For a country that loves talking about how tough they are, Americans seem surprisingly selective about when they’ll actually throw down. Public life is full of aggression, posturing, and people one bad afternoon away from humiliating themselves in a parking lot, but most adults aren’t out here solving problems with a right hook.
The mythology around fighting still hangs around, especially for men, but real life looks a lot more restrained than the culture likes to admit.
That tracks with a new YouGov survey, which found that 83 percent of U.S. adults say they never get into physical fights. Just 4 percent say it happens at least a few times a year, while 13 percent say it happens rarely. For all the claims about toughness, most Americans seem committed to keeping their conflicts verbal.
Men report fighting at slightly higher rates than women, though the gap is smaller than you’d probably think. YouGov found that 5 percent of men say they get into physical fights at least once a year, compared with 3 percent of women. Even then, large majorities in both groups say they never fight at all, 77 percent of men and 88 percent of women.
Americans Claim to Know a Lot of Violent Americans
People also seem a lot more willing to say fighting happens around them than to them. Thirty-four percent of Americans say people they know get into fights at least occasionally, while 17 percent say they themselves do. That discrepancy feels extremely human. Plenty of people can identify a hothead in their orbit. Fewer want to picture themselves as one. Men were also more likely than women to say they know people who get into fights, 41 percent versus 28 percent.
Childhood, unsurprisingly, was a rougher period. Fifty-eight percent of Americans said they got into physical fights while growing up, including 7 percent who said it happened at least monthly and 13 percent who said a few times a year. Men were much more likely than women to say they fought as kids, 72 percent versus 44 percent. That part feels almost reassuring. A lot of people apparently got their dumbest fight instincts out of the way early.
The survey also asked about a young man being publicly disrespected and then walking away instead of fighting. Nearly half of Americans, 49 percent, said he’d be viewed positively in his community, while only 8 percent said he’d be viewed negatively. Women were slightly more likely than men to see walking away as a good thing.
That may be the most revealing detail here. Americans still romanticize toughness, but when the question gets concrete, a lot of them seem to respect self-control more. The fantasy of fighting still sells. Real life, thankfully, looks a little less committed to the bit.
The post Are Americans as Violent as They Seem? appeared first on VICE.
