was exactly the sort of conflict that he promised to avoid.

On the individual races side, I’ve been surprised by polls showing Democrats as competitive in South Carolina and — if you believe internal polls, which you probably shouldn’t — even in Louisiana. Those states are typically rather sticky, without a lot of swing voters. It would take a huge turnout differential among Black voters, which would be the reversal of the usual pattern in midterms. I’m not sure I buy it, although there is some evidence for it in the early voting data.

Mangu-Ward: Every election surprises me anew with how little policy actually gets debated. Trade, war and immigration are all signature issues for Trump. A Democratic “tsunami” could make a substantial difference in how those policies play out. But the election seems to be mostly vibes and scandals in its final days. This is partially a consequence of the fact that the G.O.P. is no longer anchored in ideology and Democrats are divided on their ideological commitments.

Guida: Thank you. Enjoy Election Day (and beyond).

Katherine Mangu-Ward is the editor in chief of Reason.

Nate Silver, the founder and former editor of FiveThirtyEight and the author of “On the Edge: The Art of Risking Everything,” writes the newsletter Silver Bulletin. He is a part-time adviser for Polymarket.

The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: [email protected].

Follow the New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.

The post ‘Trump Has Left Republicans in a Highly Perilous Position’: Opinion Writers Assess the Midterms appeared first on New York Times.

Shocking Detail of Trump’s Response to Air Travel Fiasco Revealed
News

Shocking Detail of Trump’s Response to Air Travel Fiasco Revealed

by The Daily Beast
November 16, 2026

A Hollywood heavyweight reportedly questioned Donald Trump’s priorities during America’s aviation emergency after the president called to discuss tax breaks ...

Read more
News

China ‘full stop, is ahead of us’: SpaceX alum building a $13 billion defense startup warns of Beijing’s hypersonic weapons

November 16, 2026
News

Fed Chairman Highlights Economic Uncertainty of A.I. Boom

November 16, 2026
News

DOJ Warns Democratic Senator of ‘Consequences’ Over Trump Investigations—What Can It Actually Do?

November 16, 2026
News

I started a handbag company at 22 and grew it into a fashion sportswear brand with partners like MLB. Here’s what I’ve learned.

November 16, 2026
Are headphones robbing us of the silence required to actually think?

Are headphones robbing us of the silence required to actually think?

November 16, 2026
‘The View’: Alyssa Farah Griffin Says Trump Admin’s Response to Nationwide Flight Grounding ‘Felt Like a Shakedown’

‘The View’: Alyssa Farah Griffin Says Trump Admin’s Response to Nationwide Flight Grounding ‘Felt Like a Shakedown’

November 16, 2026
California sues OpenAI, alleging it endangered public by developing AI without safeguards

California sues OpenAI, alleging it endangered public by developing AI without safeguards

November 16, 2026

DNYUZ © 2026

No Result
View All Result

DNYUZ © 2026