A federal judge in San Francisco lit into the Pentagon on Tuesday for its attempt to blacklist Anthropic following a dispute over its AI, rather than simply contracting with a different AI company.
“It looks like an attempt to cripple Anthropic,” Lin, a Biden appointee, said at a hearing on Tuesday to decide whether the “supply chain risk” label can stand while Anthropic’s case against the Department of War goes to trial.
On March 3, Defense Secretary Peter Hegseth formally notified Anthropic that he was labeling the company and its products as a supply chain risk, the first time such a designation had been applied to a US company. The designation is akin to putting Anthropic, the maker of Claude, on a government blacklist, restricting both its contracts and how its technology can be used.
Before the action, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei publicly announced that he would not agree to Hegseth’s demands for the Pentagon to have unfettered access to its AI models “for any lawful use.” Amodei said he was concerned that a contract with that language could allow for misuse in surveilling Americans or lead to Anthropic’s AI being deployed in fully autonomous weapons before it was safe to do so.
Lin, who has handled other high-profile tech cases, said that the decision to formally designate Anthropic as a supply chain risk was a “troubling” given that this designation is normally reserved for “adversaries of the US government who may sabotage its technology systems.”
“DOW could just stop using Claude,” Lin said, using the initials of “The Department of War,” the Trump administration’s preferred name for the Pentagon. “It looks like they went further than that because they were trying to punish Anthropic.”
Anthropic sued to both temporarily and permanently block Hegseth’s action and President Donald Trump‘s separate order that all federal agencies cease using Anthropic’s technology within six months. In legal filings, Anthropic said the designation was “jeopardizing hundreds of millions of dollars in the near-term” because of the uncertainty around what it meant for defense contractors that also use Claude.
“On top of those immediate economic harms, Anthropic’s reputation and core First Amendment freedoms are under attack,” the AI startup’s lawyers wrote in their complaint.
Silicon Valley is closely watching the case because a broad interpretation of the Pentagon’s restrictions could ripple out to partners like Microsoft, which filed an amicus brief supporting Anthropic. As a government contractor, Microsoft could be forced to limit how it uses Anthropic’s Claude.
More broadly, the case will test how far the federal government can go in restricting AI vendors through its contracting and national security powers.
Read the original article on Business Insider
The post Federal judge says it looks like the Pentagon tried to ‘cripple Anthropic’ appeared first on Business Insider.
